Plum Tomatoes
| Address: | 420 Beach 129th St, Rockaway Park, NY 11694, USA |
| Phone: | +1 718-474-1775 |
| Site: | plumtomatoespizzarest.com |
| Rating: | 3.2 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–10PM |
Location
Photos 71
Reviews 31
A
A Private User
The pizza is okay, but not great. Ive never tried the pasta but my mom has and she said its horrible. Our family is originally from Brooklyn so we know what good pizza tastes like. The thing is, this place has a monopoly in Belle Harbor. Theres no other pizzerias to challenge them/put them out of business, so they can serve crappy pizza and charge whatever they want and get away with it. Its a shame a better pizzeria doesnt come to the neighborhood!
CO
Conor MacCourtney
Offers sit down dining and take our trattoria style menu items. We sat down for dinner after a beach day in the summer. The service is above average. They did have a fly issue as in there were flies creating a nuisance while we ate. We ordered pasta dishes which tasted great. Would come back.
MD
MD Roberts
A little pricey for the type of restaurant but the service was great. Fetuccini alfredo was very plain, clams in red sauce was better, luke warm bread rolls and pizza strips were served before the meal. Food was very slow to come out. Bathroom is gross and a 1-er so lines when busy.
A
A Private User
Ordered the buffalo pie and it was runny and only barely cooked through. Had a pseudo-bad experience a few weeks back, but this time it was just too awful not to mention something. Now I understand why Rockaway residents dont order pizza from anywhere on the peninsula.
HA
hasani thompson
Where do I begin; The food there is absolutely horrible, customer service is 10xs worse. And if you ever order out, make sure to request napkins and silverware, they wont give you any. Just a terrible experience all the way around P.S. YOU SUCK Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria!!
GI
Gina Fabrizio
I love plums!! Always delicious! Theyre better than all the Italian restaurants in Howard beach. Amazing Chicken Sorrentino and franchese. I just discovered the original plums by my job in mineola. Now I get double the yumm!
R.
R.J Connors
This place has very good food but it a little pricey. I would recommend their Mariana slice because their sauce is really good. Overall a great place for a quick slice of pizza
SA
Santo Cappello
Spinach rolls are my thing. They make the best spinach rolls Ive ever had. Just the right amount of mozzarella and onion. Service was on point as well.
A
A Private User
cardboard pizza and 2 hours to deliver it because they forget to make it but they were speedy in charging the 15.00 to my credit card never eat here again
NI
Nicole Hoffman
Looks like a great resturant, right ? Aha. No. They have alcohol feens work there. Nasty attitude. Stuck up people. With NASTY food!
JO
Joe B
Terrible pizza the cheese is not mozzarella, the food is complimented by terrible staff who are nasty to people of all ages.
AM
Amber Matos
The food was cold and we waited almos 2 hours just to order drinks DO NOT GO the pizza dough was not cooked it was doughy
AU
Autumn Thomas
Love love love their food. I only eat the Bolognese everytime i go there but my friend loves theirs meatball sub
JU
Julian Ford
Horrible food even worse customer service a joke to say the least flies in food and would not fully give refund
RO
Robert Hehner Jr.
Food isnt great. They reuse unused food. Service isnt the best either. Dont recommend to eat or work there.
LI
Liam Mcivor
The best place ever. The pizza is always warm and tasty. The best garlic knots ever.
GE
GEORGE 11694
The delivery guys are jokes and the food is to exspensive but the food aint that bad
A
A Private User
Prices are a little high, alternate means are always exhausted before secret there
KE
Kenneth Zwolinski
Excellent food. Great menu. The best pizza and sausage rolls Ski
A
A Private User
pretty good dishes. pizza is decent. im spoiled by brooklyn pizza
JA
jackie c
Pizza was delicious!! Service was excellent and very friend.
KI
Kim Scalamandre-Lee
Good for typical Italian. Nice menu but have had better
JO
Jorge Cornejo
A little on the over price, but overall is ok.
LO
Louisa Guzman
Cant go wrong with anything on the menu!
SE
Seth Lesch
Best pizza weve found in rockaway
RO
Ronald Grossberg
Decent pizza and Italian fare.
SA
Sammy Garcia
Order from elegante next time.
A
A Private User
GREAT pizza and french fries
CH
Charlie Stauhs
Best pizza in this area
DI
Dion Moore
Fresh chicken roll
BR
Brooklynapoli
Expensive.
