Setauket Village Diner

238 NY-25A, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733, USA

Address:	238 NY-25A, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733, USA
Phone:	+1 631-941-3826
Rating:	4.5
Working:	7AM–9PM 7AM–9PM 7AM–9PM 7AM–9PM 7AM–9PM 7AM–9PM 7AM–8PM

Location

Photos 72

Reviews 25

Sergii Golovko

I visited the place together with my friend, who found tooth stick (open) in his plate under pancakes. After he asked a manager whether they serve all food with tooth sticks, she after consulting with servant and cook, said that it is 100% impossible. Of course, we left the place immediately after paying our bill completely. Then in the car, we saw manager running towards us. They charged us $60 more by mistake (the total bill was $23), and the manager had no better idea how to fix a problem than requesting us to come back later. We agreed to meet at certain time, even though I was proposing simply canceling the transaction with my credit card company, and breakfast be on them (given all we had there it would be fair, no?). After coming back at specified time, we did not find manager there. Even more, girl on the counter could not find our bill. She was aware about our case, but 10 min (what a waste of my time!) was not sufficient to find my bill. We left with a simple request that their main boss (not a manager) call us, say sorry and fixed the problem without our intervention. Later, the manager called me with her sorry (not mentioning tooth stick at all, only sorry for $60 extra charge) and informing that they fixed the problem and they want to give me gift card that I could use in there place (Is she serious? Me coming back to that place again?). Their main boss never called me with his or her sorry :( From my experience, I have all rights to conclude that these people (or at least the manager) care about money more than customers satisfaction. That is why I am giving one star to them.

caitlin schnuerle

When I went to this Diner with my fiance before we were dating. I thought it was a nice looking restaurant. The people are friendly. The food was amazing. the first time there I had their Chicken Alfredo pasta and i will say it was the best Alfredo I ever had. It was better then Olive garden and the Cheese cake factory Chicken Alfredo. When My fiance and I went there last week the owner made me a Virgin Pinata Colada and it was beautiful and it taste awesome and with the strawberry on top was unique. Their chicken gyro is the best gyro I have ever had in my life. Every one in that restaurant are kind warm hearted people and I am glad that I have enter into that restaurant with my fiance it was the best I recommend this diner is worth coming to everything where is fresh tasty and amazing

Michael Marelli

Just went to this inconspicuous establishment for some "diner food" and I have to say I was extremely surprised with the quality and portions! We even had to wait a few minutes for a seat! Thats what made us want to stay to be honest everyone seem happy! LoL anyways I got the shrimp and steak quesadilla with the worlds BEST potatoe salad you ever had and my girl got the Patty melt with a burger that was way thicker than any diner Ive ever been to! Cooked to perfection , we live around the corner and gave this place a shot and will def be coming back, and I never leave reviews!

Leta Edelson

My husband and I eat at the diner approximately once a week, and have done so for the past four years. The quality of the food is consistent – – always hot, fresh, and well-made. We especially like their omelettes and chicken souvlaki. The nice touch is having a small Greek pasta salad placed on the table before ordering. This is a family owned and run restaurant which tries very hard to be friendly and pleasant to all their customers. An excellent place to dine when you just want a casual meal.

Sunni Cannon

I have been a regular customer for the past five years. I must say their food is always fresh. For breakfast their egg-white omelets and there lox are out of this world. As far as lunch I usually get salads, they have some really great options. As far as dinner my favorite is the salmon picatta but honestly I have yet to try something i didnt like. I highly recommend this diner to everyone.

A Private User

decent food, however, they claim they deliver..... called to attempt to get a delivery not even a quarter of a mile down the road (im at work and can not leave) and they are asking for a $25 minimum! Ive worked in restaurants and delivery services, thats extremely over priced. they just lost business for that.

Anna Zangler-Scaduto

This is our one and only diner we will go to in eastern Long Island! When you come here you will see and be greeted by the same faces over and over again. If youre looking for friendly service, consistency in food, and a clean diner to eat and be comfortable in, then this is the diner is for you.

Tristan Szakacs

The food was delicious, and the owner is incredibly personal. Great guy to have a conversation with and definitely a recommended diner to checkout for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.

the_scribe11

Absolutely love this place. The owners are a nice Greek family who are always there and the variety of food options is enormous (am always delicious).

Mike Swanson

Great breakfast and the staff is super friendly. Meet her with friends on the weekends and we are never disappointed.

A Private User

A place I religiously go to whenever Im on long island. The staff is so friendly and even knows my family by name!

teejg

Really Great interesting food selections. A little pricy, but your in Setauket.

Brandon Croak

A++ food A++ friendly staff Small, Local, Family diner

Leon Klempner

Good food, family owned, you wont be disappointed.

Bektas Birben

Get the Setauket Eggs Benedict if you go there.