UnCommon Pizza
| Address: | 616 Paxton Pl #104, Lititz, PA 17543, USA |
| Phone: | +1 717-569-0906 |
| Site: | uncommonpizza.com |
| Rating: | 4.3 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 12AM–9PM |
Location
Photos 95
Reviews 52
A
A Private User
Finally, a pizza I can respect. In my opinion, the pizza crust is the most important determining factor of good pizza. I have found that this crust can stand on its own merit. I dont know what dry shaker cheese they use on the table, but sprinkle a little bit of that on the bread and you have the makings of a bread and wine meal (not that they serve wine, Im just saying). As to the pizza, the toppings offered are typically traditional. I think once this place starts going they might venture into more exotic combinations. Their pizza has a crunch exterior which holds up to the last slice. Not teeth breaking crunch, PERFECT crunch. Not too doughy and not dried out either. And can you believe they have a decent array of bottled beer and on tap?! I predict this pizza establishment will soon outgrow its modest dining room and will need to add more locations. I wonder what they could do with deep dish? THANK YOU UNCOMMON PIZZA!
AM
Amanda Lompart
Only order from here if you would like to wait almost 2 hours for garlic bread, ice cream, and beer. Especially if you prefer beer thats never been chilled. Ordered here at 4PM and had to call and do status checks on my order twice before it was received. When I finally received my order, the garlic bread was cold and the beer warm--apparently it had never been in the refrigerator. I called and spoke to the manager who informed me I conversed with someone regarding the beer never having been chilled. Nope no one ever said anything. Oh. And the manager told me he "had to go" when I voiced my complaint. Wonderful customer service.
PA
Patrick D
Send a very nice location however its not very obvious from the car. And its more like just off the corner of Paxton st. Rather than directly along it . The staff here is very friendly and helpful. The food however was only so-so theres several other pizza places like this in the area that are much better. So unless I was a resident of the Apartments and Townhomes that surround the pizza place I dont think I would go back.
A
A Private User
UnCommon Pizza is now our familys favorite restaurant! We enjoy having a glass of wine or beer in a comfortable / family friendly restaurant. Besides the pizza, our favorites our the cheeseburger sub and the homemade soups. The patio is also great. Check out the daily specials...Mondays are $1 pizza slices...quite honestly the best deal in Lancaster County because the slices are huge!
BI
Billy Peene
Their subs and pizza are very good. Got their lunch special, $6.99 for a 6 inch sub with chips and a soda. A side of fries will cost you a little over $2. We split a basket of fries for $3.99, which was just enough for two people. Their fries are excellent and battered! They have a nice selection of drinks and a very nice atmosphere inside and out.
A
A Private User
Nice casual place. Organized and pretty clean, but not sparkling. First bite was very good. Golden brown crust with a dry finish. After 2 small slices I felt ickier and ickier... The chicken and ham toppings are OK, but almost soft. Kids loved it! If you like Pizza Hut, youll love Uncommon Pizza.
BR
Brent Piech
We ordered a Super Supreme Pizza, custom veggie pizza, loaded fries, and hot garlic parmigiana wings. They were all excellent!!! The delivery was fast, and the food was piping hot when it arrived (and less expensive than most pizza chains). I highly recommend Uncommon Pizza!
KR
Kristina Bastian
Easy, comfortable, welcoming atmosphere. Perfect for "hanging out" and visit with friends. Attentive, personal staff. Pizza was awesome! (see photo!) Totally uncommon and very special. (great for foodies!). Nice selection of beer and wine - just the right variety!
A
A Private User
I love this place because my kids can walk there and I know there wont be any trouble. The owner runs a tight ship. Many locals frequent the establishment but it isnt a "hang out" in a bad way. The servers are friendly and the food is good. Great selection of beers, too.
DA
Dawn Denney
I had my sons rehersal dinner here...and it was Awesome. The food was Great and the staff was so helpful and accommodating. I am sorry I dont live in the area because I would go back here all the time. Thanks everyone for a Great night!!
BI
Bill Torres
Went for lunch 1:00 service was poor Pizza wasnt that good taste like a frozen tombstone pizza salad was fresh wont go there again very disappointed for a place with a name Uncommon Pizza this was less than common
JI
Jim Toshack
Recommended! Service was amazing, food was fantastic. 4 stars only due to sticky table! Had a wonderful evening. Pizza was served hot and their but knots were just amazing with garlic butter! Well be back.
A
A Private User
Very good food, very friendly people. On more than one occasion Ive requested something that wasnt on the menu and they happily made it for me. Love this place!
SA
Sanjay Manseta
Food is good. But as usual during busy time, they are not up-to par in service. They forget things and when you re-ask, they dont like it and do fake apology.
DA
Dan Fethkenher
The pizza tasted great! Well satisfied with that. The service seemed to be fine, so 4 stars. Ill have to go again soon and see if I can raise it to 5 stars.
CE
Cesar Viveros viveros
Muy buen lugar para comer pizza muy deliciosa ....
RE
Rebecca Goshert
Food is average, some selections are better than others. Service was rather slow despite the amount of staff I saw working.
BO
Bonnie Hevener
Cute nice clean place. Pizza the worst, no flavor. Yes it is uncommon...the box with tomato paste probably taste better.
AL
Alex Reyes
BBQ chicken pizza wasnt that good in my opinion. Also, delivery took way longer than expected and the coffee was cold.
BE
Becky Smith
Friendly staff who made my nephews day by chatting with him. Good pizza with a fun selection and plenty of parking.
KA
Katie Whitehill
The service is always good. They are busy Friday and Saturday nights. Good beer selection, pizza is good.
DI
Diane Hilton
Great fresh food! Nice selection of BEER...fantastic service..would definitely come back here!
E.
E.A. Harvey
Good pizza and even better homemade ice cream. Nice deck for cool summer evenings.
NI
Nicholas Bakken
Cozy, popular, and inviting restaurant. Staff is excellent, and food is good.
GA
gary rupp
Excellent pizza, subs, homemade ice cream. Nice environment, good service.
JE
Jessica Morgan
This is one of our favorite places to go!! Love sitting out on the patio.
CH
Christine Kile
Never a bad experience here. Prices are good and service is friendly.
TI
Timothy Shultz
Great buffalo chicken pizza and friendly staff. Delivery available.
BR
Brandon Schmidt
Good pizza and a comfortable, although sometimes cramped, location.
NE
Neil SIROTA
Great food and amazing staff! Best pizza experience in the area
CH
Christian Brooks
Our entire familys favorite place. Great food at a great price.
AL
Alexis Brandenburger
Such good pizza. One of my favorite places in the Lititz area.
KE
Ken Eastman
Wonderful good food good service good company
DE
Dennis Clark
Meh
MA
Maria Gittens
Very good pizza! A little pricey, but good.
SU
Susan Landis
Great place! Their specials are unbeatable!
RO
Rob Ledrew
Prices great; loaded cheese fries greater!
DE
Dennis Dennis
Great place to eat & price is not to bad.
AL
Alexander Henderson
Good pizza, friendly service, good vibes
JU
Julie Rexroth
Good service, okay food, decent prices.
AN
Anthony Panichelli
The best pizza west of Philadelphia --
MA
Matthew Aument
Delicious strombolis and Long Islands!
HE
headcase31780
Its like coming to a friends house.
TO
Todd Barto
Very good pizza if you can get in.
AD
Adrin Vargas
Delicious options but expensive.
BR
bryna freeman
Great service and good food!
RO
Rob Landon
Great food. Prompt delivery.
CO
Corey Nickliss
Excellent cheese steak
CA
Carson Schreiber
god-tier pizza
JO
Jonathan Chacon
Great wings!
DA
Dave McDonald
Good pizza!
JA
Jason Salters
Awesome
