Blue Moon Pizza
| Address: | 425 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA |
| Phone: | +1 609-884-1170 |
| Site: | capemaybluemoonpizza.com |
| Rating: | 2.7 |
| Working: | 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–3AM 11AM–3AM 11AM–12AM |
Location
Photos 80
Reviews 36
JA
James
Just saying, the owner wrote a 5 star review on this place. you know because there is a 4D picture under the review. Thats how bad this place is. WORST PIZZA i have ever come in contact, and ive tasted some bad pizza. Service was HORRIBLE, and I mean bad. WAITRESS WAS JUST CHATTING AND WATCHING TV INSTEAD OF SERVING OUR PIZZA!!!!! And to make things worse, there is an annoying as hell girl sliding into your conversations and gently saying pizza? with a question mark into your ear... And the music??? Playing whip nae nae loudly! Thats just weird.
AL
Alex E
I ordered the Gyro King and it came out in good time and tasted very delicious. I was with a group and they ordered salads. It was a good portion size even for the house salad. The service was overall phenomenal, as the waitress greeted us promptly and was very kind throughout the entire order. The setting is very casual and laid back. I would definitely recommend this place for their Mediterranean food and salads. Their pizza selection is very large and many of them look delicious. I would come back just for the service though!
DA
Darlene Hetchka
Not only in the pizza good, so are the falafels. The young lady there was so nice and friendly. Lets face it when on vacation if your going to spend your money at least your being treated nicely. I have been going there for years. After Reading reviews I guess everyone is entitled to a bad day. To bad for you. Always friendly. The shop is still there. They must be doing something right. Someone wrote creepy. Their making a living like everyone else. Whats so creepy? WILDWOOD CREST?
AL
Alex Spada
Every year I make sure I stop by Blue Moons pizza. I make it my top priority. This pizza is so good i genuinely look forward to it every single year. Their service is quick, respectful, and always willing to help. I walk in to the restaurant and I am greeted with nothing but smiles ear to ear. These guys are what make this place great. Some of the genuinely nicest people Ive seen and are always willing to talk. I love blue moon pizza!
MA
Mark Abenante
My family and I visited Cape May and decided to try the local pizzeria and right when we entered Blue Moon we were greeted with friendly smiles. The food was delicious, they even have a mediterranean section. My wife ate their falafel sandwiches and I tried their gyro and now I know next time I come to Cape May, that is what I am getting. They even had Disney Channel for the kids!
HU
HugeMedal Gaming
Great people and great food. We ordered 10 pizzas and they came on time and the food was very good. I highly recommend to come here. They are genuinely one of the nicest people you could meet. The food was perfect, and being there just reminded me of home. It was great. So, if you are ever in Cape May come eat at Blue Moon Pizza.
CH
Chris Wong
The gyro meat was very flavorful and great spices. They make it themselves. They have gluten free pizza options that were good.. I placed an order and they txted us back when it was ready. Diana the waitress was super personable and nice.
LI
Lightning Lucario
Thee is a bed in the back of the restaurant and there only seems to be 2 people working at a time! Also the atmosphere is very creepy. There was unfinished meals on a table that were not cleaned up! Very unpleasant overall.
HE
Heather Hamilton-Cuzzocrea
This place was great! We got the burgers and fries, and cheese sticks with sauce. Everything was awesome. The sauce for the cheese sticks was amazing! The staff was wonderful, too. I would highly recommend Blue Moon Pizza!!
AN
Anthony Passmore
Average pizza at best, and the prices are ridiculous. I could go next door and get a beer for the price of my wifes Snapple. Cappys is way better and better priced if you are in Cape May area.
AM
Amanda Said
Amazing place with wonderful food and lovely people working there. The pizza and everything is excellent. A very nice place with a friendly staff. I recommend everyone to try it out.
BA
Barb Lange
We really enjoyed our times at Blue Moon.... The white pizza was delicious and the Philadelphia ice is so much better than Ritas!! Diana was extremely helpful and friendly
LU
Luke Parry
I dont know why its got a bad rating but its good here. Good employees and theyre tryna feed you. I come in and grab a slice while Im on the promenade and its always good
FA
Fast Swinger
Avoid at all cost. Acted like they are doing me a favor. After waiting for my change for like 5 min they asked me "can I help you?" Yeah give me my change you POS!!
JA
Jack McEvoy
Disney channel on the tv was nice for the little kids but the chairs were not that pleasant but the pizza a fries were one of the best that Ive had on years
RI
Rikkman Vonn
I ordered a pepperoni calzone i was great. The young waitress was so nice, the only thing i didnt like was the dining room. is not the prettiest around.
DA
Daryl Martens
Pleasant people working there but unfortunately the pizza was horrible :(. My suggestion is to start with new dough and go from there.
VP
VPSRexts
A pizza place AND a ice cream place together?!? Sounds bad already! Anyways, I got ice cream once, but the outcome wasnt pleasant...
FR
Frank Piscopo
Waitress Diana is the best. Food was perfect. Definitely going to come back in the future for more great food and great service.
CY
Cynthia Correa
Had a delicious Eggplant Parmesan here, and at 1AM, no less. The portion was large and it came with salad and garlic bread.
IS
Isabella Sanchez
This place was so fricken amazing. Definitely recommend it. fantastic service, fantastic food. Hearty servings. Five stars
EM
Emily Phillips
We had the chicken parm pizza and it was really good! Our waitress Diana was super nice and friendly!
KA
Kali Gianacopoulos
Food was very good and employees were very friendly. Close to the beach and the service was quick!
IS
Isabella Fanucci
The best white pizza Ive had in cape may! Clean and quick. Perfect for a quick hunger fix
AB
Abigail Hays
Awesome! Good food, good service, and a very friendly staff. Definitley going back!
HE
Herman Kellner
The best crust on the Cape, they must have a NY pizza guy cause it was great!
DO
Don Windrem
Very expensive, very average pizza. Louies pizza is slightly better.
JA
Janeen Kime
Food was tasteless and some was cold. Fries were good.
EL
Elizabeth Lerch
food was good and staff is super nice and friendly!!
SA
Said Hadad
Good pizza and ilove cultton free pizza and wrp
RO
Rob
The food was good and service was great.
KE
Keith Perkins
Excellent pizza, friendly owner
EL
Elia Cossis
Way over priced for okay pizza
SH
Shannon Green
Absolutely terrible pizza
TI
Tim Reed
Pizza is good
JO
Jordan Android
So bad
