NY Pie (Hendersonville)
| Address: | 305 Indian Lake Blvd, Hendersonville, TN 37075, USA |
| Phone: | +1 615-431-5618 |
| Site: | nypienashville.com |
| Rating: | 4.6 |
| Working: | 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–9PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 40
DI
Diana Ralls
May 20th, went for supper at 6:30, ordered a 14 inch veggie pizza. The cashier was very nice. Our order took about 45 minutes, we checked on it 2x. There were at least 5 people cooking so I dont know why it took so long. The pizza was not good. Soggy in the middle, over crispy on the edge. Very little cheese, sauce was spotty and didnt have a whole lot of flavor. The veggies, what there were of them, were concentrated in the middle of the pie, the outside 2 inches of the crust was pretty empty of toppings, sauce, or cheese. I attempted to use the garlic powder to add some flavor, it was rock hard in the shaker. At least the herbs and Parmesan cheese were good. When we left I told one of the workers about the garlic powder. If I have to doctor up a pizza with all of that stuff to make it edible then whats the sense in going out? I was not at all impressed - I wont be going back.
DE
Debbie Kinney
The only place around to get real NY/NJ pizza. Lots of choices if you like toppings. 3 sizes plus Sicilian and slices too. Perfect crust, sauce, cheese...its so good!!! My husband is a calamari guy & said it was the best hes had in years. It wasnt rubbery or fishy. Great salad, great garlic knots. Open for lunch and dinner.
TO
Todd Wolfe
Great pizza, authentic New York taste. You order at the counter, then they bring out your pie. They will taker eservations if you have a big party. Limited beer selection disappoints, but otherwise this was a great place for a family get together of 6 adults and three little kids. Would definitely go again.
R.
R.c. Schneid
When 1st opened it was great.as time went on got cheaper on product and took forever to get your pizza. There has been to many mistakes made with a dont care attitude from employees.For the price you pay it is not worth my money y to go there anymore.
JE
Jeremy Winnett
Decent representation of NY slice. They give the kids a chunk of dough to play with. Cost is a little higher than street slices. Quality is that of a decent street slice. Eat it, dont get it to go. NY pie is best enjoyed straight from the oven.
KA
Katie Powell 101
I am from New York Ive been in Nashville for about 18 years and Ive never tasted any pizza better than NY pie me and my family sense theyve opened up never ate at any other restaurants pizza. There crust is crunchy and its to die for.
LU
Luzangela Correa
The best pizza in Hendersonville. Family oriented restaurant.... we go there every week, the staff is really amazing, we feel at home every time we go. We love NY Pie, its staff, and its delicious pizza. Thank you guys!!! ❤
MI
Michael Longo
I am from North Jersey. I have lived in TN for 30 years this is the best pizza ive had down here! Eat here all the time great staff great food the real thing finally!! Its like going home again with out having to travel.
DA
Dan Warren
First time I tried it. I ordered a single slice for lunch and it was hot and it was good. The 4 stars is because seating was a little tight inside and the day we went it was just a little to hot to eat outside.
RO
Robert Crain
Love this place. Hendersonville has a TON of pizza options. I would say this is one of the best in town. If you NY style - this is your place. Wish they had a better neer selection (maybe some tap options).
RE
Renee Clevenger
The best pizza around! Drive here from Mt. Juliet all the time. Wish they were out by us. Authentic New York style, with wonderful people who work there. Always friendly and great service! Highly recommend!!
JA
James Madden
I had a issue when I called in my order. I contacted the owners an let them know about my service issue. They resolved it for me. We order the Greek and Meat pizzas both pizzas were very good.
TE
Tess Weber
Ive been going here for years! Since I was introduced to them down on Charlotte ave. You might have to wait a little while for the food, but you cant rush perfection. LOVE THIS PLACE!!!
BR
Brandon Roaten
They have 2 locations and this is our favorite pizza! If you like Dominos, Pizza Hut, or Papa Johns.... This is not your place... If you want awesome pizza, this is for you!!
BR
Brittani Wodicka
I have been pleased both times. The garlic chicken pizza was amazing and the garlic knots are delicious. If you want a good quality, not greasy, decent priced pizza come here!
AU
Austin Pairs
The staff is absolutely amazing!!! Amari is an extremely nice guy and makes a killer pizza too!!! Will definitely be back and would recommend this place to anyone!!!
TH
Thomas Bennington
Came in at busy time, line went pretty quick, employees were helpful and polite. Pizza was absolutely great. Overall a very nice dining experience for the money!
SA
Samantha Hale
I eat here all the time and I love their pizza (and Stromboli. 10/10) The staff are always friendly and have a great attitude I love their precious Lil faces uwu
CR
cris moses
Great staff and great food. We came in town for a Texans V Titans game. Treated us just like we were locals. If you visit, this is a must see, must eat!
KA
Karen Geibig
The people are wonderful and the pie is not overloaded with cheese and soggy with sauce like local pizza tends to be. Truly Authentic Pie !!!
RY
Ryan Georges
Chicken Sriracha with BACON. Just order one. You will thank yourself. Props to this team as well, always friendly.
ME
meg wolf
Our favorite slice of American NY style Pizza in Tennessee But we do have to order it well done "but not burnt"
NI
Nick Smith
Quick,fast,and polite service. Had a beer which is a plus to me while waiting on our pizza. Pizza was delicious!
HE
Hector Zepeda
$$ but i like it. The kids enjoy playing with some dough while we waite for the pizza. The pizza is delicious.
SE
Seth Norman
Very Good fresh pizza. Best when it is hot and fresh. I recommend dining at the restaurant instead of carry-out.
JA
Jason Baxter
Very nice employees and Pizza was 5 stars. As I am writing this I am eating leftovers and it is sooo good.
VE
Verica Howard
Very good pizza. Youre able to seat yourself. Didnt have to wait to long for pizza to come to our table.
SA
Sarah Gibson
Best pizza we have had in a long time! Staff was super friendly as well. We will definitely be back!!!
KE
Keith Wilson
Excellent pizza. Great topping arrangements and flavors. Tough is delicious. Will be back frequently!
KI
Kisha U
Great pizza. Good to have New York style pizza restaurant near by. Try their buffalo chicken pizza.
CH
Chrystalandgordon Maugeri
This pizza is the real deal the best you can get with out traveling 1200 miles !!!!!!!!#☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆
M
M Sandoval
The pizza and calzones are great here but expect to pay a little bit more than you expect for it
ST
Stuart Wiston
Hands down the best pizza in Hendersonville. True to its name, this is real New York pizza.
DA
Dani Vega
Great Margarita pizza, disgusting the NY veggies (didnt have much cheese), SLOW service.
DA
Darryl Greene
Great Pizza, Friendly Staff. Been Loozing For A Good Pizza Place Since Moving Here.
JO
Joseph Philpot
Slow service, confusion as to whose order belongs to who. BURNT crust & toppings.
HE
Heather Neumann
Best pizza on this side of the Mississippi!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
VE
Veronica Coleman
Best pizza in Hendersonville. The employees are always friendly and helpful.
ST
Stephanie Taylor
The staff were very friendly and attentive to our needs!!! Exquisite food!
NA
Nate Bkuxbky
Ive worked here for 2 days eaten here for 4 years best damn pizza in town!
