Allentown Pizza
| Address: | 94 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222, USA |
| Phone: | +1 716-885-0529 |
| Site: | allentownpizzabuffalo.com |
| Rating: | 3.8 |
| Working: | 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–4AM 11AM–4AM 11AM–12AM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 37
DE
Dennamar Odle
Ofirst issue was when I ordered a cheeseburger sub and got a sub with no burger on it at all. Management never fixed this ay all. Then I attempted to order food another night and waited two hours. Called the store to see if everything was ok and was told my order was cancelled because Im out of the delivery area... I ordered delivery a week prior to this and received my food but now all of a sudden I cant get delivery? The manager didnt even have the decency to call and let me know they cancelled my order nor did they have the balls to own up to their mistake and speak to me on the phone instead using an employee as proxy when I can hear them over the phone telling the employee what to say. Real scumbag way to run a business guys.
JO
Joshua Robinson
Ill be honest - the pizza here isnt that great. Its somewhat bland, and always seems to arrive a bit undercooked (it gets better if you reheat it in the oven for a little while, or order extra well done as another reviewer suggested). That being said, as a vegetarian this is the only pizzeria that Im aware of that offers seitan wings and vegan pizza. And they are REALLY GOOD seitan wings at a reasonable price. So Ill throw in an extra star for the ability to enjoy wings with my pizza again. If you are only ordering regular pizza, though, you might be better off choosing from another pizzeria.
BR
Branden Sweat
I never give full reviews, but this rime I felt that it was my obligation to do so. The pizza tasted like Buffalo Public Grammar School cafeteria food. I thought I was back in the early 90s again and I dont mean that in a good way. The taste of nostalgia was disgusting and the chicken wings... ugh.... This is Buffalo if you cant make good wings then dont put them on the menu. Sorry. I had to be honest because I was disappointed.
KE
Kevin Carney
Pizza is just okay. I definitely wasnt wowed like some of these other reviewers especially when there are so many other pizza places in Buffalo to choose from. Garlic knots were actually cold and they didnt heat them up for me even though it wasnt busy but I was so hungry I just ate them.
CH
Chris Casas
Best pizzaria in Buffalo hands down. My girlfriend is vegan so we have a hard time finding a restaurant we both enjoy. We randomly stopped in at Allentown pizzaria and were pleased at the vegan options. I had the honey mustard chicken wings the best in buffalo..and thats saying somthing.
LO
Louis Bordonaro
Meh. The food doesnt do anything to make up for the death metal when you go in to pick up. And the stacks of pizza boxes in the windows makes the place look like crap. They say "order our pizza, we knead the dough". I think they just need help. Id rather have Buffalo Cakery back.
JO
Jo Weissberg
The service was really good and thats why i didnt give one star. The pizza was super oily and the dough was ugly. Couldnt finish my pizza and Im definitely not a pizza snob. I had a chicken finger pizza and my friend had pepperoni.
ST
Stu W.
customer service at least in side is just ok, delivery guys all ways nice, pizza is like 4 star most of the time, the price is not bad compared to some places in Down Town Buffalo! They do have some really Good Pizzas tho.
AL
Alec Meyer
Cheap, fast, and surprisingly good. Often have Vegetarian and Vegan options. Pizza is solid, lunch deals are good. Exactly what I expected, and Ive been back more than once. Good option for lunch in Allentown.
MA
Maria Rodriguez
Very nasty person in charge tonight over the phone,ive been a loyal costumer to them but as of today i will order from somewhere else.i just feel sorry for the delivery guys not theyre fault.very dissapointed!
AM
Amanda Thompson
HORRIBLE!!!! The chicken tenders were over cooked and the sub rolls were black. When I called back to complain, the manager told me he made them and I was lying!! NEVER AGAIN!
DA
David Sheffield
My favorite pizza place in Buffalo. I always get it extra well done because if you dont its a bit undercooked but thats how most places are in Buffalo.
CA
Carmen Rodríguez
Delicious subs, good price. I did not try the pizza. At noon you have to wait between 10 and 15 minutes
CH
Chris Vumbacco
Went to get a slice, couldnt find someone behind the counter to take my order. Will not visit again.
ST
stephen miller
Nice people. The crust was a little chewy (maybe a regional thing?) and the pop was lukewarm.
AL
Alex McGuire
Pretty decent slices and garlic knots. Almost always open. Good late night option
BI
Billy Hill
Love the vegan pizza. Just introduced vegan wings. Love those too.
AN
Anthony Cipoletti
Best pie on Allen, one of the better pizza joints in Buffalo.
SA
Sajith Joy
Terrible.... Way to expensive for something very unappetizing
JO
Joe Lombardo
Always great food and there always on time if not early!
JE
Jewel D
Their food is great....especially their pizza dub OMG..
JO
Joe Bella
Fantastic food and the fastest delivery in Buffalo.
NI
NI CO
Only had take out once. Pizza was heavy and tasty.
CH
Chris Clements
Great pizza and extras. Great atmosphere as well.
EZ
ezeriya brooks
Its meh. Better pizza options out there.
JE
Jessica Smith
Great place to be at 2am on the weekends
AL
Alicia Wesolowski
Great pizza after a night of drinking!
ST
Steven Michalski
Very good pizza. Excellent variety.
PR
Preston Williams
Some of the best wings Ive ever had
LE
Lesionread
great drunk pizza and they know it
TI
Timothy Hunt
Their pizza sub is the best ever!
PA
patrick spruill
Chicken finger pizza the best!
MI
Miguel Angel Viera Rivera
Best pizza in buffalo period
BR
Brooke J
They have great vegan pizza
TI
Timothy Gilpatrick
Best pizza in the area
MO
Mohamad Gaafar
They serve good pizza
ED
Edward Parker
Great food
