Mystic Island Pizza
| Address: | 841 Radio Rd, Little Egg Harbor Township, NJ 08087, USA |
| Phone: | +1 609-296-0257 |
| Site: | mysticislandpizza.com |
| Rating: | 4.1 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM Closed 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM |
Location
Photos 92
Reviews 38
A
A Private User
Well it seems like attacking me for reporting exactly what happened with my experience at Mystic Island Pizza is more important to some people. Sounds like an employee that works there trying to save face. I do not need to defend myself to an employee, how about you spend more time cleaning that COCKROACH infested pizza place. There must be so many that you cannot seem to pick them all out of the food before cooking it. I was refunded my money after several demands to the mean and nasty lady that answered the phone. The delivery driver that came back to my residence even saw the LARGE COCKROACH and said, " that must have flown in there and no one saw it". Sounds like this is common practice to pick out the COCKROACHS before baking. How dare you come on and try to put me down for my review, I am very educated and successful, maybe you do not mind COCKROACHS in your food BUT I most certainly do!!
A
A Private User
The hateful tone of the previous writer leads me to belive this was written by a female who is not yet out of high school. My experinces over a 10 year period have been superb. This is a family run business that goes out of its way to to provide a clean eating atmosphere and superb food. "I feel so violated"..... " They are dirty n nasty....." "Do not order there" "They should be should be shut down" "I hope they go out of business" Stick to Dominos....plastic cheese and all. Hope you get earn that GED
A
A Private User
This pizza has got to be the worst I ever tasted. I went there because I live around the corner and was too lazy to run to Naples, boy was I sorry. Me and my girlfreind both also got diarrhea and bad stomach pains. I would steer way clear of this place. The dough I think was just frozen bread dough the sauce had a very sour taste that they tried to cover up with sugar. All in all it was disgusting!!!!
A
A Private User
I was told by a friend to go in and try the food because it was the best in town. I had to try for myself and I must say they werent kidding. Ive eaten at the other places but this was the best. And the people were very friendly. I recommend mystic island pizza to everyone.
A
A Private User
If you like real italian food, this pizzeria is the place. Has a BYOB dining room, nothing fancy. Great for take out. They make nice calimari. Pizzas are great. Dinners taste like homemade sauce from tomatoes not a jar. Family operated, friendly service.
KA
Kaitlyn Gravatt
Someone who we believe was the owner called my niece fat when she was eating pasta there yesterday. DO NOT GIVE THEM BUSINESS. Who calls a 7 year old fat? I wish I could give 0 stars! Learn how to treat customers with respect.
A
A Private User
I agree with the last reviewer. There pizza was good and the restaurant was clean. Very friendly family run business! Try them out, it took me a few years but Im glad I finally did. New customer for life.
PA
pamela hannen
Everytine we come here to eat..my family and i are always so impressed....the food is always fresh and delicious and everyone is always so friendly and make us feel so welcome.... Thank you everybody.....
A
A Private User
I eat at mystic pizza at least twice a week. I have never had a problem with the service or the food. They are reasonably priced and the food is delicious. The girls are also very friendly.
DO
Donald Dunn
My Girl and I have been eating here for years and have always found the food and service to be top notch. Very friendly and very tasty. I recommend to all. Ignore the naysayers.
RA
raymond davis
Ive been eating here for 15 years always good food never any cock roaches and has never made me sick and I dont work there people are always nice friendly even when Im not...
LI
Lindsay Sorg
Love this place. Friendly and great food! I dont go anywhere else for Italian food! I travel for a living and this is by far one of the best places Ive been.
JE
Jennifer Butler
Terrific! !! We are visiting family friendly. Food is amazing. The waitress work together. Definitely a great place to eat .
MI
MIKE WUSS
Food was horrible , had better food out of vending machines, tried this place a few times, so its not just a one time thing.
A
A Private User
The best pizza around!! Prices are a tad high but the food is more than worth it and the people are very friendly!
MI
Michael Owen
Best pizza and service. We love everyone there. Order a slice and the antipasta you wont be disappointed. Yum.
JI
Jitteryship394
I have had there pizza for my life they know me and my father there there the best people
VI
Virge Bon
i love this pizzeria . I have always had the best. Delivery is quick and great.
LE
leyanid rymarenko
Not too bad not too great ... Hot or a miss .. but does hit the wallet a bit
SA
Sarah Burnett
I was at Creative Cuts right next door. Linda, the owner is fabulous!!
MA
Marilyn Dunn
Best Italian in the area. Have been a customer for 17 years.
TE
Teri Giercyk
Sat and ate and the food was hot and fresh and delicious!
KE
Kenn Kazz
Great family owned Italian pizzeria
DA
Daniel Shapiro
Pizza was ok. Good for South Jersey.
CU
Curse Bringer
Wasnt impressed with food...
BA
ballooniecorn
The pizza makes me quiver
MO
Morgan Lane
Chicken Alfredo is garbage
RI
RICHARD LACOVARA
Great food and service...
SA
Sarah Scott
Great old time pizza!!#
KE
Kenn Kaczorowski
Good authentic meals.
BR
Brian Therien
Good food and service
MI
MICHAEL OGDEN
Always very good food
CA
Carl Vallone
Good food, period
RO
Roger Green
Fantastic pizza
BO
Bob Pante
Great pizza
DO
Don Savasta
Great food
MA
Marie Miller-Kowalski
Good pizza
JO
Josh Cosulich
Great food
