The Original NY Pizza
| Address: | 6458 Tryon Rd, Cary, NC 27511, USA |
| Phone: | +1 919-852-2242 |
| Site: | theoriginalnypizza.com |
| Rating: | 4 |
| Working: | 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 12–8PM |
Location
Photos 53
Reviews 29
VI
Vincent Vacca
Man, this place is hit or miss. But more times than not the pizza is kind of soggy in the middle and crispy around the edge. It does taste decent though, once you get through those first couple bites each piece. Also the wings are really bad. Theyre pre cooked and warmed up in the oven- And they definitely taste like it. And Im pretty sure the buffalo sauce is just regular hot sauce. And theyre expensive too at 6.50 for 6 wings. I really want to like this place And Ive given it a lot of chances but I think Im gonna have to suck it up and just drive to johnnys pizza which is always outstanding.
A
A Private User
Pizza is NY/NJ style pizza cooked in a slate-bottom oven. Service has not been a problem UNLESS you ask a question. Then you get the stereotypical NY/NJ attitude that says, "What the hells wrong with you? You dont know exactly what you want? Just order ya damn food and go sit down." Ive gotten this both times Ive eaten in and the one time I called. No, they were not busy during my eat-in visits. Cant say about the phone-in. Good Pizza.
JO
John Jack
I would love to give this place 4 or 5 stars, but I cannot. I ordered from Holly Springs, and it was excellent. Well cooked, great ingredients. However, two of the three Cary locations DO NOT know how long to cook a pizza. The crust was severely undercooked, which left us with a greasy pile of undercooked pepperoni and soggy mushroom juice. Inedible.
CA
Carlos Russo
Recently ordered from them and loved it. Their pizza was authentic NYC style pizza, and tasted like home. We got a large pepperoni delivered and it came a lot faster than expected. Looking forward to trying more of their offerings, and highly recommend it for anybody looking for NYC style pizza around Cary.
SC
scott visakowitz
As a real new yorker, this was excellent pizza. Doesnt need anything added like garlic or crushed red pepper like some other spots. Garlic knots were good, the dough was kind of bland but it was made up for with ample garlic and oil. Will be visited again.
CA
Caroline Cullen
Great Pizza and Great People!! We brought in NY Pizza for our March Madness party at work. Paul had the pizza steaming hot and ready to go right when we needed it. Such a great experience, will definitely be doing this again! Thanks Paul!!
KE
Kelly Sullivan
I would NOT order from here EVER.......unless you dont mind pieces of hair in every slice of your pizza! Its creepy to think about how unsanitary this place must be. I cant believe they havent been shut down by the health department.
SH
shanika williams
Nothing special the bbq chicken pizza was by far the worst Ive had the chicken had an awful taste to it and bland the chicken wings had so much fat on them we couldnt even eat them!! my FIRST and LAST time!! Ny pizza? YEAH RIGHT!!
A
A Private User
Wont deliver more than 4 miles from their business, which is a real pain for a cheap take-out pizza place. Pizza is also bland and overly greasy. save your money and go to dominos, at least they dont have lazy delivery men.
KA
Kayla Nunez
Im sad I am moving out of town and just found this place. This is the best pizza Ive had in North Carolina in three years!! If youre from the north and looking for that real newyork style; this pizza will not disappoint you
AD
Adam Charles
NY Pizza? I dont think so. Lived on Long Island for 29 years and this is not NY Pizza, they didnt even know what grandmas pizza was!!! Knocking this place off the list
A
A Private User
This is the one the best pizza places around! We are original NYers and this pizza is just like home. Good crust, very tasty, not greasy.
ZA
zac Leeman
This my favorite place to get pizza. The pizza is great and the price is good especially pizza by the slice. The service is great.
MI
Michael Laney
Pizza is good, customer service was not overly friendly or talkative. Quick in and out.
BE
Becky Occhipinti
Best Pizza. Hands down. Ive been getting pizza here forever. Great people, great food.
MA
Marilin Jacinto
Real NY Pizza. If you sign up for their VIP club you also get a free small cheese pizza
DA
Dan Lucas
Every Friday night is New York Pizza night! Its a tradition. The pizza is that good
MI
Michael Litty
Better than most chain pizza but still bland. Very nice people who work there though.
RA
Randy Parnell
They sale pies by the slices. Crispy thin crust makes for an awesome pizza.
RY
Ryan Higdon
Pizza is great, Paul and the staff are awesome. Check them out!!!!!
PA
Parker Goodin
Another great location for this superb local pizza chain.
WI
William Goeders
Best pizza in Raleigh metro. Go here and taste NY.
CH
Christy Beam
Closest thing to NY pizza that Ive had in ages.
NI
Nick Amatetti
Phenomenal pizza by slice, just like home!
GI
Gio marquines
Extraordinarily delicious Pizza!!!
TR
Travis Vaughn
Best place in town
MA
Mark McCullough
Best pizza around!
GR
greg blane
Best pizza around
CA
Carrie Archer
Great pizza!
