|Address:||260 Market St a, New Albany, OH 43054, USA|
|Working:||11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11:30AM–9PM|
Great atmosphere and really great pizza. We have visited this location a few times and have had great food and a great time every visit. The staff tends to be well trained but laid back making it a very casual atmosphere. The kitchen is an open concept and my kids like watching the cooks toss the dough as they make the pizzas. While Mellow Mushroom is a chain, each location has a section of local favorites. This one is no exception and while I cant be sure I suspect they rotate the selections. Always worth the look to see some additional flavors of pizza to check out. Of course, the pizza is what they are all about. An eclectic collection to flavors to be sure. Holy Shiitake and the Buffalo Chicken are two of my favorites. The Buffalo Chicken, especially, is delicious and I dont hesitate to say it is the best buffalo pizza Ive had. The pretzels are a favorite starter. They take the pizza dough and bake them into soft pretzels. They serve them with marinara but you have to add on the beer cheese. It makes the pretzels and if there is any left, you can dip your pizza crust in it for a bonus round with your meal. The menu is rounded out with other choices. The hoagies are good and the salads look fresh and delicious. I cant speak to the salads... havent had one. I cant get past the pizza.
Very cozy atmosphere with a rustic look, and a nice looking bar. Sat at the bar, service was very prompt and friendly. The bruschetta was amazing and a nicer plating/presentation than would be expected at a pizza place. The House Special pizza is loaded with toppings, and a small was definitely enough for two people. There are plenty of pizza places in New Albany, but it is the care with which their food is prepared that sets the Mushroom apart from the rest. I will definitely be back to try their other items.
The best Mellow Mushroom Ive been to. Great location, great atmosphere, and always really good, unique pizza. Minus a star because they seem to get overwhelmed easily. Mellow Mushroom is never fast because of how they make their food, but a few times its just been too long here. At least the restaurant itself is super cool and its not horrible having to wait! Still highly recommended.
Great food - the pizza and pretzels are outstanding. Good beer selection, both on draft and bottles. Staff is friendly. The restaurant is clean. Decor and atmosphere are typical Mellow Mushroom - funky and fun. Prices are on the high side, but the food is worth it.
I have been here a few times with very large groups, and some with small. The service has always been excellent and I would recommend this place for either situation. The pizza is great, along the craft beer selection which features a lot of Ohio breweries.
We stopped in here for lunch for the first time and had a great experience. The service was top notch and Taylor went above and beyond to make sure we were happy customers. Pizza was outstanding and the beer selection was good. Will definitely go back.
Jolly damn this was a delicious treat! Service was excellent and the pizza was fantastic. Very reasonably priced and there was no wait when we arrived at 6:00pm on a Friday. We will definitely be back to try some different pizzas.
Excellent pizza! The crust is Uh-mazing! Its one of my girlfriend and Is favorite pizza places in the Columbus area. Cant go wrong with any of the pizzas on their menu. Great craft beer selection on tap as well.
Best family restaurant in New Albany. My kids beg to go to MM. The food is fresh and the servers are happy. You can tell they like each other and they love their job. It makes the experience all the better!
The decor inside is even nicer then the one in Polaris. However my pizza was burnt, and my box had greasy finger prints all over the outside. :( Parking was OK, it is located in the heart of new Albany.
I am so glad to have another dining option in New Albany. The pizza is really good, service good, and atmosphere is crazy and fun. The prices are a little high, but I would recommend and will return!
The service was very nice and my food was pretty good. The minor issue I had was with kid food that looked like Catholic School food. So we could not get the kids to eat it. But otherwise very. Nice.
Not family friendly. Didnt allow me to sit at the bar with my 15 year old son. Instead, asked me to leave the bar and wait 30 minutes for a table. I have other options that will suit us better.
Decor was bright, clean, and colorful. The playlist was upbeat 90s alternative, and the food was tasty AF. Mellow Mushroom is always a destination for our family.
Our waitress was so nice and accomidating despite us being a pain. Food was great as per chain staple. Liked the settings more than our Polaris Mellow Mushroom
Service is hit and miss. Ive had great responsiveness and times when Ive experienced a two hour wait when it did not seem that busy. Food is consistently good.
Incredibly slow service. Restaurant wasnt very busy either. Our waitress would disappear for 15-20 minutes at a time. Had to get my own refills at the bar.
Pizza is pretty good and service is super fast. It does get busy so plan accordingly. They have a quite nice beer selection that has something for everyone.
Vegan and GF options!!! Daiya cheese available. Just specify which crust you want. They can bake it a bit longer too for a nice crispy finish.
We love Mellow Mushroom and we love this location. All the local kids/wait staff here are great. Good service, great food, perfect location.
Wow! Loved the house pizza and the Mediterranean pizzas. The small salads were just the right size. And the meatball appetizers were great
Awesome interior and Atmosphere, but the service was terrible and food took almost an hour it get out to us. Other than that, pretty good.
Great pizza, friendly staff and family friendly atmosphere. A little on the pricey side, but you can tell they use quality ingredients.
Very clean and friendly place. Food is good and nice beer selection. Sometimes slow service but overall a good place to eat.
Really good pizza. I love the crust and they have a great selection of toppings and pizza selections. Fun atmosphere.
Server was knowledgeable and attentive but it took a while to get our food. The food was good, the decor was fun.
Awesome food, lots of vegan options, helpful & friendly staff. Wish they delivered though, as often I am lazy. :)
Excellent house calzone! Great bartender in Tonya AND great cold beer draft selection. What else do you need?
Dry sub and pizza, thick crust, no flavor, whole wheat ? Threw it away, worst pizza weve had in years....
Parker Smith (2021)
The made us wait for two hours and the they messed up the order and were very disrespectful to all for us
This place is absolutely awesome. Excellent service with a wide array of pizzeria type choices.
The pizza is pricy but not your average toppings. They have a good selection of draft beer
I was surprised by the great tasting pizza! The price is a little on the high side though.
Good food but the place gets loud on the weekend with all the kids and families there