Goodfellas Pizza
| Address: | 7288 W Oakland Park Blvd, Sunrise, FL 33313, USA |
| Phone: | +1 954-636-6440 |
| Site: | goodfellasnypizza.com |
| Rating: | 4.4 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 12–9PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 12
BE
benjamin frazier
I ordered for delivery from a hotel. I ordered a pizza and soup. The food was mediocre at best. The service was poor. The person who took my order was pleasant and polite.. but I did get the wrong kind of onions on my pizza "these things happen". The big problems were that I received No napkins, No spoon for the soup or any utensils at all, No cheese, crushed red pepper, salt, or pepper. I was delivered my pizza and my soup.. that was ALL. Worse than that was that when I called back to let them know I was first asked if Id requested these basic items and then told that the boss has given instructions to only give these items upon request. Ive worked in the restaurant business and I Know Better.. Even McDonalds puts napkins, and utensils in the bag without request. PITIFUL AND UNACCEPTABLE! ! Oh yeh, I remind you again that the food itself was mediocre at best
FI
Fire Medic
Reminds me of my first time to New York! The first time I experienced a New York slice was after I stumbled upon some mom and pop pizzeria walking around near the Waldorf Astoria! I do not even think the place had a name! It just said PIZZA! Did I ever hit the jackpot! What I experienced that day was the most incredible slice I have ever eaten, certainly better than any slice in South Florida. Well people, I found the pizza I enjoyed in New York and it is at Goodfellas! I couldnt believe how much it was like the pizza in New York! I had two slices, pepperoni and a cheese, a coke, and a slice of the most amazing lemon creme cake! I was in heaven!! Cant wait to try other items on the menu!!Told the guys I would be back and I meant it! If you get the chance to stop in there and grab a slice, DO IT!! You wont be disappointed!!
JE
Jerry Rocker
Ordered an 18" Pizza last night, the pizza tasted so, so, not great, not terrible......The pizza was 1/2 cheese, 1/2 Hamburger/meatball. My wife ate one slice of the cheese side, was unimpressed and stopped there, I ate three slices of the meatball side.......2 hours later, I was puking my guts up. I havent thrown-up in 20 yrs. The meatball meat didnt taste bad, but something had to be terribly wrong. I ate nothing else with the pizza but a glass of tap water. I cant say for 100% it was anything to do with this pizza, but with all that happened, its hard to point a finger any other way. This morning I still feel ill as food poisoning usually will leave you feeling ill for at least 24 to 48 hrs. Needless to say, I wont be eating from Goodfellas Pizza again.
MI
miguel castellano
Went there just last night night 12/21/16 with my wife we recently moved into the area and decided to give it a chance especially since it had high reviews. I was not disappointed. I will be honest and say I am used to getting fast service that you would get at a Reys pizza for example but I enjoyed the experience. It was my first time seeing a pizza dough being hand tossed and having our pizza made on the spot by hand. The John Gotti pie was delicious. I personally had it with the ranch on the side and didnt really need it. Anyways appetizers,service and pizza were amazing would definitely go again
JE
Jennifer Nelson
I ordered a small house salad and chicken parm sandwich as soon as they opened. The salad looked like slop, the onions and greens were soggy and slimy. When I called to ask JC if the salad was made today, he said yes. I can not believe a salad made and sent out as soon as you opened looked like slop. Also, the chicken parm sandwich left a lot to be desired. Ive ordered from here several times and I have never seen anything like this....you cant take shortcuts with food. Soooo disappointing! JC did refund the salad, when I told him how disappointed I am, he replied "we did our best". WOW!!!
SH
Sharon Reed
As soon as I walked into Goodfellas, I was greeted as though I was known as a regular patron. This was my first visit. The hospitality is very welcoming and appreciated. The Crispy Calamari was delicious. The Garlic Rolls are loaded with garlic and butter and very good and you cant get enough. I especially enjoyed my very Entree :Signature Meatball. The amount of tasty food that they serve you, is enough for 2. A special Thank You to all at Goodfellas, especially Guy and JC. Im a lifetime customer from this day forward.
AL
Alejandrooct Lu
Ive never visited in person. Found them while searching online for gluten free pizza options since every now and then I get tired of making my own pizzas and I need a quick delivery for the fam. So far we have tried a few variations of thier gf pizzas and my family really enjoys them. We have also ordered subs, their regular pizza and their homemade meatballs for some guests and it was a hit. If you order online be prepared to wait about an hour for food to be delivered, make sure you tip your delivery guy and enjoy.
NI
Nicole O.
Pizza was tasty. Spinach artichoke was unappetizing and ended up feeding it to my dogs. Bbq for the wings tasted slathered on on; if you get them ask for light sauce. Delivery driver did not follow delivery instructions not to knock or ring and disrupted the whole house being overly chatty and hyper at the door; started speaking to me loudly in spanish (which I dont speak). He also wrote in a tip line on my receipt in bright blue ink which I thought was tacky. Wont be ordering again based in the service alone.
KE
Kenneth Burke
Woooooooow, I cant say anything but great things about this place . Its clean , looks cool , o and did I mention the food is great . Be ready to go on an empty stomach, as they give you a lot of food at a great price. The girl at the front counter is super cute and was very helpful ,as well as the staff in the back. So no matter if your going solo , taking a date out or want to feed the family, GOODFELLAS PIZZA is the spot to go . Ill definitely will make this my cheat day spot !
JE
Jessy
First of all it took 2 hrs for my delivery to arrive. The food was cold and tasted like it was put in the microwave before it left which left the Chiken Parm sub and fries super stale by the time it arrived. The fries felt like cardboard in my mouth and were extremely SALTY .The chicken parm was burned and almost black. I hope that Goodfellas resturant will read this review and do a better job next time.
JE
Jessica Salts
Im not usually one to give all 5 stars but this place blew my mind. The only downfall was we had to wait an hour for delivery, being pregnant it feels like forever! But it was totally worth it, everything was so delicious and it wasnt cold or like warm it was hot. My husband loved the wings so much he wants to order them again tomorrow! Probably my favorite place in Florida to eat right now!!!
LI
Lilly Lioness
I am not a big Pizza eater but if I eat it must be delicious. I am a Big Critic because I lived in NYC. This is the closest to NYC style pizza within the sunrise, plantation, and Tamarac areas. Its very decent pizza! I am a healthy eater so for me the cheese has a little too much sodium. But, for normal people the pizza is excellent. JCs customer service was grand! Thank you!
