Caked Up Cafe
| Address: | 40 S Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA |
| Phone: | +1 845-499-2929 |
| Site: | cakedupcafe.com |
| Rating: | 4.8 |
| Working: | Closed 10AM–6PM 10AM–6PM 10AM–6PM 10AM–6PM 10AM–6PM 10AM–3PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 12
JO
Joanna Caccavo
Absolutely delicious cupcakes and wonderful staff. Caked Ups cupcakes are as delicious as they look. They are beautifully-constructed, and thus could easily function as an alternative to a standard birthday cake. Unlike so many clever cupcake flavors, these do not disappoint. The chocolate chip cookie dough cupcake, for example, is better than any chocolate chip cookie Ive ever eaten! The fundamental quality of a cupcake, in my humble opinion, lies not just in the overall flavor but also the texture of the cake and frosting and of the proportion of cake to frosting. These cupcakes have a moist, fluffy crumb - not too delicate, yet not quite as dense as a standard cake. The buttercream is buttery and creamy with a hint of sugar crystals. There is, perhaps, more frosting than cake (the cupcakes are all, I believe, filled), but its difficult for me to judge, as I generally like more cake than frosting, unlike most people. In summation, Caked Up obviously cares about the quality of their products, and not just how pretty they look. As the daughter of a former baker, I have always been picky about the baked goods I eat. I am delighted to have discovered Caked Up and only wish I had done so earlier!
DI
Diane Hettrick
I called very late this past week (Wednesday) to order a cake I needed for Sunday...for a Bridal Shower. Although Denise informed me she was pretty booked for a lot of cakes but asked me to check out photos of Naked Cakes online and see if that would work. I thought they were unique and beautiful and told her I would love one of those. Denise and her staff made me the best cake ever for my future daughter in law. Not only was it gorgeous to look at with fresh real roses adorning it - it was absolutely delicious with butter cream filling between each lawyer filled with strawberries and blueberries. Denise and her staff go above and beyond and I will make sure I use them for every and all upcoming events. I recommend them highly and cant thank them enough for making this shower so special for a very special lady. THANK YOU.
AL
Aly Cat
These are literally THE BEST cupcakes out there! Ive tried many of the other "famous" cupcake spots, from New York to D.C... And these are the most moist, tasty, and creative cupcakes with delicious, creamy frosting flavors to match each unique ensemble. There is just the right balance between cupcake and frosting... so you can enjoy your treat without feeling sick afterward! In fact, you might want to have another!
CH
Christopher Jordan
Caked Up is very Allergy Friendly, they use separate prep area and clean equipment to make allergy free cakes. They have been able to make me multiple custom cakes using a non-dairy margarine to make delicious butter cream frosting. All their cakes are great, but the chocolate peanut butter cake they made me might be the best cake Ive ever had. Definitely recommend!
E
E F
Always top notch and they always have new products. On top of that, they have a friendly staff. Went there once on a Sunday without knowing they close early, but the staff was nice of enough to offer to let me come in. There are many reasons why celebs and members of the media have featured them; their desserts are delicious and are presented well.
ST
Steven Octaviano
Top notch all the way. Always a pleasure to stop in and find out what new cupcake flavors are available. The maple bacon cupcake is to DIE FOR, and they are ALL as delicious as they are beautiful. Finally placing my first custom cake order and cannot wait to see and taste it! DO cake yourself up at Caked Up!!! You wont regret it!!!
CH
Christopher Markowski
If you are debating whether or not to stop in, or to order a cake for an event... stop, do it - youve found your bakery. I had a sweet tooth while driving through the area for work and decided on a whim to try it. The maple bacon pancake cupcake caught my eye. I devoured it. Best cupcake Ive ever had.
EL
Elizabeth Parks
Although we have enjoyed the cupcakes in the past apparently they are too famous and busy to respond to inquiries
GE
Gerald Gatto
Been here multiple times and they are always courteous and the cupcakes always look and taste delicious
CH
Chris Brophy
Best Damn cupcakes and parfaits
EL
Ely Liberov
Great spot, so happy to see this opened in New City. anything > starbucks. but Caked Up is good
PE
Peter Milman
What a gem!!
