OddFellows Ice Cream Co.
| Address: | 75 E 4th St, New York, NY 10003, USA |
| Phone: | +1 917-475-1812 |
| Site: | oddfellowsnyc.com |
| Rating: | 4.5 |
| Working: | 12–11PM 12–11PM 12–11PM 12–11PM 12PM–12AM 12PM–12AM 12–11PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 46
KA
Katie Hamilton-Meier
While I wish this place were slightly more affordable, and I wish they had a bigger selection they certainly have some good ice cream. I think I paid around $6 for two tiny scoops. And I think they had about eight flavors to choose from. I went with one scoop of oatmeal cookie and one of PB&J. The oatmeal was certainly nice. Its the kind of flavor that will always attract my attention. But the PB&J is what really hit it out of the park! The Peanut Butter ice cream had the perfect balance of Salty and sweet. And the jelly that was swirled in tasted like it it was straight out of a Smuckers jar and I mean that as a compliment. Even with the high prices, I would be back for more scoops or even pints of this flavor!
NA
Nana Boateng
They have a pretty short selection of ice cream flavors compared to most shops, and they tend to be on the wild side so unless you have a penchant for the strange, you most likely wont like most of the flavors here. There arent basic options either so it makes it tough if the flavors they have fit the month arent stuff youre into, like jalapeno or coffee. The Oddpocket is pretty good though.
TR
Traci Cappiello
Love, love, love this little ice cream shop. The decor is a little creepy but the staff couldnt be friendly and the ice cream any tastier. I had the peanut butter and jelly and it was insanely good. Prices are fair and while the shop is small, if you go before 5pm, youll be able to hang out and enjoy the funky carnival monkey decor.
SH
Shadele Grier
Cute tiny ice cream shop. The flavors are unique, I tried the miso cherry and honey buttermilk blueberry. If you tend more toward the traditional, you might not be pleased with the selection. Service was very friendly, and the taster spoons are tiny metal ones instead of the plastic kind. Cute and cuts down on waste!
LY
Lynn S
This outpost specializes in ice cream sandwiches. The ice cream flavors are quirky and they only have a few of them, so it might not please picky (or vanilla) ice cream fans. I was partial to the Miso Cherry flavor, which I got sandwiched with a chocolate cookie.
KA
Katie Chin
Expensive, but with a great rotating list of creative flavors and even a gluten free cookie selection, this place is worthwhile. The salted coconut sticky rice flavour was particularly intriguing, I liked it far more than anticipated!
JA
Jason Wong
They have some unique flavors here such as Olive Oil, Blueberry Buttermilk Pancake (my favorite) even Smores. This place is really good, probably my top 3 favorite ice cream spots in the EV. Single scoop here is $4.50.
JE
Jennifer K.
Cute small ice cream parlor. Flavors are unique but a little too sweet for my taste. They also have homemade waffle cones--nice cinnamon flavor but mine was on the soggy side. :( Bonus: punch card, buy 10 get 1 free
ST
Stephen Gray
My uncle and I had one scoop each for about 10 bucks total. Absolutely delicious. I had the PB Smore and I really cant rave about it enough. Sweet, but not too sweet; great depth of flavor. Cant wait to go back.
MA
Matthew Burke
Best ice cream in NY, though selection is limited compared to the Brooklyn location. Flavors change often and VERY often. Dont bother checking to see what flavors they have that day, because they will change.
IA
Ian Williams
Sometimes the flavors can be too out there to entice me (mushroom ice cream?) but when they get it right they are up there with the best. Coconut kaffir and mint chocolate chip are my current favorites.
TH
The Corcoran Group
No dinner in the East Village is complete for us without a visit to OddFellows after. Just like its Williamsburg outpost, our favorites are the Chorizo Caramel Swirl & the Buttermilk Honey Blueberry.
N
N Li
New favorite ice cream place! I got the Thai Iced Tea it hit the sweet spot. My boyfriend got the stout ice cream and he loved it. Hes not much into sweets but he liked that ice cream.
KA
Katy Conrad
This is a tiny shop so they dont always have the flavors that they get at their big story in Williamsburg, but theres usually at least one or two really unique good flavors!
AQ
Aquanetta Wright
The vanilla bean was horrible. Strangest flavors, left awful taste from unknown additives. Spent $10 on two small 1 scoop cones ,one lick each both went into the trash.
MA
Matt Weth
Im eating spiced honey ice cream. Its spicy and delicious. Staff is very friendly. Red-and-white throwback aesthetic is very effective on me. Dig. This. Place.
19
1987Timmy
Delicious, interesting flavors. My favorites are: olive oil, saffron passionfruit, thai ice tea, and matcha crunch. The customer service is also spectacular.
OS
Oskar von Hauske
Very interesting ice cream flavored, be adventurous and try them! I highly recommend the miso cherry ice cream if available, its sweet and savory.
TI
Tim Hand
Small but efficient, the shop has some weird but likeable combos. Peppered strawberry ice cream sandwich with crunchy flakes. Hit the spot for me.
AG
Agustin Riobo
Los helados con los sabores más sorprendentes de la ciudad.
NI
Nicholas
Got the ice cream cookie sandwich, was a little short on ice cream but the cookies were squishy and buttery. Small but decent flavors selection.
ER
Erika Pliego
Odd Fellows is always a good choice! If you are into the strange and new flavors this is your choice , also if you have a very sweet tooth!
SI
Simon Markowski
Interesting flavors and nice little shop. Definitely a place to visit in the hot summer months. All the ice cream was fantastic.
EM
Emily Johnson
Tasty flavors (I tried carrot cake and buttermilk blueberry honey) but probably wouldnt pay $4 for such a small scoop again.
DE
Dev Master
Small little ice cream shoo with interesting flavors of ice cream. The Brooklyn shop is much bigger and has more flavors.
LO
Lolala Lolo
This place is too good to be true. Everything about it is a quality. One of the best ice cream shops Ive been in a while.
CH
Ching-Ching Liu
Great interesting flavors!!! And service is really patient and nice! Some flavors can be a little overly sweet though.
ME
Melanie Wahl
Carrot cake and buttermilk blueberry were crowd favorites, but saffron passion fruit with pistachio stole my heart. ❤
RE
Rebeca Paredes
Great customer service, friendly employees, and super delicious original ice cream with new options everyday.
TR
Trenton Erker
Offerings werent clear, service seemed tired and contributed to an odd atmosphere, but ice cream is great.
SE
Sean Glickman
Great ice cream shop with many unique flavors. Ask for samples and try the Thai Iced Tea if its available.
HO
Holly Buechel
Fig and black pepper ice cream??!!! So good!!! And you sample flavors on a REAL spoon, very classy.
DA
Daniel Heinzelman
Tasty ice creams. Friendly staff. Would definitely recommend the ice cream sandwich option.
MA
Marley Sutton
The Thai Iced Tea ice cream was awesome! Made it worth fighting the Saturday dusk crowd.
EM
Emily Liftman
Literally some of the best ice cream Ive ever had in my life. The Miso Cherry is a must
TO
Tobi Josephus
I heard so many people raving about this place. It is that good. Cant wait to go back.
AL
Albert Holmes
Very small place like everything in NY but ice cream was good and staff was nice.
MA
Manasvi Lalwani
Small but inventive selection of ice creams. Really liked their black pepper fig.
FA
Fang H
Some interesting flavors here. They use virgils soda for the float. Yummy.
AN
Andrea Lee
Their ice cream is so interesting! Definitely worth a trip to try some!
CH
Chris Reilly
Nice rotating ice cream selection. The cornbeard ice cream was great.
RA
Ramon Trotman
Great ice cream and interesting mixes with the ice cream sandwiches
JO
John Tinoco
Best ice cream sandwich Ive ever had. It was messy and fantastic!
WO
WoodenRoller
Asia month has amazing flavours! Also very affordable icecream!
ZI
Ziba Bakhtiari
A taste sensation. Every country should have one of these.
PH
Phillip Van Nostrand
Great weird ice cream selections, classic NY establishment
