Lost River Pizza Co.
| Address: | 2440 Nashville Rd, Bowling Green, KY 42101, USA |
| Phone: | +1 270-746-0255 |
| Site: | lostriver.pizza |
| Rating: | 3.7 |
| Working: | 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–1AM 11AM–1AM 11AM–11PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 21
JO
Josh R
Its a sad state of affairs when the beer is the best part of the meal. The extremely over priced pizza pies aside (Ill gladly pay for good food), this "pizza" set a new bar for me with pizza, and it isnt the top one. The pan white pizza was 80% bread, just dense crust. Then there was no garlic based sauce under the cheese so it was just straight cheese on dense bread. All of this glorified cheese bread for only $21. The deep dish...if I could post a picture of deep dish for them to see, I would have. Their "pizza" posing as deep dish was an insult on all levels. Had a high crust like a deep dish...but the filling stopped 1/3 the way up and the crust was, you guessed it, dense like bread. Also, the filling wasnt even done like a deep dish should be. It looked more like what Id expect of a normal NY style pizza. Best part...that was $28. As an eastern Pennsylvanian in Kentucky who has been greatly impressed with the food during my vacation here and knows a thing or two about pizza, I was surprised and extremely let down by this place and the sham they dare call pizza. Do yourself a favor and stop with a beer...its downhill after that.
AJ
AJ Brown
Zero stars if I could select it! Amanda, you dont want to argue? Whos arguing? I asked what happened to my order that I placed thru YOUR website. How would anyone know you declined my order unless THEY call to ask where the order is? You guys dont or wont offer common courtesy to call to let us know that your own outdated website lets you order a pizza, make payment, get confirmation and...? Genius! Not much of a manager if you wont let someone ask a question! Fix your website. Get a job at a daycare Amanda, you dont do well with adults.
BI
Billdozer Experience
Great place! Food is fantastic... you are going to pay a little more, but you get so much more in terms of quantity and quality. Staff is friendly, beer selection is plentiful and the place just has a great atmosphere. I highly recommend the all meat pizza or boneless garlic parmesean wings. But no place is perfect... the one nitpick about LRP is even during slow periods, it does take quite a while for the food to come. This is my second favorite place in Bowling Green to get food and watch a ball game.
BR
Brandon Fugate
I have eaten there a few times and loved their food. However, took my wife their for a lunch date and we sat down at the table. 10 mins passed and a waitress throws menus on our table as she passes. We look over the menu decide on what we want. Sat there another 5-10 mins and was NEVER waited on! Not even a drink order was taken! I love to support our locally owned businesses! And they have great food but what does it matter when no one comes to wait on you just as they waited and served everyone else!
PE
Penny Richardson
If you suffer from an antisocial disorder I would recommend not to go on a night that Kenticky Basketball is playing. It was very loud and Im very thankful my autistic daughter was not with us. However, the wings were delicious and the staff was on top of everything, especially with how crowded it was! Well definitely return to dine here. Next time we will have to try the gluten free pizza!
GR
Greg Royalty
$58 got us a mediocre 12 inch pizza, a side salad, some burnt boneless wings, and two beers, and that was before tax. The pizza used to be so much better, but my last two visits have been just too subpar to continue to support it. Happy to give it another try some day if things turn around, but for now and for those prices? There are better options in town for pizza, wings, and beer.
JA
Jason Trombly
I worked at 5 different pizza places in college as either a driver or cook. I have tried their pizza twice and it is the WORST I have ever had! Both pies cost over $25 each and I wouldnt give $5 for either one. Beer prices are high also. How they stay in business Ill never know! Many friends with similar experiences too. Stay away!
DO
Donna Coko
Not even close to NY style... Flavorless, undercooked. Also ordered fried pickles that had to be sent back as they were more like hot pickles dipped in sauce. Serious waste of money as a 12" pizza should not cost $18 with veggies on it. Staff was nice and beer was good (it was bottled elsewhere). Wont be back n wont recommend.
MI
Michael Sawyer
We walked in and got seated very quickly. The first thing the waitress did was make a joke about my fiancees and my age, even though we are about to graduate college. We then looked at the menu to find that a 16in meat lovers pizza would cost us almost $30. I left incredibly disappointed with this establishment.
DA
Darek Tidwell
Dough for pizza way over proofed like they used everclear instead of water making it and the aroma was like a drunk hobo sat on our table. Lots of toppings as a plus. $22 for a 12" inch pizza is steep. Wings are Hooters like. Ton of Toppings on salad, feta was the star of the whole meal.
LT
Ltus Green
I was surprised at how big the wings are and all you can eat at that for 9.99 and the pizza was very good but I did not like the cod salad the chicken was very dry brought it home to my dogs all in all I would go back nice atmosphere and good service
MA
Map
Pizza was terrible. Ordered XL cheese sticks, and it was literally a small thin crust, sauce less, cheese pizza. Buffalo wings are a joke. Nothing about our visit was good! Would eat a totinos frozen pizza before I would go back!!
A
A Private User
I bought one large pepperoni pizza, cheese sticks and a side of peppers for 26 buks. They didnt give me my peppers and I didnt care to much for the chunks of tomatoes on the pizza. Overall, good food.
CH
Chris Tenbarge
The pizza was great, beer selection better, but the portions on the boneless wings were pretty slim. We got 5 small chicken fingers for $10. The service was very good, so I plan on going back.
A
A Private User
Love the choice of beers on tap. Specialties pizzas are very good. Ive gotten the thin crust, so I dont know about the deep dish. Staff are friendly and can be helpful with recommendation
JA
Jacob Starks
Extremely nice/clean every single time. The staff seem to genuinely enjoy themselves. Finally, whats not to love about All-you-can-eat wings on Sundays! All of their sauces are amazing.
LI
Lisa Prather
Staff seemed confused and did not offer to ask someone else when they didnt know the answers. Good was okay. Need to work on recipe. Ive had way better pizza and calzone.
MI
michele james
This was the worst. They claim to have a New York Style pizza obviously they never had a it and just imagined what a ny slice tastes like. It was a big let down
KR
Kristin Cimino
Never have a had anything at lost river I did not LOVE. the pizza leaves nothing to be desired and the wings are gigantic. The beer is always cold and on tap.
BR
Brent Baker
The beer list is constantly changing and offers sampling and flights. The pizza is the best in town, and the sandwiches are an often overlooked surprise.
JU
Justin Derr
The place has amazing pizza and delicious food just the prices are ungodly but if your looking for the best pizza in town its definitely a contender.
