Red Pepperoni
| Address: | 842 W Main St, Madison, IN 47250, USA |
| Phone: | +1 812-274-0111 |
| Site: | theredpepperoni.com |
| Rating: | 4.7 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 30
MR
Mr. Wiley
First time here - we were told the pizza dough is never frozen, the bread sticks are hand rolled! We ordered the MacDaddy pizza large $14.99 The crust was a bit under cooked, it was thin and the crust couldnt hold the toppings well. They would fall off when dishing to the plate. The pizza was greasy... but tasted okay. Im not blown away. The bathroom was clean, the restaurant was packed when we came in. Good place overall. They could dish the first piece of pizza but they dont. April was our server - she was good.
LU
lucas gibbs
Please dont waste your time. Me and my girlfriend came in and sat down waited 10 minutes for them to ask us for a drink and ordered our food. Then we waited another 20 minutes just to get breadsticks. Next we waited 15 minutes for our food. We told them we havent received our food yet and they didnt even make us a priority. They just didnt care we saw other people that came in way after we did get their food before we did. Dont waste your money, or time.
CH
Chris Roswog
Me and I friend stopped for a late lunch in the afternoon around 3. The place wasnt busy but that was good because we wanted a quiet meal. We had the cheesy bread and calzones, both were great. This building is an old service station but has cleaned up nicely to become a great pizza place with what looked like a great beer selection. I thought the prices were more than fair for the quality of the food and the selection. I would recommend it.
AN
Angela Baker
The staff is really great here and the food is pretty good. It wasnt the best weve ever had but still better than others. Place was really clean. The parking is frightful. Horrible parking lot on the corner. You cannot pull out of the lot without pulling out into traffic. The corner they are in is a busy one too. Took us 10 minutes to leave. That is why I gave 4 stars instead of 5.
SA
Sandeep Raja
Best Pizza place around here. Cozy and comfortable, the food is so tasty that you will stuff your face with everything even if you do not have place in your tummy!! Do try this place if you live near by Madison. You will love the ambience and its location just near to the Ohio River makes it perfect to walk off all the delicious food you have eaten at Red Pepperoni. :)
TI
Tia Hiles
We ordered the All American calzone, a pepperoni calzone, a strombolli, chicken BBQ pizza, meat pizza and breadsticks and all were great. We had a group of 16 so we called ahead and they had the table ready and waiting. The service was very quick and all orders correct. The atmosphere is neat due to being in an old gas station/garage. I would highly recommend it!
PH
Phillip Bowlds
Local pizza stop with a wide selection of craft beers. Very good pricing on delicious pizza, subs, calzones, and baked pasta. Known for having the newest and best beers of Indiana in stock, as well as a few highly rated national brews. Sweet iced tea is made right, if that piques your interest more than beer.
IA
Ian Minderman
One of my favorite pizza joints! They have a wide variety of pizzas that are always excellent. Never had a bad experience or meal there. Also, the beer and cider choices are terrific! Nothing on tap but the variety more than makes up for it. I especially appreciate the local choices. Great place!
VI
Vinal Lee
The service here is wonderful and fast, they treat you as if you are family and the food is amazing! I love to take people from out of town here as there is a great selection for everyone. My personal favorite is the Thai Chicken Pizza, this sweet and savory pizza and very unique and very good!
JE
Jennifer Williams
My family visits here on a regular basis! We invite friends and other family members to join us! The pizza!!! We drive from Lagrange, KY and pass more than a dozen pizza places to eat here ♡! Yum, must try the meatball pizza! They also have a ton of craft beer options, and I mean a ton!
AS
Ashley R
We had a 14" buffalo chicken pizza. Tasted great (spicy) and was plenty for my family of four. The waitresses were courteous and welcoming, as it was our first visit. The decor is fun and unique. Service is fast, so a visit here would be ideal especially if youre crunched for time.
PH
Phillip Riley
This is my second trip here. We came out from Clarksville to for an afternoon at Clifty Falls. We got rained it but had out lunch here. I could not recommend this place more. In fact I could see myself coming it for just the Scicillian. Best pizza Ive ever had!
DA
Dad Hunt
Monday, 3 day holiday weekend, ONLY place the locals were suggesting...AND it WAS awesome! Very busy, servers were flying around, beers were poured into chilled glasses, pizza was great, and bathrooms were clean! Go Red Pepperoni!
RE
Retha Neal
First time trying and we will definitely be back! Not from the area, just came to visit the falls and get potato salad from the Red Pepper, now we have another favorite! Kids left very satisfied as well!
RA
Rachel Ringle
Best pizza place I have ever been to in my life amazing service didnt wait for anything food came out fast I am a server myself and understand the resturant business 5 stars all around!!!!
JA
Jared Martin
Really good pizza at a great value. They also carry many craft beers that are also priced very reasonably. Outdoor seating and a great motorcycle destination. We love going here.
VI
Victor Pallotto
Its the best pizza you will find in the area...Im from the east coast and it is almost compraible to home...but I gave 4 stars for the red sause, just not quite there yet...
MI
Mitzi Walburn
Thank you John and Lori for your wonderful food and consistent quality at all of the "Reds"! Dinner from here last night and lunch today!! Yum! The service is exceptional!
RA
Rachael
Great for the whole family! Cheese pizza for the kids, lots of unique pizza for us, and an extensive beer list for the hubs! We really enjoyed the BBQ pizza and Korean.
DE
Deborah Boston
Fantastic - my husband and I love sharing the Italiano salad and 10 inch gluten free pizza! Delicious. Servers are friendly, a great place to eat!
EL
Eli Howard
Good service and nice pizza. At first you dont notice just how cool the floor is. If you go here just look at it for a minute, its neat.
JE
Jeff Kinman
They have absolutely wonderful pizza. Their pizzas taste very fresh and have unique specialty pizzas, as well building your own.
JA
Jason Long
Great place with great pizza. Only down side is the amount of space, so it does fill up really easy. We always enjoy going there.
RO
Robert Waller
Love the MacDaddy Pizza. Always a great select of craft beers. A place where friends hangout, to enjoy a meal, and catch up.
MO
Monica Fuerte
The food was delicious. Everything came out quick. Has a good atmosphere and the waitress was nice. Had a great experience.
BR
Brandon Wilch
Good little pizzeria. The staff was very friendly, the food was good and the price was right for both. Well worth visiting.
PA
Patrick Overholt
A really good pizza joint. Try the spinach artichoke pizza. Tip - if you get a medium you can get half and half!
MA
Matthew Mourning
Awesome beer, service, AND PIZZA! Also ordered bread sticks and garden salad. The house made ranch was great.
KE
kelly lee
Delicious food, Sunday specials, excellent beer selection! Will definitely visit again in the future!
AL
Allen Shuler
Very cool place ! Best pizzaria around with craft beers! On Sunday $12 large specialty pizza!
