All Star Italian Restaurant & Sports Bar
| Address: | 2485 Swamp Pike, Gilbertsville, PA 19525, USA |
| Phone: | +1 610-323-1735 |
| Rating: | 3.5 |
Location
Photos 64
Reviews 28
KA
Kathryn
Second visit to All Star and we can confidently say we wont be back. The food is mediocre (wings and onion rings are decent though), but overall its overpriced and unimpressive. My daughter ordered the kids chicken tenders and french fries...no lie the fries were black. I asked the waitress about them and she said they used to have steak fries but now they are homemade and apparently this is the new norm (Ill try to post a picture of them, everyone tried them and we all decided they were inedible, blah). Also, BEWARE PARENTS that the $5.50 kids meal does not include a drink so youll be charged an extra $2.00 bringing your kids meal total to $7.50.
A
A Private User
The food was a joke. I ordered the antipasta salad and it came without dressing. My husband ordered an italian hoagie with mayo and a side of italian dressing, neither of which showed up. The wings were alright as was the beer selection (kind of hard to mess up a draft). My in-laws, who dined with us, made a comment on the way out that their food was amateurish at best. Not to mention our waiter trashed the food from the former All-Star Cafe and then had to go check on a couple of things with the kitchen since he wasnt familiar with the menu since he had only been working there for three weeks! Seriously..... dont waste your money
RI
Richard Anstett
Went there twice and enjoyed it both times. Very good food: nice presentation, delicious, and generous servings (leftovers go to work with me the next day). Service: Very good, the staff is attentive and friendly. Interior appearance: Average furnishings/decor and clean, they provide good food and a good dining experience, and are not trying to decorate the place to look like Italy. Atmosphere: a very comfortable place to take family and friends for an enjoyable dinner. Try the Bruschetta - yum.
DO
Donald Boscoe
Cool place with ample barstool real estate and a better than average selection of craft beer. I ordered 11 dollar nachos which were one step above the chips and cheese whiz that youd get at the county fair or a movie theater. That might be ok if they were 4 dollar nachos. I thought about trying something else, but if they cant make passable nachos I doubt they can make anything else worth eating.
A
A Private User
Glad to see this place back to what it was before they tried to make it a stuffy fancy place. What a disaster that was, as you can see from some of the older reviews. Now that all star café is back they have Very good steak sandwiches, good wings, great specials, good service and great prices. Not much to not like about the place. Always a game on one of the many TVs. Will be a regular stop again.
A
A Private User
Have been there a couple times now w my boyfriend- hes italian and loves the food selection. There has always been a chill crowd. They have delicious Italian entrees. Their 3 dollar 3 Olives special is amazing with a variety of flavored vodkas. The waiters have always been extremely courteous and attentive. They also have a pretty good beer special during Saturday college football.
DI
Diane Thomas
Had dinner with a friend - fries were lukewarm; chicken marsala was far from what chicken marsala really is; salad greens were soggy and spoiled--had to send back; soup- noodles were not cooked--had to send back. There was no offer to reduce the bill as a result of the "returned" food. Very disappointed - never to return.
B
B Martin
Its ok. Close and good patio. Live music and good drinks (but expensive-ish). Good service. But food is just ok - were out of ravioli, no veal anymore, and chicken Parm was meh.we have been there many times hoping for a good meal and trying many menu items. Always meh.
A
A Private User
Food is great, staff are great. I recommend the wings and cheesesteaks, but entrees are very good as well. Staff always willing to change the tv closest to you to your game of choice.
FA
Fallon Davis
The bartender ignored us to flirt with men, gave us attitude when we tried to order, and the food made me sick (eggplant parm). Wouldnt go back again.
MA
Matthew Braglio
Staff can be friendly, especially if you visit often enough. Food is ok, nothing to write home about but the choices are limited in this area anyway.
A
A Private User
called on a Monday evening -- no answer no recording. Dont know if theyre open Mondays. Should at least have a recording...
DI
Diane McGrath
Good service, friendly waitress, large choice of beer, specials, loved the cheesesteak and prime rib sandwich special.
ME
melinda burger
I ordered fettuccine Alfredo, bland ad hell. It was noodles in heavy whipping cream, no seasoning what so ever.
CH
chris anthonies
i wanted to go until i scrolled to the second picture...wtf does she have to do with the restraunt????!!!!
A
A Private User
Awful food! Drink only. Dont waste your money on disgusting food.
BI
Bill Holsonback
Terrible! Best thing you could do is keep driving right on past.
BE
Bethann Kendlic
The service and food was very good! Would recommend!
JO
John Mahler
Tuesday is 45 cent wings for the Best wings around.
A
A Private User
Food was not very good. Bring back All Star Cafe!
CA
Cameron Allen
Good food, good price, good atmosphere
FR
Fred Ogden
Im not much of a bar fly anymore.
CO
Cory Weirman
Gr8 food , friendly servers :-)
ER
Eric Gray
Great sports bar/restaurant!
SU
Susan Mary Reimer
Very good homemade food.
AM
Amanda ODaniell
Good food great service
RO
Rob Devine
Great wings
JO
Johnny F
We had fun.
