Cudahy Burger Joint
| Address: | 4905 S Packard Ave, Cudahy, WI 53110, USA |
| Phone: | +1 414-585-0066 |
| Site: | thecudahyburgerjoint.com |
| Rating: | 4.5 |
| Working: | 10:30AM–8PM 10:30AM–8PM 10:30AM–8PM 10:30AM–8PM 10:30AM–9PM 10:30AM–9PM Closed |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 10
JU
Justine Alioto
I was seated us at a table that had not been wiped off and still had a dirty dish on it. After standing in front of the dirty table for 10 minutes, surrounded by food debris all over the floor, another staff member came over and cleaned it off. She was very apologetic. I waited for 30 minutes for my food. It was about 1:30 in the afternoon. The restaurant was slightly busy but not 30 minutes for a burger busy. The staff was very nice and apologetic but they did not seem to be organized at all. My food arrived and my fries were soggy, greasy and luke warm at best. The burger bun was very greasy, the red onion was cut very thick and very thin (not cohesive), the lettuce was romaine (not what I expected for a burger) it was thick and kept slipping out of the side. The bacon was cooked perfect for a burger, nice and crispy. When I tried to pay with my credit card, the internet connection kept doing down. After several failed attempts, I offered to pay by check but I was told that they do not accept checks. I did not have enough cash on hand so I had to wait for the staff to resolve the internet issue before I could leave. Finally they agreed to take a check. If you are in a hurry for lunch this is not the place to go. About 45 minutes later I started getting stomach cramps and spent the next few hours in the bathroom. Im not sure if there is a sanitary issue going on there or the food was just too greasy for me. Either way, I am very disappointed. I was hoping for a great new lunch destination and I ended up with a bad first impression. Sadly I will not be returning. For everyone else, I guess you will just have to check it out and see how your own experience pans out. Good Luck!
YE
Yer Boss
Went here with a friend, on a quiet Sunday afternoon after hearing how "wonderful" this place was. Traveled 25 miles JUST to try it out. TERRIBLE experience! The dumb waitress brought my friend a completely wrong order. They were "out" of onion rings, (how that happens I dont know). There were only 3 other tables of customers in the whole place, and all my friend and I heard were apologies for this and apologies for that. The burgers were extremely greasy with soggy bacon, wilted lettuce and extremely over salted hamburger meat, with gristle in it. Whoever thinks this place has anywhere NEAR quality food or service obviously has never gotten outside their cudahy neighborhood. The place is run by people who are obviously stoned and cant even do the simplest tasks like use a cash register. When I was here there were so many employees in this place, they actually outnumbered customers. And STILL the food and service was deplorable. Do NOT waste your money and time here. Get a bar burger from any local tavern. MUCH better, and done by pros. Cudahy burger joint is CHOKE and PUKE on a bun of regret.
NI
Nicholas Gates
Excellent experience, now I have to bring my wife here as well. Ordered the Mr. Fungi burger and it is one of the best mushroom and Swiss burgers Ive ever had! The portabellas and cheese were melted in harmony and enhanced even further by the truffle aioli, brioche bun and juicy burger. The fries equally as good, crispy, salted to perfection and paired beautifully with (my choice) whisky BBQ and garlic aioli. Washed everything down with a peanut butter shake that was amazing. The interior décor is quaint and tastefully "Cudahy". Staff was attentive and responsive as I was the only one there during my time period. Food came out faster than expected and was delightful. Definitely will be back to continue to try other burgers, not to mention the wild game burgers as well which sounded great (Venison, Boar, Bison). Thank you for a wonderful dining experience.
BR
Brittany Konkel
The staff was very friendly and the tatortot nachos with beer cheese WAS amazing.... I first got the wrong flavor shake then I ordered my tatortot nachos with no onions and jalapenos and pulled pork on side.... When it came out it was all on there with A LOT of onions.... Im not sure if it was a new cook but it was not beer cheese on it... Straight up CANNED NACHO CHEESE was gross I would come in all the time and order the same thing so I know it wasnt the beer cheese. It was very bright and thick when the beer cheese is darker and runny.. A very very different taste for sure! Im very very dissatisfied sadly I wont be returning. Gave two stars because the manager was understanding
NO
Noel ray-ortega
Awesome menu and great service! Cudahy needed a great spot like this, and I hope to see it stay. The staff was very accommodating without being fake-nice or hovering. Plus, they had a steady rotation of Morrissey/Smiths songs. I would definitely recommend it to friends and we will be back soon! As this seems like a fairly new business, I can tell they probably have some minor improvements to make but overall I think its an awesome spot. Id suggest seasoning the meat a little more, making the shakes/malts a little thicker, and maybe adding booths along the perimeter in the future.
RY
Ryan Post
First time there today. Group of 3 after peak lunch hours. Samantha was our server. Ordered iced tea and waters. Iced tea was fresh brewed variety, unfortunately it was definitely 2 days old instead of brewed and dumped every day. That was disappointing. Food was good, but there was not nearly enough pork on my drunk pig sandwich to warrant paying $8. It was tastey though. Tots were good too, Sad they had no French fries though. Good enough for me to try again. Oh asked for a water 3 times and never got it. That was frustrating too.
DE
Dennis LeDoux
Just went here on Wednesday before Christmas and it was great. They had opened only a week earlier to great reviews which is why I tried them. I had a bowl of chilli and it was huge with chunks of meat....not hamburger, meat and a variety of beans. I had the chicken burger with sweet potato fries- my buddy had the blue cheese burger and normal fries. Both were great. Not greasy, not soggy,fries were crispy....very good indeed. Check this place out. You wont be disappointed.
KA
Karen Gerek
Went back tonight for a second visit...gotta say, this place is fantastic! My family did a burger challenge over this past summer and I picked a mushroom swiss burger as my burger to challenge.We easily went to 12-14 different places and BY FAR Cudahy Burger Joint surpasses every single one that I tried! Kudos to the chef and the owner for having such a fabulous recipe. Just AMAZING!
GR
Greg Johnson
This place is absolutely amazing. Great atmosphere, friendly staff, and incredible food. Having tried every burger place in the Milwaukee area over the past ten years, I can honestly say these are some of the best. Very creative, flavorful burger recipes, and their side items (fries, tots, cheese curds, dipping sauces, etc) are killer. Highly recommended.
JA
Jaimee Sixtyy
Ordered a burger medium, got well done. Boyfriend ordered a BLT. He had one strip of bacon, toast was soft and barely toasted. Super expensive for a burger, sandwich and it didnt even taste good. Shakes were great tho and the staff was friendly. Overall I will never go back there.
