Bagel Lady Cafe
| Address: | 99 NY-25A #18, Shoreham, NY 11786, USA |
| Phone: | +1 631-744-0071 |
| Rating: | 3.5 |
Location
Photos 31
Reviews 16
JO
John Calabrese
This is my favorite bagel place in the area. Their French toast bagels are wonderful. Except they usually run out within a couple hours of opening and they are often small and dont let them rise enough (believe its called proofing). Thats why I only gave 4 stars. Great flavored cream cheeses also. Never ordered any real food from here so I cant comment. Although I do get a sausage, egg, and cheese on roll from time to time which is also very good, if a little overpriced. All in all a 4 star place like I said. Very good but not the best on long island (which it would have to be to earn 5 stars from me). Also on a side note bagels are only $8.50 A dozen Mon, Tues and I think Wed. Otherwise they are $12
S
S Anonymous
Wish i could give 0 stars! the staff is rude and WAY too opinionated... the older gentleman behind the counter has a little too much to say if he doesnt agree with you on something, very unprofessional... one bad experience was enough for me let alone my friends who have stopped going after YEARS of putting up with it for the sake of keeping a local business afloat!
MI
Mimi LaRue
Bagels are great! Service could be faster and prices are a bit outrageous as they are a cash only business. Female Employees are friendly so, but seems like they rush each customer along and yet also move independently slow. All in all - would recommend this eatery as a go-to for local WR bagel lovers :)
HU
hunter fleming
These are the best Bagels out there, they are not heavy or chewy. Great tasting, no other bagels compare. Highly recommended. They are superior to all the rest. Even better fresh out of the oven. Enjoy.
A
A Private User
The bagels are tasty but very airy. They taste like they were never boiled before baking, hence no chewieness to the texture.Definitely not dense enough. These would be good for a sandwich though.
CA
cathy lilley
We have been coming here for years, never disappointed. Our Family visits often from out of town always order a few dozen bagels to take home. Super friendly.
BE
Ben Ericsson
They cant get any lunch sandwich orders correct and def do not use common sense whilst making them. Breakfast has been great tho so Ill return for breakfast only.
GA
Gary Handel
Not real bagels. Theyre too lazy to wake up early and boil the bagels. Only in deepest darkest suffolk can u pull this sham off!!
JA
Jay Kothari
Decent options for sandwiches, bagels and salads. Has some outdoor seating as well, were we sat with the dogs.
A
A Private User
The bagels are not boiled before bakeing makeing them almost like a roll and the service is extremly slow
ME
Melissa McGrath
Best bagels Ive ever had. They are best in morning when freshly made.
JA
Jason Nadler
Very nice place to go for breakfast.
AP
April Delia
TURKEY POT PIE SOUP WAS FANTASTIC!!!
IR
Ira B
The familys favorite for bagels!
DE
Dee
Busy place but worth the wait
JE
jean JJ
Bagels are great great great.
