Keystone Pizza
| Address: | 207 S 9th Ave, Caldwell, ID 83605, USA |
| Phone: | +1 208-454-1700 |
| Rating: | 3.9 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 29
KA
Kamra Christensen
My husband and I visited Keystone Pizza on Monday of this week. We had worked a long day helping his father with his cattle and really looked forward to sitting down and enjoying some great food (my husband had been raving about Keystone for months and I had yet to try it out). It was late, about 9:00, but we looked it up and the hours stated it was open till 10:00, so naturally we go. By the time we got there it was 9:25, we entered to building and were greeted by the employee at the register and she proceeded to say that our order would need to be carry out because "the dining room closed at 9:30." Past tens. looked at my phone, noticing it was before 9:30, then checked the clock on the wall (giving her the benefit of the doubt, thinking that the clock may have been fast) but it said 9:25, just as my phone did. Now, I understand; Ive worked at restaurants in the past, when you start cleaning up shop you hope and pray that no one comes in before the dining room closes. But regardless of how you feel, if a customer comes in interested in purchases from the restaurant, you ought to let them do so, ESPECIALLY if they arrive before the closing time. I get that this is inconvenient, but it is also disrespectful to prematurely kick them out. This employee bent protocol to her will and it was not professional by any means. My husband and I were exhausted. We wanted to sit down to a nice meal. We counted on it. The meal we got to-go was delicious; this review is in no way to bash the pizza. It held up to the reputation, but the laziness of the employee tainted my first experience at this establishment, and I cant say for certain that my liking the pizza will outweigh the fact that I was rushed out the door when I had every right to be there.
JE
Jesse Merrill
I had the pizza buffet twice. Its more than reasonable price for just pizza. Its extra for salad bar. Pizza is decent, but missing something. I think they probably need to add a little sugar and oil to the dough mixture. It has a real crispy crust and a simple red sauce. Atmosphere is that of a dark dank dive bar. Old school. Chicken wings are baked and spicy. They seem a little slimey with an odd taste. Friendly service. Awesome refund policy. Merica!
SH
Shandra Salinas
This pizza place is in an old historic building in downtown Caldwell. The owner is a hoot, and during the week days they have an all you can eat pizza buffet for $3.99. nothing beats that! They have a decent salad bar you can add to the buffet, with the best ranch in town!!!! They have a pool table, and fun older arcade games. My family has enjoyed Keystones for years. A+
AR
Aracely Lopez
Me and my boyfriend come to this place every week or so. We have gotten to know the owners very well and they are super friendly, the best part of the restaurant is the pizza. Its delicious and fresh. The price is affordable. Beats any pizza place ive been in boise. The place but i come here to eat.
LY
LynnDee Pfeiffer
VERY RUDE STAFF UNFRIENDLY NOT CONCERNED WITH CUSTOMER SATISFACTION. had to ask very politely twice for ranch for the salad bar and the staff got irritated at me. Tables dirty, pool sticks bent and without tips making it difficult to have a fun night with your children.
JA
Jacob Bass
Superb Pizza, decent selection of games for adults and kids if your still into those arcade machines. Decently good service, just be patient and you will be helped properly. Prices are OK, but its a good drive if you live in boise. and they do not deliver to boise.
KO
korey raburn
Place is filthy. Dead bugs in the lights and cobwebs on the chains the lights hang on. Service was bad, after they brought our pizza never saw another soul. Pizza was completely bland, the crust was the only good part. No refills on your drinks either.
PR
Priscilla Raburn
I came here for a pizza party,the employees were super super friendly no doubt but very unorganized,they seem very under staff and stessed.the pizza was pretty good but they came out 45 minutes apart for a large party of 30
JE
Jeremy
Awesome, nostalgic pizza place! The food is delicious, and reasonably priced — the buffet is an especially good deal. This is my first choice for pizza in the Treasure Valley. Theres just something about Keystone Pizza!
JO
Joe Sanchez
Great pizza the best in town, but it starting to smell bad I think its the carpet. Staff is cool really on their toes all the time, but that bad odor kills it a little, the family and I will still be coming back tho.
DJ
djlcruze
The place could use a remodel but the pizza is the best in Canyon county by far! It sure would help if they would post a menu online so people could see exactly what they want when calling to order....
A
A Private User
Great food for good prices. The place isnt the neatest place in the world, but theres a great view of the Downtown Caldwell Christmas lights at night time if you sit by the big window in the back.
RO
roni ochsner
Children that belonged to servers were running amuck and getting into the pizza dough! Wings are good. Pizza is decent. Atmosphere is run down and dirty. So, eat at your own risk!
A
A Private User
the Pizza is freaking awesome. i dont think this place needs to be updated because the atmosphere is great here. i believe its a family own business so that makes it even better.
AD
Adam Trowbridge
This place was filthy and the kids were playing in the places filth then putting that filth in the pizza dough I was eating..pizza tasted good till I saw that
OL
Oliver Olsen
The pizza was amazing. They have an arcade atea. The bathrooms were pretty filthy and general upkeep wasnt that great. But I would still eat the pizza.
DE
Desiree Ramos
Good thin crust pizza and wings but the place is run down. Leaking water during rain storm. Little children running rampant getting into dough.
DA
Dave Dellamaggiore
Great little place, pizza was fresh and hot off the buffet. The salad bar could use some help. Just not up to par. Get a table by the river
JO
John Smith
Pizza salad bar just mediocre. Very light on the pizza toppings. Mens bathroom doesnt have a lock which makes for an awkward experience.
MA
Matthew Baumann
The food is good and they have a great lunch special. The building is pretty old though and could definatelly use some fixing up.
AR
Archie Lomax
All you can eat pizza buffet every day for just 3.99. And the dough is made fresh each day by the owner. Best pizza in Caldwell.
G-
G-Maw Carroll Dodd
Still a FAVORITE pizza place of our FAMILY since 1978! A must stop before or after viewing Christmas lights downtown Caldwell
CA
Caden Bostic
Really friendly staff, good prices, cheep arcade games for kids, good pizza just wish they had more options in the buffet
ER
Ernie Cody
Cant beat a $3.99 buffet. Try a pizza with sauerkraut its awesome. Nice people, Caldwell landmark over the river.
CO
Cole Paulsen
Pizza is some of the best in the valley. Not the greatest pitchers of beer. Little dive place. But great food.
CU
Curtis Wood
I like it, I had the all you can eat Pizza & watch T.V. Ive been going there off & on since 1970s.
KA
kaydee baney
I love this place.. great family atmosphere and the staff is wonderful. Kids will have a blast
EM
Emma Bernal
Their pizza pretty good but their salad is horrible i just go there for pizza and its cheap so
MI
Mike MikeRogers
Epic family dinning experience tor the whole family. Era correct video games included.
