Mellow Mushroom
| Address: | 1641 W Pensacola St, Tallahassee, FL 32304, USA |
| Phone: | +1 850-575-0050 |
| Site: | mellowmushroom.com |
| Rating: | 4.2 |
| Working: | 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–10PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 29
A
A Private User
My girlfriend and I went there on a Monday night. Thats the night they have trivia. We didnt know, or else we wouldnt have showed up. The parking lot was full so we had to park across the street. When we entered the restaurant, there wasnt a line, but almost every table was taken. We stood at the podium for almost 15 minutes before anybody bothered to come over and seat us. After getting seated, it took another 20 minutes for our order to be taken. When our order was taken, it took about 30-40 minutes for us to get the pizza. The pizza was tasty, but whatever you do, do NOT, I repeat..do NOT look at the prices. If you do, you will likely never return to this place. It is absolutely the most expensive pizza in the entire city. Ive actually been to airports and 5 star hotels that sell pizza that is cheaper. When comparing their prices to other pizza places near by (Brooklyn Pizza, 3 guys pizza), Mellow Mushrooms pizzas were, on average, 6 to 7 dollars more expensive. Theres really no reason to go here. Although their pizza is good, you can also get very good pizza (and in my opinion, better pizza) at Brooklyn pizza and 3 guys. And its about 50% cheaper over at those places as well, and is much much quicker. The only reason to go to this place is if youre looking to pick up a college guy or girl. But if youre just in the mood for a good restaurant (good service and/or a bargain), then dont go here.
CA
Candace Tibbetts
The food was awesome and the Mellow Mushrooms decor was fabulous! However, our waitress took up our entire lunch hour processing our order. We didnt received our food until it was already time to go. And I had to go into the store and let her know that I was being impatient and that I needed my check and a to-go box when she brought out my food. And she still took 10-12 more minutes!! And there were no apologies! This is terrible customer service! I feel that this is too long for everyday workers that decide to stop the restaurant to eat. I wouldve, and probably will next time, stopped at a way more customer-friendly/time-friendly restaurant.
A
A Private User
service sucks. i think we can all agree. pizza is too pricey, i went here with some friends for her bday and it literally took like an hour for our pizzas to come out. not worth it. the only good things about this place is the cool decor (but who cares when my pizza takes forever to come out and the service is literally a joke)?? and the variety of pizzas on the menu. but, the value is bad. i would recommend you try something else because there are a lot of options for pizza in tally, not just around the college area.
DA
David Money
The pizza is really good here; probably one of the best in Tallahassee. It is a bit pricey for gourmet pizza though. The pretzel bread is off the chain. You can get decent craft beer here and international brews. I have not had a bad server here yet, and the place is pretty psychedelic it Decour. One of my favorite pizza places to eat. Recommended.
KE
Kerry Hartley
I am a fan of Mellow Mushroom. What a fun loving up beat place to go. Mellow it is but there staff is lovely. I had the pleasure of trying some fantastic pizza from here and was not disappointed. Let me tell you the price of there pizza is correct this place goes over and above expectations and deserves to price there art accordingly.
CH
Christine Key
We ordered pizza with apples for our kids and they ran out of apples and just put oranges on the other kids meal instead of asking what was wanted instead. I also didnt get a refill the entire time we were there and my sub was made incorrectly with things I asked to be taken off left on. Terrible experience.
NI
Nick Lopez
Carly really made this experience one of my favorites in Tallahassee. Being my first time coming to Mellow Mushroom she suggested what I should eat, and let me tell you something the pizza was definitely top notch. Ill definitely be coming back again! 10 out 10 would recommend.
DE
Deidre Garner
Just like all other Mellow Mushrooms, the pizza here is delicious! Large portions for decent prices. Great appetizers and beer selection. Awesome atmosphere. Great for students and FSU fans (very close to the stadium). Also a great spot for lunch.
A
A Private User
Great varieties of pizza for anyone in your group. My favorite is the Ceasar Ceasar pizza. I was hesitant to try it, but I dont order anything else. And you cant beat their Wednesday $5 Pizza. Did I mention the breadsticks are to die for?!
TI
Timothy Griswold
The pizza is gourmet and very unique and delicious. I was about to give up on pizza, then finally tried theirs. I did not dine in but got my order for take out but the place seemed nice. I definitely recommend trying their food.
TO
todd henkel
So they come up with a catchy phrase for the name of the restaurant in a catchy theme and mix it with quality ingredients and woo hoo woo hey you got one pricey pizza the subs salads good quality but high price not cheap ear
MI
Mima Kantemiri
We visited Mellow Mushroom for the gluten free pizza which was actually good. Early afternoon and it wasnt crowded at all. Good service, nice people. Server was extremely accommodating!
MI
Michael Staden
Its always a great time at Mellow Mushroom. Cheap PBR and the pizzas and subs are to DIE for! The wait staff is a little slow but theyre HOT! I highly recommend them!
TE
Ted Bergquist
We love their pizzas. Everything from traditional to handcrafted exotic pizzas (and beers). Great environment and delightful staff. Fun place for the entire family.
J
J D
Great food and service. Some inconsistencies depending on the cook and not a great draft menu like some of the other Mellows, but overall worth the drive!
TO
Toby Chapman
Incredible Pizza and service. This is a well run restaurant and is great for both College crowd, business people, and families. The food neve disappoints!
OL
Olivia Mcclellan
Carly was such a great server. She was friendly and made the experience expentially better. The food was phenomenal. For sure coming back.
BR
Bruce Orand
"Oh we no longer have that..." was more often then not when we looked at the menu. Not in the same league as the one in Palm Harbor.
ER
Erica Young
Service is sometimes slow here but I still love Tallahassee MM. So much Seminole pride here - gotta give em credit. :)
A
A Private User
The food (pizza, subs, salads) is pretty good... if you can handle the long wait times and generally poor service.
GR
Gram Znatch
Some of the best pizza I have had in years. Very friendly staff. A great place to unwind after a stressful day.
A
A Private User
Freshest pizza in town, with the most interesting ingredients. Avocado anchovy pizza is terrific.
R.
r. b.
Has to be the best pizza in Tallahassee. Great service, laid back environment, excellent food.
BA
Babyliss45
Food is great and staff is on the ball. Great atmosphere, real close to FSU stadium.
EH
Ehsan Joud
If you want to make your own pizza, it is expensive. Sometimes they have specials.
A
A Private User
Girls are hot and the food is awesome. Plus you can get great deals at the bar.
LO
Logan Simon
Attractive servers more than make up for the entryway, which smells like farts.
SC
Scott Handley
Gluten free pizza really good but service slow. Rest rooms headed cleaning.
TR
Trudy Canty
Amazing Happy Hour deals. The best Bruschetta Ive ever had. Great wings.
