John’s of Arthur Avenue
| Address: | 115 7th St, Milford, PA 18337, USA |
| Phone: | +1 570-409-6996 |
| Site: | arthuravepizza.com |
| Rating: | 4.5 |
| Working: | 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 12–8PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 56
D
D Lev
Very average food quality for Milford, PA. Restaurants should be required to meet a standard when using "of Arthur Avenue", because theyd surely go out of business if they opened in the Bronx. I was also disappointed with their takeout policy and the way they handled a customer complaint. We ordered five meals to go (expensive takeout meal versus a single pie or a sandwich) and they charged me for grated Parmesan cheese, when its complimentary when dining in the restaurant. In fact, I was told that all condiments are an additional charge. The reason the manager gave me was, "its a different dining experience when eating in". It sure was a different experience, one that turned me off completely. They wont see me again, nor will I recommend them to anyone either.
AR
Ariana Vassos
Food is pretty good for quick take out, probably best in the area, they do get very busy though so sometimes its hard to get a call through to order and there will be a long line/wait for food. Pizza is pretty good, not the best Ive ever had but best in Milford, PA for sure. Some dishes can be a bit pricey for pasta and their melted mozzarella gets a little chewy on the heros (think bc its fresh mozzarella though...) and their wings are pretty good...
GI
Gianni Lisanti
I went there today for lunch and got screamed at by one of the workers when I poured my soda into a cup near their fountain machine which is right in the waiting area! One of the worst encounters at a restaurant iv ever had. Its so degrading to be yelled at in front of workers and customers for a simple misunderstanding. Pizza was okay but the customer service is close to none.
AN
Anthony Recino
I would never go back, went there for pizza it was 730 they told me dining room closed at eight, and that I would have to get my food to go. If dining room is closed they shouldve said it closed at 7:30 not 8 oclock. Second time Ive been there and they are very rude. So now we are enjoying our pizza At A G PIZZA IN LAYTON .and by the way the pizza is better at A & G !
RU
Russell Place
Ordered an Italian combo and a cheese steak. The Italian consisted of just ham salami and cheese. No Cappy or pepperoni. The ham was the cheapest Ham money can buy looked like spiced ham . The cheese steak was avarage. Cost you ask.. 21.00 yeah .. last time I will order from There.
GE
George Radcliffe
Just got a delivery from Johns of Arthur Avenue delivery person was AWESOME, Friendly Food the best! I Can not say enough about this place will get take from them always Dingmans Ferry has nothing like this would like them to open a place here.
MI
Michael H
The food is good but they need to answer the phone. I attempted to call in an order on multiple occasions and they dont answer. Also, their flyer says they deliver. If they dont answer the phone, how can they? Other than that it was fine.
CH
Christine Ness
Love this place! Every time Im in town I take my mom. Their cheese pizza is made exactly the way I like it! The freshly made calzone! Love! Broccoli rabe with garlic and oil! Love! The staff couldnt be nicer. So welcoming every time!!
BR
Breanne Rossi
Yay vegan pizza! Awesome staff allowed me to customize every detail of my order and waitress double checked with the kitchen about all dietary questions. They were super sweet to my son too!
TE
Terry Ziemba
The only reason they get 4 stars instead of 5 is the prices are on the high side, and they invariably mess up any order that you place for delivery, like they forget garlic knots or soda.
SE
Selene du Ciel
Way overpriced for woods of PA and dont bother with the broccoli rabe -- most bitter tasting, overcooked mess ever. The rest of the food was fair, but the staff -- what a poor attitude.
SK
Skip Tarrant
Service is usually good to very gold. The food is acceptable, but Im not really enthusiastic about it. Their pizzas arent seasoned very well, and thats what Im most familiar with.
JE
Jeffrey Cooke
Moved here a year ago from Brooklyn, New York. This is the best place for Italian food in the area, including pizza! The atmosphere is great also. You wont be disappointed!
SE
Sean Marsiglia
We had penne a la vodka, pizza, and some wings, it was spot on. Food was very tasty. Very family friendly. We make it there at least once a month.
NO
Noah Merino Gonzalez
This is my go to pizza shop in town. The staff is super courteous. The prices are reasonable. The NY pizza has amazing crust! And, yummy zepoles!
OL
Olga Torres
Amazing food. One of the best Italian places in the area. Its our regular spot. Romantic for just the two of us, loud for the whole family....lol
RU
Russ LaBosco
5 stars in comparison to the other restaurants thats in our area. Very clean and good service also. The food isnt bad either :)
AN
Angela Thompson
Got a eggplant parm sub and a specialty pie (Sausage and Broccoli rabe) Both were amazing! Will definitely be going again!
LA
Laura kresel
The pizza and appetizers were really good ....bravo to the cook! :). ...wish the place stays open to 11:00 pm though! !
BR
Bryan Bell
Never disappointing. The worst thing about this place is it is always busy. The food is amazing. Service is great.
KA
Karen Rice
I highly recommend the PEAR SALAD! It is delicious!! Very good food, healthy portion sizes. Definitely recommended!
CH
Chris Betsch
Pretty much everything you eat here is good. The employees are nice also which makes it more enjoyable of course.
CH
Christina Borkowski
Out of towners called for pizza for 30!!! Amazing service, great pizza and nicest service. Highly recommend!
TR
Trinka Ravaioli
Great casual byob restaurant with more than just pizza. Hit the spot after a day of hiking
GA
Galen Montalvo
Love there food! Everything I have tried is great! I tell everyone about this place.
RO
Robert Stoerrle
Sunday sauce pizza was good however their fries and garlic knots fell a bit short.
CE
Cel Ortiz
Great food, all the staff are friendly. Great tasting pizza, salads and wings.
AD
Adam Altvater
Consistently good. They havent let me down the 10+ times weve been there.
MA
mark L
Love this place food always great service fantastic highly recommend them.
RO
Roger lake
Best pizza in Milford pa. Period. Nothing else needs to be said. :)
CI
Cindy Baldwin
Excellent pizza. So many different varieties. Nice atmosphere
О
Олексій Волинський
A cozy place and very tasty pizza. I recommend to visit
AL
Allen Guttenplan
Best pizza in Milford...they charge for home delivery.
JO
John Wayne
Good food, but I had to get a second job to afford it.
C
C Meade
Good food. Friendly staff. One of our favorite spots.
WI
William Jamros
Great delivery, still hot and fresh when it arrives
ER
Erin Morrison
Great food! We love going here. Great service, too!
MI
Michael Oddo
Good New York style Italian eatery and pizzeria
TE
Teodoro Vinhar
The best Italian food Ive found in NEPA so far.
CL
Claudia Longmore
Exceptional food, huge portions, great service
DA
David Walker
Good food and nice atmosphere. Little pricey.
LI
Liz Steen
had a great lunch...good food nice people.
NA
Nate Proulx
Love the pizza. Best pizza in Milford.
JE
Jeffrey Nietupski
Very good, service food just great.
FR
Frank Davey
Great pizza. The best in the aria.
FE
Fellsy
Great food best pizza in Milford
GL
glen zaczkowski
Sunday sauce will blow you away!
AR
Arron billings
Portion sizes are too small .
DA
Dayna Walters
Food and service is great!
KI
Kisha Morris
The best pizza in the area
DO
Dolores Albro
Best pizza in town!
DA
david schramm
This place is great
FR
Francesca Haarklau
Best Place to eat!!
TI
Tim Finnis
Great food
DO
Dotti Mizowek
Great food
GE
George Novak
Good food
