58 Main BBQ & Brew
| Address: | 58 N Main St, Brockport, NY 14420, USA |
| Phone: | +1 585-637-2383 |
| Site: | 58main.com |
| Rating: | 4.1 |
| Working: | 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–1AM 11AM–1AM 11AM–11PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 24
AS
Asif Hossain
Great location and parking. Away from town center. Ordered drinks, fried calamari for app, chicken french for my partner and 1/2 BBQ chicken for myself. The drinks were poorly mixed. Glass was almost only ice with mostly mixer. Couldnt taste much liquor. Price was very low so I would not hold that against them. Was a very busy night as well. The fried calamari came in and it was mostly the actual squid with head and tentacles intact part. I would advice their management to look into it. Appearance of the fried calamari could use great help. The chicken french was impeccable according to my partner. The BBQ chicken did not satisfy my expectations. The skin was chewy on the chicken (Im talking gum like chewy) and it was soaking in sauce. BBQ chicken should have a hint of sauce on top to compliment the smoky feel from the cooking. Overall, I would go back, specially after I noticed that their owners actually read these reviews.
TY
Tyron Ramsey
Place used to be good. Now, they charge you 50 cents for a wing on wing night. With the 2 drinks you must get and then leave a $3 tip, 20 wings come out to $20 total. Youre better off ordering wings from a pizza place or go dine in a real restaurant with cooked wings. You cant even take wings with you whatever you dont finish and when we got them, they were undercooked and slimy that there was red blood in the wings. Couldnt even finish half of the wings because of how raw they were. Most disgusting and expensive dining place Ive been to. Used to love this place a couple of years ago when you could get 20 wings for $5. Never coming back here, dont waste your time.
WA
Wakeesha Gamble
When I received my food I was given Cole slaw and baked beans. I ordered Mac n cheese and a sweet potato. I informed the waitress and she said "oh I meant to tell you we ran out of sweet potatoes" so why wasnt I given an option to pick different sides. I dont eat pork so I couldnt eat the beans. I asked her to bring me double Mac. She replied " I wont charge you an extra $4 for my mistake" She should have given me a discount for her mistake. I didnt even want the food after that because I felt like she lied and just forgot what I ordered. Then anytime we asked for something she would kind of brush us off. My first and last time eating there
SH
Sheila Galdieri
We headed out for a late dinner at 58 Main. Kudos that their open late. We ordered a flight of beers that were refreshing and delicious,our favorite was Genesee Honey Orange. We ordered the Thursday night strip steak special for $15; great deal for a strip steak, potatoes and mixed veggie s. But unfortunately the steak was a very poor cut. Very grisly, rare ( lt was ordered medium rare). But on the up side, when I asked for it to be further cooked, the waitress actually had it replaced with a rib eye steak. Hours open, 5 stars; our food tonight, 3 stars; the beers,5 stars; our server 4 stars... Overall 4 stars.
WI
William Bucher
I ordered crispy parmesan garlic wings, with a side of hot sauce to mix with the blue cheese, and what I got(almost burnt wings) with a mild sweet sauce and did not get much garlic or parmesan and I think they put parsley or some green stuff in with the mixture of what they called garlic sauce, beer price was ok, sign on door said they close at 2:00 a.m., 7 days a week, but thats only for Friday and Saturday, they close at 11 or 11:30 Sunday through Thursday so overall if you want wings or late night bar, dont go there
JA
Jamal Mendez
Customer for several years and never a disappointment..Absolutely amazing service, food and staff ...owners are fabulous...home away from home..authentic barbeque taste year round..atmosphere is very welcoming! Bar area to relax with friends and family and dining area clean newly remodeled and comforting!!! Family and friends oriented place fresh food fresh taste....always a delight at 58 main!!!, :-)
MI
mike scheer
58 Main is a classic Bar and Grill to be sure to try out. I have become a regular over the years, feels like family with great service, excellent live music, and constant renovations and improvements for the consumers experience. Food is hands down the best in town, best Reuben I have ever had. Do not miss out!
MA
MaryLouise Brennan
Cool place with great wing night special on Mondays. Nachos with pulled pork are a generous portion and delicious. The service is always great, even when its a busy night. We love the wings so much it is hard to find room to try all the choices their menu offers.
JA
Jamie Zalewski
food was good. Then we went to the patio and they cut us off after a couple drinks, we were being perfectly behaved maybe laughing a little loud. They were more concerned with us laughing than the person overdosing on drugs in the bathroom
NA
Nathaniel Gustke
Theyve improved a lot since the shift towards BBQ. Though Im still not a big fan of the food. Ordered a "Cluck n Oink" and everything was less than warm and the wings were slimy. Ribs and pulled pork was alright, along with the sides.
A
A Private User
Ordered a rack of ribs for take-out and half the rack was burnt to a crisp (basically charcoal). Phoned up to complain and got the "yeah, yeah, bye" treatment. Well never order from there again.
TO
Tonilee Meyers
My fish fry was so under seasoned my garlic potatos werent fully cooked. My husbands buffalo chicken wrap was really gross. The only good thing we had was the wings. Really disappointed.
AN
Andrew Riexinger
I cant say enough good about this place. Food is amazing, staff is super friendly. Joe , Wendy and Everett are great bartendersite and Sam is the beat server. I Love this bar.
RA
Randy Ford
Just a great down home BBQ joint with a great beer selection and killer food. Clearly a town favorite as plenty of locals coming in to chat and hangout on a Sunday afternoon.
SA
Sarah C
Love it here! Youll always find your game during football. Great drinks, awesome food (definitely the pulled pork egg rolls), and the staff is always happy and friendly.
MA
Mark Dibelka
Best smokehouse in the Brockport/Spencerport area. The atmosphere may be raucous and have live bands, but its always friendly towards my young son. He loves going there.
AL
Allan Roberts
The first place I visited after moving to Brockport, and still my favorite! "3 brothers" is an amazing meal - friendly staff, awesome atmosphere, live music on weekends.
KE
Kenneth Verhagen
Love the place !!!!!! Atmosphere is soothing and food is amazing !!!!!!! Prices are good food portions huge !!!!! Drinks awesome !!!!!!! Highly recommended
BR
Bruce Sullivan
Best cubano sandwich around. Brisket is recommended as well. Tables near bar area are not for young ears as adult conversations can sometimes be overheard
RY
Ryan Tampone
The wings were fantastic, and they have some of the best mac and cheese around. Service was also great, very attentive and the the food came out fast.
GA
Gabe Hicks
Great food but always crowded. Staff is ok sometimes nice sometimes not, good beer and drink selection. Lots of seating inside and some outside.
JA
Jacob Publicover
Awesome BBQ food that is surprisingly authentic. Nice creations as well like the pulled pork potato skins! The brosted potatoes are incredible.
CO
Courtenay Lanier
Ribs very good. Chipotle chix wings very spicy. Cheap prices for better than average food. If I lived in the area, Id probably become a regular.
A
A Private User
Love 58 Main. Delicious food, always hot, generous portions. Friendly, courteous service. Have eaten there many times..always very pleased.
