La Parmigiana Italian Restaurant
| Address: | 44-48 NY-27A, Southampton, NY 11968, USA |
| Phone: | +1 631-283-8030 |
| Site: | laparmigianaitalianrestaurant.com |
| Rating: | 4.3 |
| Working: | Closed 11:30AM–10PM 11:30AM–10PM 11:30AM–10PM 11:30AM–10:30PM 11:30AM–10:30PM 12:30–10PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 19
NI
Nicholas Sands
Went with a party of 8 last year thought the food was just okay. Some dishes good some were not good. At the end of the night we split the bill some paid cash some paid credit. Five days check my credit card the whole bill was charged on my card. Quickly called Restuarant and credit card company a few days and all was corrected. A year later I return with a party of six, place has completely changed!!!! service was horrible , pizza a regular pie was the worst we have ever had the cheese was terrible. Now to the main course didnt taste that great didnt say anything as the others seemed to enjoy it. Next morning food poisoning for four days. This restaurant is totally overrated I would not waste a single dime on anything in there. The service from start to finish was terrible couldnt even supply a candle for a birthday we were celebrating.
A
A Private User
Food is excellent and consistant and the owners are good people who are ALLWAYS there. They are very friendly when you engage them in a conversation. Patty is one of my favorites. My daughter was not feeling well a couple of years back and she insisted on making something special for her that actually got her to eat. I was flawed be their concern. I only go there a few times a year because I live about 50 miles away in nassau county. If they would only open a new place near me!!! Great people who are often busy keeping the food they serve first rate. Talk to them when they have time (early evening) and you will see them shine.
CH
Christian Haerter
If what you are looking for is delicious Italian food in a family friendly setting you dont have to go any further than La Parmigiana. While they do make some of the best pizza on Long Island, you would be doing yourself a disservice if you didnt try something off their extensive menu. Portions are large, service is great, employees are friendly, and prices are moderate. Portion sizes make it easy to split an entree or to bring home an extra meal. If you are looking for a typically overpriced pretentious Hamptons restaurant with mediocre food and a side of attitude then go someplace else because this isnt it.
TI
tina amodeo
La Parmigiana is the best place in Long IsLand New York to get a great meal not just the pizza but other food as well. My Ex-Boyfriend Rudy is a fabulous for the best pizza that he can cook pizza. Rudy makes La Pamigiana Italian Restaurant a family place not just a fast food place it is like being part of one big happy family that is because he is a wonderful father and my very best friend he is an honset man he can make you anything that you would want he NEVER over or under cooks anything since I known him a that is my entire life he is the best cook that I known personally that I have ever dated.
WI
William Smith
I stopped here to grab a bite for lunch. I had a chicken and broccoli rabe panni. The sandwich was great. The thing that wasnt great was the service. When I entered the restaurant it was very confusing where I was supposed to order. I didnt know if I should just sit down or go to the back where there was a sign saying place orders here. I ordered on the back sat down and they brought me my food. I had to go back to the area where I ordered to ask for a napkin. Overall food good, service mediocre, place is pricey.
A
A Private User
Although the food is pretty decent, the staff is not really pleasant. I work in the area and I stop in at least once a week and the staff and their attitudes are yet to change. So if you are looking for a decent slice of pizza and really good salad dressing La Parmigiana is the place for you. However, if you are looking for friendly service with a smile and amazing food, perhaps you should drive further East.
J
J Matesic
The late Celestio Gambino was a family friend since he first came to the states from Italy. Since first opening La Parm the consistency and quality of the food has only improved. Practically every plate you order can serve as a full meal or easily shared with guests and make splendid leftovers. To this day I cant, for the life of me, find anyplace that makes better fried calamari or tiramisu!
ER
ERIC ALEXANDER
Ordered pasta carbonara at $20+. Horrible!!! It was spaghetti noodles with an alfredo sauce and ham from the deli. Also ordered ravioli with pesto sauce. Not sure what the sauce was but it wasnt pesto. How do you screw up pesto? I dont recommend this place. It was a long wait for the food , high Southampton prices, and plenty of regret for dessert!!
DY
Dylan H
Great food! my go to is usually a meatball hero. They also have a gluten free pasta that tastes as if it was real pasta. Excellent. They also have what I believe is a gelato and man is it good. The new addition of a bar rounds out the environment from the pick up pizza oven area. DO IT! The best pizza in Southampton.
GL
Glenn Bazazian
I grew up on this place. Forget about being a must for newcomers during the summer.....it is a must...period! Yes, i am partial to hometown favorites, but this place is an institution. Skip all of the other "Italian" restaurants, and check into this place......you will not be disappointed
A
A A
Mediocre service, horrible food, unnecessarily huge portions, will NEVER goback, the tiramisu tasted like onions, pretty sure it was stored with onions in same fridge. Very sad and dissapointed, very overpriced for the quality of the place, food on all levels. I prefer McDonalds.
A
A Private User
Very good home made style food. You can always count on there being a wait in the summer. Ask their pasta portions are huge. My family normally takes the leftover home and it is enough to eat for lunch the next day.
A
A Private User
They have the best pizza in NY! Ive been dining at this place for over 30 yrs & nothings changed, the family has always been very friendly & courteous! The staff is excellent!!! RIP Mr. Gambino(owner/founder)
LA
Laura Slabin
Pizza an A+ (ask for thin crust). Good for groups and families. Red sauce dishes like eggplant and chicken parm also tasty. Would not recommend chicken marsala. Attentive and friendly service.
JO
Joshua Huizing
Probably my favorite pizza in Southampton, though I prefer to eat it before it takes the trip to my home enclosed in cardboard, which I believe alters the flavor of most pizza. But yes, delicious.
MI
Michael Correia
Good food and friendly service. The entree prices seem a bit high but the portions are huuge. You could easily feed 2 or maybe even 3 people with one entree. -1 star for the terrible canoli.
BO
Bob Edelman
Great Italian Family Comfort food. Best pizzas in the area and wonderful Italian dishes including deli area. Nothing Fancy here. Wait staff is friendly and attentive. Large portion sizes.
DA
David Blaut
The red sauce is the star by far from pizza to Chicken Parmesan. The portions are served family style so come hungry. I highly recommend the Grandma pizza and tiramisu.
TH
The Corcoran Group
Not just pizza but a great place for family and friends to gather. Cant get a table on a Friday night? Call in your order on the drive out east and take it home.
