Xtrordinary Pizza
| Address: | 7639 Southeastern Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46239, USA |
| Phone: | +1 317-862-2960 |
| Site: | xtrordinarypizza.com |
| Rating: | 4.4 |
| Working: | 9AM–10PM 9AM–10PM 9AM–10PM 9AM–10PM 9AM–11PM 9AM–11PM 3–10PM |
Location
Photos 80
Reviews 63
JE
Jessica Lawson
I have heard many good words about this local pizza shop, so we decided to give it a try. We got bread sticks and cheese, a 7 inch pizza and a large pizza. I like that you can get any toppings and no extra charges. But they do have items you can use as a topping that isnt on the menu, such as pineapple. The bread sticks were amazing. Soft and delicious. The pizza was different, it is a sort of pizza you have to eat with a fork and knife. Very messy. Mine had alot if taste, but they put onions on mine I didnt ask for. The crust was sort of hard making it hard to cut with a knife. I got tired if trying to cut it and eventually just stopped eating. It was okay. I would go back. Just not really my taste and I enjoy eating my pizza with my hands not. Fork and knife. Good for a small pizza place.
A
A Private User
DISGUSTING will never order from again. Crust had so much greese on the bottom it was soggy with it. Topping were good or at least thats what I heard from the rest of the family me I was groosed out by the soggy sopping greasy crust. Paid over $40 for a meal I cant eat. Completely disappointed, Ordered 2 large pizzas 1 peperonni sausage ham & xtra cheese, other everything w extra cheese except the banana peppers & jalapenos,
LE
Leann English
Holy Cow Batman! Where I live, there is NO PIZZA that anyone over 12 likes, so it was worth the 5 mile drive to try this place. I love the Ordinary pizza, but I thought Id try this place for a change and it truly was EXTRAordinary! Piled high with yummy toppings, soft breadsticks and a super great value! Get there.
CA
Carole Bennett
My first time ordering pizza here. It took an hour and 45 minutes for it to be delivered. I live just a couple of blocks away. Ince the pizza arrived. It wasnt hot. It was soggy it hard to tell if there is even a crust. I have never had such a miserable first and last impression of a restaurant of any kind.
AS
Ashley Jackson
Went to this AMAZING place a week ago and got 2 large pizzas (pepperoni & sausage).THEY WERE EVERYTHING!!! Super cheesy, the sauce was great, topping were packed on!! I wish there was one on the westside, love them!!! No trouble calling them,pizza was ready on time (30mins). Great place!!
JO
Joshua Holmer
I heard a good review from someone I know, but when I went to check it out, they were closed, and I couldnt find any place where their hours are posted, online or on the building. I want to like their pizza but Im not going to jump through hoops just for a chance to try it.
AN
Andrew Borton
A hidden gem of a pizza place. Very unassuming but fantastic pizza. The lunch special is a real deal. They close at 1 pm so get there early. You have to watch closely or you will drive right past. They are behind the front buildings.
ST
steelgiant8
It tastes alright but it looks like a toddler put it together. Actually, a toddler would have done a better job. And I ordered bread sticks that never arrived. Wont be ordering from here again.
CH
Charla Bullock
Ive been twice and had a great experience both times!! The staff and food is excellent!!! My sister saw pictures and came from Columbus Ohio just to try it and went home with lots of pizza!
SC
Scott King
This is no ordinary Pizza! I have had a lot of pizza in my life and this is one of my familys favorite places if not the favorite. Only complaint is that bacon is not an option.
CY
Cyndi Pilotte-Sanders
We had the BEST pizza ever today. My word it was stacked so high with meat, I just couldnt believe it! And the crust was to die for! Oh. My. Goodness!
LU
Luther Bowens
I love the Extrordinary Pizza. It is just like the old recipe from NBO. The pizza is well worth the price. Also the calzones are the bomb.
NI
nimmer caldwell
Sons of the Original owners of the Ordinary opened this to get back to the real true roots of the Ordinary pizza....a must
TA
Tasha Smith
This was the nastiest pizza Ive ever had. Was very soggy and greasy as hell. Dont waste your time and money
A
A Private User
Best pizza value in town. Always hot, fresh, and ready before expected. Piled sky high and delicious!
A
A Private User
Deluxe large weighs 8lbs. all meat and cheese!! extrodinary for sure!! Best for carry out.
MI
Michael Wenzel
Biggest, best pizzas for the money in town, especially if you like a lot of toppings.
JO
joe moore
You get more 4 your $ just need 2 change sauce and get bacon and Ill have 2 give a 5+
CH
Chasity Howell
Fast, friendly service! Pizza bowl was hot and delicious! Will definitely be back!
DA
Dashawna Johnson
Brett and Brian rock. Their food is wonderful.I really like their crustless pizza.
CI
Cindy Monday
Horrible soggy crust pizza this is the second time Ive ordered. Never ever again
ST
Steve Hartung
Love the pie. And the meatball sandwich. Friendly staff and reasonable prices.
JO
John Sanders
They single handedly revived the pie that put Wanamaker on the map.
AD
Adam Thirion
Forget the name on the old building! This is the original and best.
MO
Morgan King
Great pizza! I think it is called Chicago style being so thick.
MA
Mark Barmes
We love the Pizza but tonight its sandwiches, choices Indy :)
MI
Mike Perry
Awesome pizza topping are the bomb well worth the money....
GA
Gary Williams
The pizzas are the best Ive ever had no question
MA
mack blair
Absolutely the best pizza in the entire state.
KU
Kurtis Graybill
Agreed! Like NBO used to be. Much preferred!!
JE
Jennifer Cline
Best pizza ever!!! Our families favorite!!!
KA
katynix Exercise
Love this pizza! Absolutely delicious!!!!!
CH
Chris Valentine
Always a great job, polite and courteous!
JE
Jenny McGraw
large Pizza with Everything Ecellent
SU
Susan Lynch
Wonderful toppings on a frozen crust
RO
Roger Reeder
Always good well worth the price
MI
Miguel Angel Aponte Rodríguez
Very cheese, but the crust is...
SK
Skyelar Highbaugh
Great food! Nice place to stop!
NI
Nick Hardwick
Still the best pizza around!
TH
thomas & connie hennig
Its one of the best in indy
JO
Joe Bireley
Best pizza in town by far!
ZO
Zoe Tucker
Best pizza I have ever had
DA
dan applegate
Great people, great price
KE
Keith Jones
Great pizza as always!
JO
Joe
The pizza is amazing!
ZA
Zach Havlin
They do not deliver
JE
Jerry Price
Best for your money
HU
Hua Guofeng
the pizza is good.
CL
Clifford Hunter
Good place to eat
ON
onekool Guy
I love the place!
MI
Michael Beason
Best pizza ever.
HE
Heather Kozachik
Awesome pizza!!!
BR
Brent Booher
Love this pizza!
ST
Stephen Morse
Wonderful Pizza
MI
Mike Pollard
Extraordinary!!
TR
Troy Harper
Best pizza ever
JO
joalbe a.c
Horrible pizza
K.
K.C. Dotson
Best around :)
JU
Julie Loos
Great Pizza!!
LI
Lisa Lockridge
Great Pizza
DE
Deborah McDuffey
Great Pizza!
KE
Keenan Locke
Great pizza
TI
Timesha Ellis
Love it
