Pizzeria Sirenetta

568 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA

Address:	568 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA
Phone:	+1 212-799-7401
Site:	pizzeriasirenetta.com
Rating:	4.5
Working:	5–10PM 5–10PM 5–10PM 5–10PM 5–10:30PM 11AM–10:30PM 11AM–10PM

Location

Photos 100

Reviews 30

Aria Ni

We had a 3pm reservation (Sunday) . Modern, classy but casual decor set for a great ambiance. There werent many people when we arrived but the crowd picked up a bit later when we were leaving. Mixed crowd, from couples, friends to families with young children. Medium sized space, no tables were set to hold more than four people but it seems as though larger parties could definitely be accommodated.. Concise menu but a variety of great options. Take a look at the menu before hand because I do not think you are allowed substitutions. Our server was great! The persons at the table next to ours asked a myriad of questions (some even twice), and he answered every one showing great deal of patience and genuine helpful attitude. Food was superb! Very flavorful. The pizza was definitely the best part; you could taste every single fresh ingredient and spice with out any over powering the other. Finished off with some complimentary panna cotta (one of the best Ive had). Over all great experience.

Francisco J. Torres

Found this place randomly on Yelp, trying to satisfy my wifes pizza cravings. Suffice to say, she was very happy. As was I. We had the meatball appetizer which was way better than either of us expected. The sauce and beans that accompany the dish really help knock it out of the park. We then ordered a pizza each. I went with the fennel sausage, she did the prosciutto. Mine was good, but hers was amazing. The balsamic vinegar brings it all together. For drinks, we both had the Capri, which was good. Tasted like lemonade with floral accents. Not for everyone, but I enjoyed it. The ambiance is nice. Dim lighting and lively conversations. Our server was great as well. We made a reservation for 9:45, arrived at 9:47, and only had to wait another 5 minutes or so. The place was full, and people tended to linger long after the check, which is probably why we didnt get seated right away. All in all, we are definitely going back.

Jeffrey Andrews

This is a friendly and authentic yet modern Northern Italian restaurant with a lot more than pizza, including great pastas and meats and a very carefully chosen wine list including great ones by the glass. Prices totally reasonable. Friendly and accommodating servers. Highly recommend this place.

Toby Taylor-Willis

This is a great place, stop reading this and go! Great mix of Italian starters - I had the kale salad which was great. We both had pizza which were thin and crisp in true Italian style, staff were perfect and the setting is stylish with white brick and lots of graphics ... Yum

Arun Mathew

Excellent brick oven pizzas in a cozy but comfortable space. From the owners of the Mermaid Inn, theyve kept the special touches, like the panna cotta at the end of the meal.

Quang Nguyen

Kind of expensive for what this place offers. The type of pizza serve is not as good as some other places that does the same. The ambiance and atmosphere was pleasant though.

Patrice MULOT

Pizza très bonnes et ambiance sympa. Correct

Patricia Ameling

My most favorite Italian restaurant on the upper west side. Daily special pasta dishes are delicious! Wonderful atmosphere.

Daniel Nadasi

The happy hour specials are fantastic! $10 pizzas and cheap drinks, going up until 7pm. Excellent value and delicious food.

Kirsten Beck

Amazingly good. And wonderful service. Had several appys and a pizza with my sister and her girlfriend. All were amazing!!

Andrew Gleason

Very salty, but besides that quite tasty. Go between 5-7 for happy hour for special pizzas and low cost drinks!

robert spencer

They just opened. Nice service, food I had was limited so Ill hold off on that. Nice feeling being there