Amici Restaurant
| Address: | 304 NY-25A, Mt Sinai, NY 11766, USA |
| Phone: | +1 631-473-2400 |
| Site: | amicirestaurant.org |
| Rating: | 3.9 |
| Working: | 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 12–9PM |
Location
Photos 89
Reviews 41
A
A Private User
As far as cost goes, they had a good deal- $20.11 fixed price meal including appetizer, main course, and dessert. The bread was cold and hard. I had mussels for an appetizer and they were decent except for the size, they must have been babies! They brought me a moist towelette that was previously open and dry by the time I got it! My husband got the bacon wrapped shrimp- tasty but terrible platting :-( for main course I got the salmon over risotto. The salmon was good but the risotto was not, it wasnt seasoned and lacked cheese; also, it was very runny. My husband had the lobster ravioli. The pasta was cooked perfectly but the lobster inside lacked flavor. On the other hand, the creamy sauce was super super salty, almost unedible. Dessert was delicious! The raspberry sorbet and the chocolate mousse were great, the whipped cream was freshly whipped, kudos here. Overall, for the quality of the food, I wouldnt pay that money, even though it was three dishes.
BE
Beth Ann Dalton
I had my daughters baby shower here this past Saturday--WHAT A HUGE SUCCESS!! The staff was VERY helpful, and the food was delicious! Thanks Susan, Pat, Joanne and all the waiters and waitresses especially my friend Megan who was my initial contact! The cake was yummy as well as pretty! They were very patient as I tried to figure out all the details with them, and they encouraged questions and phone calls. I was able to bring large items the night before and come early to decorate. THANK YOU AMICI !! I highly recommend this venue for your party!
BI
Bill Thatner
The decor is appealing, and the wait staff is friendly. Very accommodating place for an intimate dinner to a larger group affair. You are presented with a good selection of food. The taste I have found to be just ok. Very well run place, but the kitchen could use some pointers and a little passion.
NA
Nancy Wozniak
One of our favorite places to eat and relax. The food is excellent and portions are large. Always have a lunch leftover from dinner the next day. The night bartender (male) can be rude. He serves his regulars. If your not his regular, he ignores you. Otherwise its a great place.
JO
Jonathan Keen
Took my wife here on our first date 12 years ago. We still come every now and then, the food is still delicious. Depending on the chef, it can be a little on the saltier side. They have great prix fixe deals and happy hour specials, so we usually come for those.
EL
Elaine Savage
We had my daughters graduation lunch here on Sunday May 15th. I cannot say enough about the wonderful owner and staff. Food was excellent and portions hearty and shout out to Dawn our waitress who kept our glasses filled and the food coming. I highly recommend!!
YU
YU ER
The food is good and big portions. I live close by and for some reason there isnt anything that stands out to make me be a usual there but its not bad at all. its clean and the wait staff is friendly and Attentive. I hear they have a fun bar area with specials
TH
Theresa Manno
We took my mom here for her birthday last week. The staff was amazing, and the food was absolutely delicious . It was my first time there and it definitely will not be my last. Thank You to everyone at Amicis In Mt. Sinai for making moms birthday special.
AL
Al AlleyCatSigns
Real authentic italian food as good as it gets. Comfortable and relaxed atmosphere. The staff and owners are absolutely wonderful! You wont be disappointed. Try their cannolis with some coffee! Just the perfect ending to a perfect meal!
SA
Samantha Sigelakis-Minski
Really great Italian food. Went for a bridal shower and went again for lunch special. Their regular menu is a tad overpriced for my tastes, but the food is solid and the deals are pretty good. I would prefer a larger drink selection, however.
VA
Valerie Abreu
We had a beautiful baby shower here. All the employees were so helpful and made our party a delight. Well be back for sure, when in town! Great quality food... yummmmmm!
JO
John DeAngelo
Terrible Italian cuisine ! Highly disappointed, really unprofessional service ... Also really expensive drinks 3 dollars for a fountain coke full of ice, no refill !!!!!
JH
Jhon Smith
Come on seriously. This has to be one of the worst Italian places around. Everything was less than good. Wanted dessert initially but passed on that and on coffee.
JA
Jack Schneider
Great food, great people, I want to go here more, The food is fantastic. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. The bartender made the best drinks. Thank you
D
D Zeppelin
Delightful each time I go. The staff is always attentive and I will be back. We have hosted several parties here as well. It is always a nice experience.
EM
Emil Wisekal
I had dinner here 3 times and tried to like it, but eventually decided it was not up to my standards. If someone invites me again Ill go though.
ME
Medium Jaret
Pasta night is on Tuesdays and they prepare your custom pasta dish right in the dining room. Great ambiance. Great food. JUST GO!
LO
Louise Share
Party off 10 excellent service excellent food everything was delicious from Veal chop to shrimp parm and veal parm
TI
Tim Schoeneman
Very nice atmosphere, great deals, excellent Italian food and customer service. Definitely would recommend.
SE
Seth Mielke
great lunch special with a salad, main dish, coffee and ice cream. The baked ziti was fantastic.
EM
emily klein
Dont waste your money ! Not impressed and highly disappointed ! Terrible Italian cuisine !
SY
Sylvia Murdolo
The food is very good. Been coming for Easter dinner for years and special occasion.
MA
Maria Mir
Nice atmosphere, good service, average prices for the fare and good food.
JO
John Marra
I have eaten here many times. The food is good and reasonably priced.
GE
George Lewis
Great pasta dishes! Service was good too. I had no complaints at all.
ST
Steve Augello
Visiting from Florida. Enjoy the stretch pizza with mushroom....
LA
laura jacobellis
amazing food, amazing people, my favorite Italian restaurant
KA
Kaitlin Skorcik
Staff was great, decor lacking, food was a disappointment
DI
Dianna Lello
The food was very good . The dessert was even better !
PH
Philip Nociforo
Awesome food and atmosphere every time with my family
CI
cindy schneider
Best pizza in town always crowded, but worth it
OL
Olivia Figueroa
Clean, staff very friendly. Foods excellent
RA
Ray Schmidt
Food is excellent and great service
JU
Judy Fischer
Food and service were impeccable
RO
Roger Flye
Good food and good people always
LE
Leo Hernandez
Excellent service great food.
AN
Anette Stalsberg
Their food is amazing
JO
Joe Barilla
Good Italian food
CA
Carolina Daino
Great place to eat
AN
Antonino Atl
Not nice
AM
Amable Then
Ok
