Brooklyn Square - Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
| Address: | 265 S New Prospect Rd, Jackson, NJ 08527, USA |
| Phone: | +1 732-961-7999 |
| Site: | brooklynsquarenj.com |
| Rating: | 4.4 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 29
VI
Vita Vinci
I cant say one negative things about Brooklyn Square....as a matter of fact I always recommend this place. Great spot for locals but I love introducing my friends from out of town to this place as well. First of all THEE best square pie Ive had.... order the upside down pie (its square). Even better then L&Bs. I have to tell you I have not been disappointed with anybody the food here. I have to mention the zuppa di clams...PHENOMENAL!!!! If you love clams you have to try an order, you wont be disappointed. Its also a BYOB which is perfect. Also, the staff...nice, accommodating and even comical. I really enjoy coming here because you always feel welcomed. Pete the owner is such a nicr guy who sincerely loves his business...always comes to the table to say hello and really appreciates his customers. If you havent been here you have check it out.
IG
igxkillzzzx
The food is okay but service is absolutely horrific. Age discrimination is a Normality of this restaurant as they take advantage of the elderly. My grandmother is just one victim of these thieves. They take over an HOUR to deliver COLD PIZZA at an off hour, Showing NO RESPECT to the consumer and saying its TOO BAD. "It cant be cold, too bad(hangs up)". How can you treat your elders like this? Dont give this place business, Age discrimination is becoming a seriously prevalent problem in the modern era and These THIEVES could be the face of Age discrimination.
BR
Brian Mann
Food was awesome, service was great. I would have given it a 5 but the flies were out of control. Not one or two or three but at least 10. Constantly swatting the flies off our food and our heads. We were afraid they were going to fly into our mouths, thats how brazen they were. Come on management put some fly traps or something to stop these pesky pests. Again as far as the pizza and service, AWESOME!
CA
Carl Forman
Food was great, but the place had poor a/c in dining room; too uncomfortable to eat and enjoy. Also, very crowded at 5:30pm on Saturday night. Small place resulting in long wait for table. Had to sit outside in the sun and heat while waiting for table. And was charged more than the menu price for salads; waitress simply brushed it off when asked. Expected a good experience, but didnt get one.
C
C Policastro
Have only eaten here once but it was very good. We ordered the Brooklyn pizza, its really just a sicilian pie with more sauce on top. The sauce has very good flavor and the pizza itself it good. $20 for this pie, I feel its a good price for the amount of food. Very good place to order from and look forward to eating there again.
CR
Crooked Dreams
owner is a complete creep . Ripoff over priced and over rated . Do yourself a favor order a pizza from this place and forget that you ordered it , in about 2 hours you will here the bell ring and remembered you ordered your food . Then after that take the pizza and put it in the oven to heat it up because it always comes cold .
AN
Anthony Sclafani
You have to tell the guy that NOW makes to the pizza to make sure the middle of the pie is not raw and the outside is not burnt. This pizza was the best pizza I have ever had in Jersey especially the Sicilian(at first). But whoever Petes letting cook the pizza now is messing it up for him big time! It is a shame.
CH
Charles Lozada
The regular sliced round gourmet pizza was all tomato paste and some curd like cheese on it, with Basil sprinkled about, Didnt like it. My friend had an eggplant parm. sandwich, she said it must have been warmed in a microwave oven, it was hard, she left a lot of slivers of the parm on the plate. Never again!
ER
Erica Robinson
I went in and asked for the best slice of pizza, and they sure gave it to me! The staff is excellent! Theyre so friendly, helpful, and personable. I felt like I was talking to family. If it was up to my belly, Id go right back to get another slice. WOW!
LA
Laurie Maydish
Spent 100 bucks on pizzas and entrees. The absolutely worst fettuccine Alfredo Ive ever had. Olive Garden tastes better. Meatballs taste like rubber dog toys. I used to spend a few bucks there, and sometimes the food was meh. Terrible. Never again
JA
Jarrod wood
The Pizza dough is boring and thye pile toppings on top so you can barely taste anything. The chicken on top of my pie was cut into whole bite chunks, wait staff is nice but the pizza isnt anything to rave about.
TR
Tracey Cianfrano
Service was horrific. It was a race to get to our food before the 50 flies hovering on the ceiling. The pizza was swimming in olive oil. The bathrooms needed a "GOOD" cleaning. Would NEVER recommend.
MI
Michelle Gonzalez
Best Brooklyn Pie in town. Their In a dish meals are SUPERB and very clean eating friendly. The staff is always on top of things. Food comes out piping HOT! From soup to nuts the fare is excellent!
CH
Chad Blackwell
Always have a great meal here whether Pizza or normal dinners. Pasta Carbonara is our favorite along with the Brooklyn upside down pie! Peter and his family/team are always fantastic!
SE
Senthil Muthiah
I have been to Brooklyn Square only once. The "Brooklyn Square" Sicilian pizza was amazing!!! I am looking forward to having pizza at Brooklyn Square again!!! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!
ED
eduardoj40
just had 1st pizza from this place. Its OK. Crust is tasty but too dense to my liking. 21 bucks for take out large pie is a bit hight for me. It was ready when promised.
JO
john casale
Someone needs to tell that adding multiple giant cloves of whole garlic on everything doesnt make you meals and pizza good. Some items are almost inedible
MO
Monica Garofano
Coming from New York it is hard to find good pizza in New Jersey. This place is a great alternative if you dont want to travel all the way into the city.
CH
Christopher Peterson
Excellent. Just excellent. We call them "superlative pizza" around the house, and its true. My favorite is the marone, with the burrata cheese. Yum.
GR
Greg Ford
Best pizza EVEN aim NJ!!! Get the Peters Special. You cant order anything different than whats on the pie... but NO worries... it is AMAZING!!
DA
David Bishop
The food is good and the portions are enormous. You have enough for a second meal. The staff is always friendly and welcoming. Its BYOB. The
ST
stephen Rug
Not impressed at regular pizza was soggy and the grandma pizza was dried out and flavorless. The search goes on for good pizza in the area
RO
Robert Carinci
This is a hidden gem, the pizza is outstanding. All I can say is you must try it, get the upside down for starters. Go now ....
GE
George L
The so-called upside-down pie is a poor imitation of the Trenton Tomato Pie. The owner is extremely rude. I will never go back.
MA
Matt Savage
Would definitely come here again. I definitely recommend this. Great food, great staff. One of the best pizzas I ever had! :D
ST
Stu Schulman
Pizza is awesome. Oven to table, super fresh. The Peters Special pie was so good. Portions are huge and food is very good.
G
G Fanizzi
Brought me back to my days of growing up in Brooklyn back in the 70s. The Marone pie with seasame seed crust was to die for!!
CA
Cathy Rispoli
Love love their Sicilian pie. My husband likes the chicken parm. Very friendly and comfortable neighborhood restaurant.
NI
Nikki Fox
It took almost two hours to get our food... The food wasnt even good. Never again will I return to Brooklyn Square.
