Piatto
| Address: | 22 W Pomfret St, Carlisle, PA 17013, USA |
| Phone: | +1 717-249-9580 |
| Site: | piatto.com |
| Rating: | 4.1 |
| Working: | 4–10PM 4–10PM 4–10PM 4–10PM 4–10PM 4–10PM 4–10PM |
Location
Photos 24
Reviews 33
RA
Ray Morgan
My wife and I were very concerned about some of the reviews posted on Piatto. We have been dining here since it was a BYOB establishment as we passed through on I-81. We decided to give it a try again since we were traveling through from the Finger Lakes. Dinner was exactly what we wanted - simple, fresh Italian food cooked perfectly with great service (although it was not crowded on a Tuesday evening after Memorial Day). Although you now have to pay for bread, it came out hot and a perfect size for two. A split salad (basil, mozzarella, and tomato) and an entree each were all we needed, leaving no room for their wonderful desserts. Best of all, their Italian wines by the 500 ml carafe were perfect for the two of us before hitting the road south. We will return...
BR
BRANDON S
Ive been to this restaurant several times and it had been better in the past. when you go to an expensive Italian restaurant I would expect at least receive a roll and maybe some olive oil or butter while youre waiting for your food. They had in the past given breadsticks with your meal now they charge you for bread. The chicken that I ordered was Bland and the steak that my wife had adequately cooked was nothing special and Ive had better steaks in the local Diner. The only vegetable that came with my chicken was one slice of an artichoke heart. In short there was nothing there that would make me want to come back. While the food was not terrible I would be hard-pressed to say that it was good.
DA
DandJ R
What a find! We were traveling x-country, stopped in Carlisle for dinner, found this on our smartphone. Nice ambiance, good wines (we liked the Salice Salentino and the Barbera, generous by the glass), good appetizer (grilled sardines). Good entrees: chicken with prosciutto and sage, Spaghetti alla Putanesca. We even went for dessert, a great tiramisu (the real thing, not frozen for umpteen days). And the waitstaff were friendly. * Perfect* (PS: if you find yourself in Kanab near the Utah-Arizona border, try the Rocking V Cafe)
A
A Private User
Lived in Carlisle for 5 years and never tried it. Finally had the opportunity to give this one a go last weekend, after the crazy October snow storm. I must say it was outstanding. Hunter (our server) was very well versed on the menu items. The food was cooked perfectly, and the large selection of wine was welcoming as well. We sat in the window lined room, overlooking the outdoor seating area. It was very tranquil, and serene. I will be back. Cost is high but well worth the atmosphere.
SU
Suzanne Taylor
Piatto is one of my favorites in Carlisle! I just moved here not long ago and have been trying many nearby restaurants, and this place is charming! The food is delicious and seems more authentic to me than many other Italian places Ive been to. The building itself is adorable, with cute and cozy feel, complete with a quaint outside dining option. The waitstaff is also wonderful. I highly recommend this place!
MA
mambo curto
We felt like we were ripped off because of their pricing policies. You can order an entree but get nothing else with it unless u pay extra. Vegetable sides are extra, including any pasta. Even Bread and butter are extra, not to mention that whatever item we ordered it was served with MICOSCOPIC portions. Stay away from this place unless you have an urge to feel like getting screwed on the bill.
CO
Cody Oelkers
The ambience is nice and I like the outdoor seating. The service was accommodating. I felt that the portion sizes were stingy. A half order is less than I would expect to be served to a child. I was surprised that customers pay for bread. After tasting four meals there, I continue to find them to be surprisingly bland.
BI
Bill Ross
Well attended. Located in a Historic sector of Carlisle. The entire menu has awesome selections to satisfy any taste buds. Servings are not huge where you roll.lut over stuffed! Matt is a great server, knowledgeable, caring and kind. When summer months come Ill try their quaint outdoor seating.
MA
Mark Aldrich
In Carlisle this is simply the best place to eat. Dont fail to order the lamb chops! Go Ross and Team!! Its all great at Piatto and the atmosphere is cooool. Oh, and the desserts? Make sure to leave some room! Really, this is a top quality place and the pricing is quite reasonable.
A
A Private User
Small portions. Bread and salad were ala carte. Server made a sugestion on a beer, no prices on menu. Shocked to see that the bottle of beer was $20.00 when we got the bill. Who would of thought a beer would cost that much. We left feeling ripped off. We wont go back.
AN
Andrew Bayer
was one of the worst meals Ive had in a long time.the bartender wasthe best part of the meal.the saltambucca was the smallest and over seasoned w/sage??my dinner came out in less than 5min.faster than burger king ,idont go to burger king but I wish I had.
JA
Jason Haring
Dined at Piatto last evening for the first time. I absolutely loved the eggplant. Their baked stuffed eggplant was the best Ive ever had. Love the food and the building! A must for dinner the next time you visit Carlisle, Pa.
A
A Private User
Whats used to be the best restaurant in town is no longer. Our dishes were not what one can expect from such a restaurant. So sad, but evidently it is an end of an era. We are definitely NOT returning.
KI
Kimberly Sheppard
A lovely restaurant with delicious food and awesome service. The cocktails were fantastic, and the ambiance was great. Would definitely go again.
A
A Private User
Loved the atmosphere, food & wine! Really good service as well. We went for gelatin around the corner after which was to die for!
A
A Private User
Overcooked small portions, slow service and expensive wine list ruin a great ambience. Expensive and not good value.
SA
Sarah Taby
One of our favorite places to get a proper drink. The atmosphere is lovely and the staff is top notch!
JA
james beach
A Lovely, historic Italian restaurant in am intimate setting. The food are service are top notch
JA
James Prewitt
Great Italian food. The service was attentive and quick. I would come back here in a second.
CH
Christopher Kimball
The food was amazing! Small portions buy if your hanging all the courses its all you need.
KA
Kajivar Jones
Great Italian food. Menu changes seasonally so theres always something new to try.
BR
Brian Cook
Best Italian food in three surrounding Counties! Carlisles best without a doubt!
JE
Jerry Brace
Overpriced with average food. Bread, vegetables, potatoes are all extra cost!
JI
Jim Miller
Good food but a could get more food for your money. The food taste awesome
BR
Bryant Cerrelli
Skilled staff here. Great food, wonderful and knowledgeable service.
ER
Erik F
Best cocktails in Carlisle and many other places in the area
RY
Ryan Loreno
Amazing food and atmosphere, reasonable price.
DA
Daphany Prewitt
Very attentive wait staff & great Italian food
JE
Jean Jones
Cozy with good food. A tad pricey perhaps
RO
robert maslanka
Pasta with sun dried tomato and pesto. YUM
JU
Julie Horter
Wonderful and enthusiastic wait staff.
PA
Paul Haut
Good food good service
TO
Toody Silvis
Good food
