Italian Carry Out
| Address: | 1070 Danby Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850, USA |
| Phone: | +1 607-256-1111 |
| Site: | italiancarryoutithaca.com |
| Rating: | 4.3 |
| Working: | Closed 10:30AM–9PM 10:30AM–9PM 10:30AM–9PM 10:30AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 12–9PM |
Location
Photos 19
Reviews 25
AN
Anados Defered
What is good food? It brings comfort. It makes your face smile, your eyes crinkle with joy. Your tongue looks all over the inside of your mouth for that last morsel, and licks those lips to savor every drop. Your nose delights in the scent. That’s what Italian Carryout gave me, and delivers to me every time I order – whether in person or by phone. In person, I can close my eyes, hear the bustle of family folks working to do their best for you. That rhythm, clacking of utensils against metal pans. People sitting, talking, laughing. It reminds you of what home should bring – and reflects that atmosphere of a family tradition honored with each new day. A tradition maintained by Christine, Tyler & Michael. That is what I get from Italian Carryout – ICO. Good food. Warmth. Great Customer service, and a feeling of satisfaction from the inside, out.
WI
wilfred graham
On Friday 1/15/16 I was chipping at a huge wad of ice at the bottom of my driveway. Im in my 70s and was feeling pretty tired when a smiling bearded young man named Paul Jackson stopped and in the kindest way asked if he could help. With a smile he proceeded to chip the ice and make this old guy smile inside. He wanted nothing but to be kind. He introduced his beautiful girlfriend and was off. HE IS THE HEAD OF THE KINDNESS PATROL... AND HE WORKS FOR THE ITALIAN CARRY OUT... This was his day off...He never met me before he stopped... What a fine quality of person works at the Italian Carry Out... Thank You Paul.. Sincerely Doc Graham.
A
A Private User
After being transferred because the snippy blonde couldnt comprehend what I was ordering, I was told I had to wait a half hour for two pizzas. Then when I picked them up the dining area was nearly empty, perhaps they were doing a swinging take out business to warrant the half hour wait. I then found out they had given my order to the gentlemen that was in front of me. The sauce was sloppy and tasted metallic, the meats werent cooked all the way, and it was fifteen dollars for one pizza. I used to love this place when I was growing up. Too bad only the name has stayed the same.
A
A Private User
Ive ordered Italian Carry Out (ICO) pizza both to my home and had them cater an event with pizza, wings and a tray of lasagna. The prices are reasonable, delivery is timely, everythings tasty, and the food is hot when it arrives. Im especially impressed with the wings because most delivery wings get very soggy by the time they arrive, and this was not the case with the ICO wings I ordered. I would recommend this restaurant to a friend for both home delivery and larger events.
DA
Dane StLaurence
I have tried many things on this menu at this restaurant. Being a garlic lover to the max, I absolutely love everything. Joeys rule big-time!!! Christine is absolutely wonderful and so are the delivery people! I never have found anyone who does not listen and care about my order. ICO fries, ICO wings, Joey, Greek salad - all things I love - and they do them just the way I like. The sandwiches - especially on garlic bread - are wonderful. Go Enjoy! Yummmmmmm!
TR
Travis Owens
Ive eaten their pizza & wings about 6 or 7 times now, I love the buffalo wing pizza. I will admit, about 2 times when I ordered pepperoni pizza it was editably thin, I wrote off this place for about 4 months, but last night I ordered the buffalo wing pizza and it came out great. I dont know if they just had 1 bad cook or if its hit or miss. Despite the occasional problems, Im happy with this place.
AA
Aaron Delahanty
Grandmother was impressed with the sauce quantity. The sausage pizza we got was an interesting dough-cheese-sauce stratification, irregular in this region but not unsatisfactory. We ordered a veggie pizza that came with pepperoni. I suppose for strict vegetarians that may be a problem but if you ask me its hard to complain about a pepperoni surplus.
A
A Private User
A tasty crust with sparse toppings, one topping that was ordered was missing. If this or something similar happens to you, be sure to call them immediately and ask for a replacement.
NI
Nicole Wills
I am from Long Island, we have excellent pizza down there. If I got this pizza back home Id be a little disappointed, but this is the best pizza Ive had in Ithaca. So, thats good!
DA
Dan Biechele
Great old Italian style pizza, my favorite in Ithaca, NY. Really good wings, I like golden fever, ICO garlic parm, and golden.
RA
Randy Ingell
Never had bad food here! Always Great Taste, and Fresh. Portion size and prices, Excellent! Very Friendly staff, Great Job!
TH
Thomas Norton
We have many allergies and they had accommodating very very good food. So if you like bad food then this place is not for you
A
A Private User
Not the best pizza in ithaca but still good and very close to IC. Wings and subs are delicious. Not open late enough though
JE
Jeff Roberts
Great everything! Ive been a customer since the late 80s. Glad that they have carried on since their days on Meadow St.!
JO
John Trinkl
You say your open on Sunday glad I called I live in south Lansing ..... you should fix your web page !!!!!!
MO
Monty Hine
Chicken parm dinner the best fresh hot sauce with fresh hot garlic knots.Cant go wrong.
A
A Private User
So good when youve been working on a film set all day, something to look forward to!
MA
Matt Tupper
Great food! Gotta try their iconic Flying Squirrel sandwich and the Garlic Knots!
JE
Jesse Wixson
Home made blue cheese tops my list and the crazy squirrel pizza is really good
NE
new phone
EXCELLENT EXCELLENT EXCELLENT!!!! Every time, great sauce, taste, freshness
RY
Ry Bacorn
I love the hot chicken wing sub they make, I get it toasted
NE
Never Stop Skateboarding
wings taste like cardboard other then that good pizza
CO
Cory McQuate
Showed up on the pet friendly list. Not true
CH
christinemcalace
BEST pizza and people in Ithaca, hands down.
DO
Doug Rice
Always excellent quality.
