Frostys Bar
| Address: | 252 Delaware Ave, Put-In-Bay, OH 43456, USA |
| Phone: | +1 419-285-4741 |
| Site: | frostys.com |
| Rating: | 4.3 |
| Working: | 11AM–7PM 11AM–7PM 11AM–7PM 11AM–7PM 11AM–7PM 11AM–7PM 11AM–7PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 63
PR
Price K
Where to begin. First server could barely understand me and vice versa. Got my pizza and breadsticks back to room and had to use paper towels to soak up butter and grease from breadsticks. They were dripping. My daughter, while sponging off her breadstick, asked me what a spot was, thinking it was burned. I looked atit and discovered it was green mold! Oh my god how gross! We took that nasty sh** right back. My husband talked to the manager behind the bar and discovered how filthy the floor and everything is. I guess a bunch of drunks dont know or care that they eat mold but I DO! the health dept will be contacted.
A
A Private User
This place has amazing pizza at anytime of day or not. I suggest ordering if your a hungary fisherman ... cruise in drop a buddy off on the island, have him pick it up and hop back on the boat to continue fishing or grab a pie before hoping the jet back to mainland at 2 am drunk ... best pizza around .... Cheezy Saucey and All around amazing ...
JO
jostr s
If youre not into the night life, this is still a great place to go to for breakfast. I think its the best breakfast in town. there is a server there named Derek. if you need info on any thing going on in Put In Bay, just ask him. He has been here for a long time and he will take the time to share his knowledge with you.
KA
Karrie Piotrowski
We ate breakfast on a Sunday. We were seated quicky and our waitress was great. Our food was done fast and everything was good. Bought a couple shirts and the man selling those was helpful about showing us the shirts and helping to find a size. Always a good spot to stop.
PO
Pon Tsou
The employees here are rude and unethical. On two separate occasion I was charged different prices. When I noted this to the waitress she responded as I was wrong, though other patrons agreed. This is not how you run an establishment nor treat customers.
HI
Hi its Kyle
Do not eat at big mans burito stand. They do not use gloves at this sub par chipotle ripoff. Food is bland and flavorless. Waste of money besides the shear volume of food. Server hardly understood english or anything about what he was serving.
TI
Tim Mikolajczyk
Never know who youll meet at a place like Frostys. Was there just an hour and ran into four people I havent seen in years. What a great experience. A place you must go to when youre at the bay..!
DA
Daniel Haller
A Put In Bay classic. Great place to grab a cold beer, eat pizza and do some people watching. Great breakfast spot too. Family friendly until after dinner Friday and Saturday night.
BL
Blake Humphries
Visited this place a while back, and if memory serves me right they have a breakfast burrito bar in the back (open till 12pm). The burritos are stuffed full, massive and delicious.
DE
Deb Tussing
Was not a good time. The people who were with me felt like the staff was making fun of them. The food was very expensive for self serve. I definitely will not be going back.
MA
Mandy Forshey
The staff that we encountered on our trip this time at Frostys was great. They were very patient with her family, and very helpful. The food is pretty tasty too.
DA
David Gilbert
Have been coming here since 1969. Best Pizza around. Remember the pizza painting being done in 1970. Anyone remember the 4th of July storm in 69??
CH
Chris Meyer
Pizza is overpriced and isnt very good for what you pay for. There is definitely better pizza on the island (practically next door) for far less.
PA
Paula Halbach
I"ve been going here for years. If you love pizza and subs this is a great place to be. Dont forget to visit the backyard bar, its fabulous
ER
Eric H
Love it...we have a place on Catawba Island and love coming to PIB and esp Frostys. Be sure to get the pizza, it will not disappoont!!
AN
Andrew Barhorst
Cannot beat frostys. Great place for late night pizza or beers. They are great for a place to have fun and drink some good beers.
CR
Craig Bauman
Its a long bar, it once held some Guinness world record, but not since 1996 I think. Some party life here at night. White people.
RO
Rob Croft
Great Place. Breakfast is out of the world. Pizza was ok. Be sure to have a Bloody Mary. Frostys is a must in Put in Bay!!
MI
Michelle Theriot
Relaxed atmosphere...food is okay....chairs could be more comfortable....Large screens are great for watching sport events.
AU
Audrey Heffner
Pretty good drinks and the food wasnt too bad either. They use fresh ingredients in their frozen drinks which was awesome.
HA
Hangman Delta
Absolutely fantastic pizza. A little on the pricey side, but still a highly recommended stop for any Put-in-Bay adventure.
MI
Michael Cherwinski
You can be served breakfast on one side of the bar but not the other, But they can serve you lunch on either side
RO
Rosemarie Marfisi
Great food some of our group said there might have been too much cheese on the pizza but as for me I love cheese.
RU
Run-A-Way Bill
South Bass Island (Putin Bay), Ohio --- The "Frosty Bar" since 1949 is a good choice to start Day 36? (i forgot
KE
KELLI DAVIS
Great visit for our family, great family value too. A bit loud due to acoustics, but worth a visit for sure.
RO
Roger Courtney
Amazing Pizza, good beer, and the staff was friendly. They should consider delivery to the main land!!!
A
A Private User
Great place for a cold one and a pizza! Little pricey, but your in PIB... so it should be expected!
DU
Dustin Kilpatrick
Great place good atmosphere good food good drinks good place to stop on the Put-in-Bay Bar Crawl
AN
Andy Parsons
Went here many times over two day. Good drinks and food. Love the burrito place in the back too
CH
Christie Wielgopolski
Great breakfast at a super price. Bloody Marys and Perrys Punch are highly recommended.
TA
Tash Bloo
Good family deal nice environment kid friendly a good deal on this island for your money
DA
David Stone
Amazing pizza and surprising filling for the size. Kinda pricey tho but worth it imo.
JO
Joseph Sinner
Pizza was amazing, triple pepperoni, yum. Loved the frosty mug beer. Tons of fun...
HA
Harry Poorman
Great atmosphere and friendly staff. Had breakfast here and it was really good.
DA
David Shimm
Best pizza in the area with a frosty mug to go along. You always leave happy.
BA
Barbara Wahl
Great Pizza, and bar attached. Good atmosphere, laid back and music too
JD
Jd
Expensive but meets the need and is always good for that frosty drink.
JA
Jamie Frank
Awesome place....always enjoy stopping at Frostys for a cold brew
SA
Sarah Dane
Great options! Kindly put up with 5 adults and 6 children at once.
BO
Bob Tom
Run of the mill. Service was good but the food and decor were meh.
PA
Paul Kruse
Love the bloody marys and breakfast here. Usually a wait though.
DA
David Bleke
Nice patio out back with frozen adult drinks. Good Pizza.
HE
Henry Matthews
Excellent friendly staff great food awesome place to eat
LA
Laura Watson
Fun, even on a random Monday night! Plus, great pizza.
JE
Jen Wood
Best breakfast and bloody Marys on the island
NI
Nita Smith
Has always been the worlds best pizza!!!!!!!!
JA
Jason Cottrell
Best stop for some put in bay pizza.! Its yum
DA
David Smittle
Good food, nice people, relaxed atmosphere.
JU
Justin Matus
A little pricey. But have gluten free pizza
MA
Marty Qualls
Great bar atmosphere with delicious pizza.
MA
Matt Young
Pizza, beer, Bloody Marys - Its all good.
JE
Jeffrey Jahnsz
Loud. Touristy. Pizza is D D D delicious.
AL
Alex Milliron
Great breakfast! Kind & courteous staff.
OT
Otis DuPont
Darn good Brunch and drinks had here.
LI
lisa kaneen
Great atmosphere delicious pizza.
AN
Anne Leidigh
Great selection of beer and food
ME
Melissa Reynolds
The Turkey Sub bread was awesome!
JE
Jeff Hrdlicka
Great views and a lively crowd.
CH
Cheryl Bieyl
Awesome breakfast, best coffee!!
JO
Jodi Wheeler
Great breakfast Bloody Marys!
LI
Lisa Pryor
Great fun, nice staff, clean
JO
johnzell wilson
Nice place to go for food.
BR
Brian
Best pizza on the islands
