Buffalo Bills Barbecue

416 Sicklerville Rd # 9, Sicklerville, NJ 08081, USA

Address:	416 Sicklerville Rd # 9, Sicklerville, NJ 08081, USA
Phone:	+1 856-875-6000
Site:	buffalobillsbarbecue.com
Rating:	3.8
Working:	11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–9:30PM

Location

Photos 62

Reviews 19

A Private User

They have the best wings around and I cant complain about their other food either! Weve ordered from them quite often over the years but will no longer do so after ordering wings for the Eagles game this past week. I ordered 35 wings which are on the menu for $21, I was charged over $30 and tipped the delivery guy a few bucks. First issue, the wings were $5.25 more because of "market increases" and I was not told this by the girl who took my order. Second, I was charged $1.89 for 1 bleu cheese, when the menu says youll be charged for "extra bleu cheese or ranch." Third, I called and spoke to the owner, Scott, calmly explaining the situation but he didnt seem to care. He said that the people taking orders should tell everyone about the price difference but sometimes they forget and that unfortunately they forgot to tell me. I was just looking for a $5 credit which I thought to be a fair compromise. I was told that I would not get my money back, I would not be given a credit for my next order, I shouldve refused the wings, or that I should order somewhere else. I had people over so I wasnt going to argue with a delivery guy who just wants to get back and run his next order and I never thought to refuse the wings. I thought itd be smarter to call later to speak with management. Im not sure if Scott woke up on the wrong side of the bed or the Grinch ruined his Christmas but Ive worked in retail management for years and run my own business and have NEVER responded to a customer in the way that he did to me! Needless to say I will not be ordering from them again!

Donnie Moreno

Small BBQ place in a strip center mainly used for take out. The menu was huge between BBQ, burgers/wraps, soup with quite a few sides. Our BBQ platters of ribs and chicken came with two sides for a pretty cheap price of $12 and $13 each. The sweet sauce was pretty good but it smothered the chicken and ribs (not my preference) and the meats themselves were quite good. This is one of the very few places Ive found in Jersey/Philly that actually had dirty rice and it was easily my favorite food item today. The Collard greens were ok but needed some seasoning besides the salt and pepper given to us. The sweet tea was on point. The young lady that took and orders was nice and it took maybe 20 minutes to get the food but they were pretty busy with the take out orders being placed. The inside had a few tables and a very loud TV so just plan on a take out order being the best bet. The three stars were mainly for the atmosphere, smothered BBQ and unseasoned collard greens. We will be back when we are in the area but its not something we will go out of our way to visit.

Will Merger

We order from here all the time. The service keeps getting worse and its sad. The food is usually good but this last episode just really aggravated me. We waited an extra 10 minutes longer than they gave us to go pickup the order. When we got there we waited another 25+ minutes for the order. I can see maybe 10 minutes but 25 or more is just ridiculous especially considering we waited an extra 10 minutes longer than they said that it would be ready before stopping there. The most aggravating part is there was absolutely no apology for the wait. Just like it was business as usual. Left a very bad taste in my mouth. Expect to wait a long time for your food without an apology for it. No respect for peoples time.

Imogene Reddick

I will never support Buffalo Bills Barbecue, again, this make the second time I went there to purchase my order, with a Debtor Visa card, that come directly out my account , they ask me for IDI I explain to them I left my ID home just I just rush out the door visa Debtor Card only... she look at me like so.. no ID no food. my food was sitting just sitting there ready... on the counter top. I told them keep the food. I will not go all the way home just for ID. to purchase my food. I will never.... support them again besides Adelphia food tastes better anyway and plus cheaper for wings ..Adelphia have thumb up.....

Michael Cohen

Old fatty meat... Attempt to drown meat in sauce to cover and hide poor quality of meat....Stale chicken wings that tasted old... Worst Ive ever ordered from... To the owners...go to reading terminal in Philly...order from the Amish Market..taste and compare their wings to your own.... You will understand what its like to eat your ribs.... My 5th attempt at you foo d ,was my last. When I moved here.. Everyone warned me against you place...I should have listened.

Rosy Amaya

The food here is fantastic! My boyfriend brought me here for the first time a week ago raving about the Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak. I was a skeptic, figuring his opinion was bias on account that his family has been bringing him here since he was a child. They blew my mind! Id highly recommend the cheesesteak mentioned above, Garlic Parmesan Fries, Homemade Chili, and Buffalo Wings. I plan on making this a weekly stop

David Dellavalle

Called 25 mins before they closed and instead of telling me Im sorry we are about to close soon we are not taking anymore orders the woman told me one moment and made me wait on the phone for ten minutes and then it was busy everytime I tried to call back. That will be the last time i order there again

Brian Biggs

I did see on the news that all wing prices across the US have gone up do to a shortage of wings in the US.... Maybe thats why they went up on the price.. I have seen wing prices go up everywhere the last six months........I love the garlic parm sauce..

Tiana Terilla

First of all I asked for chicken with no bbq sauce. I also asked for candied yams and macaroni salad.... I got bbq sauce on my chicken AND no macaroni salad. On top of that the candied yams were straight trash. My first time and last time here.

Ray Kennedy

Disregard the negative reviews. Buffalo Bills has been a staple for BBQ in the Sicklerville area for years. People will always find something to complain about. Ive eaten the food here many many many times and its been delicious every time.

Christian Davidson

First time there and they had great food. Cheesesteak was one of the best in the area. BBQ pork sandwich was also good. Garlic parmesan fries are amazing and baked beans were on point. Would definitely go back.

Bob Howe

Stopped here because of a Groupon deal. The BBQ chicken was very good, and the sides were good. The ribs werent bad but at least today they were a bit fatty with an "old meat" taste. Not sure Ill be back.

tosha reddick

loooooooooooooveeeeeeee it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!............Habenero wing queen!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

A Private User

this place is pretty good, dont mind the lunatic above crying over 5 dollars. very unnecessary.

Ralph Henderson

Food is pretty good if you need to eat BBQ. They have some really good selections.

Savage C

Very friendly staff and I love their Chicken tenders and fries.

Rhonda Venuto

Ribs are good. Staff was nice. Ate on site...not so nice

Sam Carter

cheesesteaks are banging. Nice an Juicy and what not.