The New Yorker Pizza & Restaurant
| Address: | 3 Petaluma Blvd N, Petaluma, CA 94952, USA |
| Phone: | +1 707-766-0517 |
| Rating: | 4.3 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–2AM 11AM–2AM 11AM–9PM |
Location
Photos 53
Reviews 11
TA
Taylor B
Me and my friend went here tonight and Im extremely disappointed in the service. We sit down at our table and after a long while the waitress comes up and asks for our order. We both ask for pizza by the slice but she proceeds to tell us we can only order that outside. Confused, we gather our purses and go outside..We have no idea where to go. In the cold we begin looking around and finally see a table that looks like it might be where we get the pizza. We tell the man standing by the table that we would like a pizza slice. He tells us the price and we pull out our debit cards. We are then informed they only take cash for the slices. Neither of us have cash. And nobody told us this before we gathered up our stuff and left our table and went into the cold. He was like, I dont know what to tell you. We are standing there extremely confused wondering why we cant just order a pizza slice in a normal manner. We stand there while he goes back and forth between inside and outside trying to figure out the situation (still standing in the cold). Finally they tell us to just go back inside and sit down. (Were still very confused by everything). We get our pizza slice. The waitress then comes up and says, Now dont leave without paying. Which, as a server, youre not really supposed to make your customers feel like potential criminals FYI. So me and my friend are finally eating in peace, enjoying our pizza, a glass of wine, and good conversation. The waitress then comes up and out of nowhere asks us, Are you ready yet?..... When I CLEARLY had a mouth full of food and a glass of wine in my hand. Taken back we say no. After finishing we proceed to the register to pay. Our waitress is at the register. She huffs and puffs about how we decided to come pay when she was the most busy. Me and my friend then quietly start discussing the payment because she realized she left her debit card in the card. The waitress then makes a snide remarking saying "Dont have any money?" Which Im guessing she made since were young college students. Clearly we have money or we wouldnt be eating at a restaurant. All in all an overall disappointing experience, especially considering we went because a friend recommended it. Poor and unfriendly service.
A
A Private User
Ok so pretty much me my husband and two other married couples with there kids go to this place to check it out we go in it was all good the waitress gave one of the moms that was with us attitude because her kid was playing with the napkin and it was really rude its a 4 year old kid but we forgot about it ordered our pizza and we ate let me say Ive eaten new york pizza this has no resemblance whats so ever but it was still good enough to eat we ordered like 3 large pizzas and when we were finished we payed and got our stuff to leave but right about the time we were living through the door the waitress came screaming, crying saying how we left her a horrible tip and how she didnt charge us gratuity, we have never been so insulted we asked her why she didnt charge us we are more than capable to pay it even though all three of use left more than a $10 dollar tip and on top of how she acted we had to go to a atm for cash because they dont accept credit ok Im sorry but who the hell doesnt accept credit anymore" like only little quick marts maybe, so everything she was crying i mean crying i was so surprised and embarrassed she would act in suck a manner look i dont care if you just got a 50 cent tip but you dont put a show like that its really REALLY bad for business but we gave her more tip anyway left it on the table and left never stepping a foot near that place again its up to you if you want to go but at least in my experience not so great pizza, price was ok, worst service ever shoot i keep telling people this story.
A
A Private User
Love the old-fashioned feel, home cooking, and friendly smiles. It reminds me of how eating out used to be. But what amazes me every single time is how fabulous the eggplant parmesan is! I thought I made the best eggplant parm in the world, but there is no comparison. My family gets different pasta dishes and pizza each time we go and they rave about how wonderful it tastes, but I have yet to order anything other than the eggplant parm...I just cannot get enough! Grazie per i pasti meraviglioso!
A
A Private User
My wife and I were driving through and decided to stop and eat at this place. I ordered the meatball sandwich and my wife ordered the chef salad. The meatballs were nasty and since my wife also tried the meatballs we both had stomach pains afterwards. The tables were sticky, flies everywhere, and my wifes salad was not fresh and the dressing was nasty. The waitress was nice and service was good, BUT the food and ambiance needs a lot of help.
A
A Private User
By far our favorite pizza place in town. And should anyone who knows me think that Im biased because my daughter married into "the family" I can tell you it was our favorite place for pizza BEFORE we had a direct personal connection. Love the house pizza...calzones...best bread sticks ever...awesome meatballs...and the one thing we never skip is the sauteed spinach! I highly recommend this place!
EM
Emri Bullock
I went there with my friend and we shared a 12" half pepperoni half cheese pizza. It was all delicious!! The service was wonderful and it gives off such a cozy feeling when you walk in. I love how the pizza had such a wonderfully thin crust and the amount of cheese and pepperoni was more than perfect! You must go to the New Yorker if you are ever in Petaluma.
GR
Greg Marlow
Great place for to pick up a slice of New York pizza for lunch. Been here for dinner as well and really liked the old-fashioned, family feel of the place. Have a great selection of different pasta dishes and pizzas, and the service was really good. Had the meat calzone one time and it was also really good. Will be back.
A
A Private User
Throughly dig on the joint. Im hooked on the veggie, spinach, mushroom, mozzarella only calzone. My hubby, not a calzone fan loves the all meat calzone. We are big fans on the food and the owners are adorable too. If you did not notice, we strongly recommend this joint.
A
A Private User
all i know is that the pizza was so good they decided to stay open late on friday and saturday til 2:30 am so the bar patrons could enjoy some as well. If you dont like there pizza then there is something wrong with you personally not the food. The food is very good.
RI
Ricky Alvarez
Food & Service were great. Order the breadsticks, you wont be sorry... They charge you more if you use a credit card which, although is fare (e.g. they have to pay a service fee), is perceived as a negative...
SH
Shelly Roy
Food is good, service is not so much. And they are extremely inflexible when it comes to special requests. We asked for cheese on our garlic bread and meat sauce in place of regular marinara and were told no.
