Crazy Fish Bar & Gill

9 Traders Cove, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, USA

Address:	9 Traders Cove, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, USA
Phone:	+1 631-509-4848
Site:	crazyfishbarandgill.com
Rating:	4.5
Working:	11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–10PM

Location

Photos 36

Reviews 22

Jared Gogel

If it werent for the drinks, I would give this 4 stars. If it werent for the hostess telling us before we ordered that the drinks were strong, I wouldnt be writing this review. Food was very good. Had Thai calamari, clam chowder, and the paella. Enjoyed them all and recommend. but the drinks, weak, and not made well. My Mojito was under sweetened. My fiancés sangria was over sweetened. My friends beer came 3/4 full.

Shannon Sha

I had the scallops and my husband ordered the paella. The scallops had a Mrs. Dash or old bay seasoning and Asian inspired sauce. Very disjointed. Not good at all. I was so disappointed, bec its a seafood focused restaurant. The kielbasa or sausage in my husbands dish tasted low quality, from a supermarket. And the shrimp was rubbery and overcooked. The hostess was very nice.

jay Ahgharian

I was here on a busy friday night. There was a fund raising event and there was a lot of activity but every waiting staff and a nice lady who was the Manger or the owner kept checking on me to make sure I was ok. I order pan seared halibut which was cooked to perfection and delicious. I highly recommend this place.

Steve Sobczak

We were looking for something different for lunch and decided to try this place out. It was great. I ordered the grouper rueben and it was so fresh and flavorful. My wife ordered the crab and shrimp quesadilla which was just as good. I cant wait to come back and try the full dinner menu. Great place!

Ann Shaw

We heard great things about this restaurant from friends so we decided to try it out. I ordered the Fish Tacos and Sweet Potato Fries and my husband ordered the Tuna Wrap. Everything was delicious and reasonably priced. I will definitely be back to try the other lunch entrees.

Valeria Souza

We had VERY BAD experience. Food took 1 hour. Cold food and price. The attendent was very unhappy person. They did not bring our coffee . Over all was unplease to go there. Wish We can go back in time. We were there 4th of July 2017.

Carmine Campisi

First time at Crazy Fish. Dined on Shrimp, Scallops and Grits and Shrimp over Risotto. Both dinners were perfect! Friday evening the restaurant was packed, Inside, Outside deck, as well as the Bar. We will be sure to return soon.

Benita Randolph

This was our first time here, the service was ok as our server was a little inattentive. But we thoroughly enjoyed our meal and was pleasantly surprised by the size steak that came with my meal. Will definitely come back..

Susan Engler

Very good food and nice atmosphere. I just thought it was a little pricey for the cosmo! ($13) and I wish the dinner came with a salad. We split a watermelon feta salad which was delicious but small for the $14 prices

CB Trombetta

I would have given 4 or 5 stars as the seafood was delicious, but $8.00 draft beers and $9.00 glasses of wine I thought was overpriced for Port Jefferson. This isnt Manhattan or the Hamptons.

Mark LoGiurato

Great place to get fresh seafood and good cocktails! Relaxing atmosphere on the open deck. Service is wonderful as is the entire staff! Highly recommend the lobster tacos!

janet love

Love the food and special mix drinks! Have been there for dinner several times and have never been disappointed. Looking to go back soon.

Edna J. White

Great cozy place and the service is great with greetings of smiles and the food.... Delicious!!!

John Juston Slawkawski

Went in for lunch, good atmosphere, friendly service. Good food. Will come back for dinner.

Michele Daniels

Very nice atmosphere. A nice place to relax. Great appetizers and dinner menu

Matthew Pearo

Seafood gem on the North shore. As a bonus, the sangria is excellent.

Michael Bartho

Food was fantastic. Definitely will be back to try something new.