Mellow Mushroom
| Address: | 410 Anastasia Blvd, St Augustine, FL 32080, USA |
| Phone: | +1 904-826-4040 |
| Site: | mellowmushroom.com |
| Rating: | 4.4 |
| Working: | 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–1AM 11AM–1AM 11AM–1AM 11AM–12AM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 12
KR
Kris Occhipinti
I was there on a hot summer day. 6 adults and 2 kids. We picked this location because weve eaten at other Mellow Mushrooms at the pizza is always great. This place was packed. Line out the door. We put our names in and were told 30 minutes. After some time we were told that our table was ready, but it was an outside table. It was way to hot out side to eat, especially with kids. Everyone who was waiting for a table was cramped in the building and people where sitting on the floor so they could be in the air conditioning. We were told it would be another 30 minutes until an inside table was ready. I dont blame them for being busy, but its obvious no one wanted to be outside. They should have asked us if we wanted to sit outside when we put our names in. Seems like all Mellow Mushrooms are kinda like this. Their Pizza is good. People are Friendly, but they have no concept of how to manage their work flow. They always seem to give you a time estimate that isnt have of what it should be. If its going to take close to an hour, tell me its going to be an hour, not 30 minutes. And always over estimate.
MI
Michael Bernhard
Excellent Food, great beer selection, but OVERPRICED ! My wife and I went in to this place mid-March. We ordered a customized Pizza and a couple of beers. The pizza was outstanding. We went a second night and just ordered a single serve salad for take out. They should be EMBARRASSED on the portion size, was literally 4 bites.... for $6. The Mgr couldnt have cared less when we called this to his attention. Guess he figured there will be other island prey.... He had a look like you guys are a pathetic bunch In closing the pizza on the first night was $55 dollars with 2 beers and tip, really ???? Way.... over priced. We believe the food was great, but way over the top on price, and mgt lacked any realization of the value equation. WE WONT BE BACK, and will continue to tell our tale of this place. Too bad because the food is good.
PA
Pam Gray
Great pizza and salad. We created our own pizza and I had a spinach salad with jerk chicken, which was outstanding. Weve been there one time before and the food quality is excellent. Last night was a slower night and we decided to sit outside. Unfortunately, since our server was waiting on tables both inside and outside, our service was really, really slow. The food was wonderful, but it took much longer for this meal than it should have. I had to go into the restaurant to locate the server so that we could get a box for the remaining pizza and pay the bill. Again, the food is great, and we plan to go back, but last night was not the best.
BL
Blistered Dragon
Food was good, service was ok. We ordered a pizza with half no meat because of a vegetarian in the family, which I mentioned when ordering. It came with just a little meat hidden in the cheese on the no meat half. Very upsetting for our vegetarian. She didnt get to eat. Our waiter wasnt the one to bring out our pizza so we didnt get to tell him until the meal was almost over. To compensate they comped our half price app. Not cool. They should have comped the pie they screwed up. I guess these reviews arent that important.
AN
Anthony Reid
Came in on a Sunday with 4 adults and 7 kids at about 4 oclock. We were told we would be seated in 20 min inside because its super hot outside, we were told they had to wait for server shift change. When were we to be seated we were told it would be a 2hr wait to be seated inside and they could seat us immediately outside.. worst experience here ever!! How can you seat a table with children and feed them hot pizza in 100 degree heat. Will not come here again.
CR
Craig Gilmore
Always a great experience at Mellow. Every item Ive ordered off the menu has been on point and great quality. Personally, I really enjoy the sourdough pretzel bites with beer cheese dipping sauce. They also offer gluten-free options for the pizzas (if youre into that sort of thing). This location has a fairly extensive beer list, as well as full bar. Only minor complaint I have is the cramped parking situation, but dont let that stop you from checking it out!
SH
Shellie Hattaway
Let me start off by saying that the service and the staff were AWESOME!! When asked by the hostess if I wanted a high top table or a regular table, my response to her was that I am not particular about that I just want the best server in the house. I was sat in Reds section. And, he was absolutely the best! The food was great, the service ROCKED!!! First time trying the Mellow Mushroom, but I will definitely be back the next time I visit St. Augustine.
CH
Charles Willoughby
We usually have a great time at MM. This location is obviously have some issues. Tonight we went about 400 in the afternoon. The place was not busy at all. We had a party of 8. We got sat quickly, and placed our order. It took over an hour and 15 min to get 3 pizzas. I talked to to the manager and he did not seem concerned.... The bathrooms were out of toilet paper and very dirty. Normally they are on their game, buy tonight. They needed some help!!
AR
Ari Giampietro
Our servers name was Dylan and we had an amazing experience. Coming from out of town, we were looking for a friendly and laid back atmosphere with a creative and unique menu. This was definitely the right choice! From very friendly and polite staff, to quick and courteous service, we were more than surprised. The food itself was delicious. Our server was very attentive and concerned with our overall experience. Definitely planning on going again!
CA
Cassandra Lipka
We had a great time. We were seared immediately. Fun atmosphere. The staff were helpful and kind to my two small children. The food was great. I flipped through the menu and saw that on top of the usual carbalicious items I love, they have several gluten free and vegetarian options that sound yummy. I dont get to MM often so I went for the carbs but on another day I might have tried another one.
JO
Joshua Wolfe
Awesome pizzas! These are not like Pizza Hut or Papa Johns. This is the place you go to when you dream of real pizza. Great restaurant atmosphere, friendly staff, and the pizza came quickly. They are happy to split a pizza half and half so your family can try two kinds on the menu. And there are plenty of other things on the menu besides pizza. I highly recommend Mellow Mushroom.
BE
Belle Clementine
I am vegan. I ordered what should have been a delicious vegan sandwich. It was not. It was tasteless. Dont order the tofu at all. They apparently dont know how to cook it. I asked for spicy mustard thinking that would give it some flavor. What was brought to me looked like watered down mayo with a tad of mustard. I tried it and it also was tasteless.
