Bottoms Up Restaurant and Pub
| Address: | 1965 NY-284, Slate Hill, NY 10973, USA |
| Phone: | +1 845-355-2886 |
| Site: | bottomsuppub.com |
| Rating: | 4.3 |
| Working: | Closed 11:30AM–9PM 11:30AM–9PM 11:30AM–9PM 11:30AM–10PM 5–10PM 2–8PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 38
JE
Jean-Paul Parnizari
So-so. Hostess was rude and ignored my request to sit outside three times. Then, didnt flag our server that we were sitting out there and thus we waited 15 minutes to be greeted. I know this place is beloved in the community, a community in which I live in but the hostess was so bad that she put the whole experience in a bad light. Sever and her support staff were good. Drinks were too strong but were fixed. Food was okay. Wont be back based on the hostess and her lack of hospitality. You never get a second chance to make a first impression.
ST
Steve Hamel
We had a delightful meal Saturday April 30th, 2016. Unfortunately, the hostess needs to be instructed in the appropriate use of fragrance. It was so overpowering that our party of 3 could taste it each time she entered the dining area causing a profoundly negative effect on our dining experience. While we understand that you cannot control your patrons use of fragrance, its use by the staff can and should be controlled or eliminated. Thank you. Steve Hamel
DE
Debbie Shanahan
While food was delicious, restaurant cant handle large tables. We had a reservation for 7:30, were not seated until 8:20 and didnt get appetizers until 9:30 - unacceptable. We complained to Donna who was in charge, she was rude and Curt. Staff are friendly but seem to cater to locals and regular patrons. We had a much better experience with a smaller table last month.
DO
Doug Coddington
Nice place but we werent impressed with some of the food. I ordered chicken parmesan. The tomato sauce was runny. Im not a fussy eater but when I get a Marinara sauce I want it thick enough to stick to the noodles. This sauce ran into a puddle on side of plate. In our 47 years of marriage my wife has NEVER sent a dish back to the kitchen but she did send hers back.
RA
Rachel S
This was the first time at this restaurant and it was definitely a good one. The atmosphere was cozy and I loved the odd layout of the dining room. The food was really good with large portions, our waitress was really busy so it took her a little over long to notice things like when we needed drink refills. Overall it was a really nice evening!
A
A Private User
Absolutely disgusted with owners actions . One of the best chefs in the area was fired because he cooked better then him , his reason was because he was late after his dog was mangled by a car . I know I was the vet . You made a mistake and then hiring a illegal Mexican for half the pay you should be ashamed he has s kid on the way .
KE
Keith Dye
Food was fine, service was good, but for $120 for two the seating was poor. Sat at a tiny little table with not enough room for our appetizer and dinner at the same time. Had to put my phone and glasses on the window ledge so we would have room for our dinner. Not the way I planned our anniversary dinner to go.
PA
Paul Evans
The wife owner is rude and horrible a very select menu on a Saturday cause they are to busy to cook ribs or a steak sandwich will never eat here again ever we ordered 3 big meals and ribs and a steak sandwich guess it was to small of an order I highly un recommend it
RI
Richard Stephenson
We stopped just to have a beer, but will definitely be back to eat. The staff was very nice, the place is sort of cozy, but not uncomfortable. The plates looked great, and were at reasonable prices.
AD
Adrian Dominguez
I ate lunch here a couple of times and everytime I tried a different lunch special and every meal was delicious. The staff is amazing and have treated me very good since day one.
MA
Matthew corino
One of Orange counties best restaurants. Try the short ribs. We have eaten here many times and everything on the menu is good. Always busy so the locals know its great.
JU
Julie Musial
The food is always superbly made. The wait staff is very courteous & friendly. Upscale dining with very reasonable pricing. Always a great meal & a good time. 5+ stars
CO
corinne copeland
Have eaten here many times. Always happy with the menu weather for lunch or dinner. Staff are pleasant and always try to make dining experience a great one.
SU
Sue Baumgartner
our first visit... very good! Serves was wonderful, Amy was our server... food tasted fresh, cooked well, temperature perfect and serving size just right!
MI
Michael Caggiano
Nice place with good drinks but the food was disappointing... Its was just okay. Everything with drenched in a sauce, overpowered the main ingredient.
RO
Rody Rosaly
Went there last night for dinner. Restaurant is very clean, food and drinks were great. Highly recommend. Definitely worth the trip. Will go again.
MA
Manuel Med
Had an amazing steak here. In fact every time I come here Ive had nothing bad. Good service and quaint inside makes this a favorite with the wife.
JE
jenny frasier
Been coming here for the last 3 years. Love this place! The food is always amazing! Never had a bad meal! Ask for Kathy, shell take care of you!
BR
Brian Leggio
Ive been here many times and the food is great and always fresh. The staff is always pleasant. I highly recommend this restaurant to everyone
JO
Joe Barberio
Food is always great service always on point the owners or great always make a point to say hi&more our favorite restaurant Joe & Sheila b
NA
Nazan Aykent
I would definitely give food 5 stars but tonight on my birthday they also had a big party and food came out really slow for us.
SA
sarah lavine
Food was delicious, had the steak Nicholas. Cooked perfectly and the potato cake hit the spot!
JO
Joe Randazzo
I always enjoy the food here. Especially the specials. Something different then the norm.
JA
Jake Lazier
My wife and I have been here a few times and ever time is always amazing.
AN
Andrew Blake
Service was a little off tonight but the food is always amazing
JO
Joe Stampfel
Great ..pricey but the food makes up for it...love this place
JI
Jim Kata
always a great meal...our go to guaranteed place for dinner..
BR
Brian Dauch
Nice people that hostess Jessica is absolutely amazing.
JE
Jeff Heldman
Very nice staff and good food. Plenty of space inside.
JU
Julie Musial
Delicious food, nice atmosphere & friendly service.
JE
Jeff Hutchinson
Nice atmosphere, good food, reasonably priced.
NI
Nicole Saunders
Crab-lobster cakes were so delicious!
MI
Michelle OKeefe
Never disappointed. A local fave :)
CH
Chris C
Food is outstanding. Service sucks!
JO
Joe McMahon
Excellent menu, food, service
DA
Daniel Hubbard
Great food great service
JA
jason plummer
Great food, pricey
J
J Brown Sell
Good food!
