Petaluma Pie Company
| Address: | 125 Petaluma Blvd N, Petaluma, CA 94952, USA |
| Phone: | +1 707-766-6743 |
| Site: | petalumapiecompany.com |
| Rating: | 4.4 |
| Working: | 9AM–7PM 9AM–7PM 9AM–7PM 9AM–7PM 9AM–9PM 9AM–9PM 9AM–7PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 38
EL
Elizabeth Scott
I have done a lot of baking and appreciate great pastry. These pies taste and feel hand crafted which makes them well worth the price. The fruit tastes like its fresh off the tree. I had apricot pie while apricots were in season. I got the lemon meringue as well and it was perfection. Service is outstanding and the park setting adds to the charm. AND - they went out of their way to provide water for my dog.
MA
Marcia Carey
Best pies ever! They use local and organic ingredients. The pies taste so good and I feel good about eating both the savory and sweet pies! They have a cute little indoor eating area and a very pleasant outdoor eating area in the square. Very friendly helpful owners and staff. I have been enjoying their pies, eating in and take home, from Petaluma Pie Company for at least five years. Love, love. love them!
CH
Charley Galdamez
The organic Elvis mini pie was perfection. Whipped peanut butter, chocolate, and vanilla cream with a bottom layer of bananas...oh yeah, peanuts to top it off. Their pie crust is always delicious and well cooked. Ive been here a bunch of times over the years and it always hits the spot. There is indoor and outdoor seating. They keep water readily available to flush down the goodness as well.
MI
Mindy M
funky little place. Good crust, although they roll it out a bit thicker than I prefer. I tried the chocolate cream pie and it was tasty. Id love to come back and try some of the meat pies, but they were all sold out. *we tried the strawberry rhubarb on a subsequent trip and it was SO good it converted my 3 picky eaters instantly to rhubarb fans!
MI
michael brooks
This place is pretty good. Standard creative flavor mixes and toppings / twists to classics. They are mini pies and hand pies. Decent prices for high quality goods. I will certainly stop here anytime going north. Quaint shop and lovely display. They totally win with the outdoor seating game in that lovely courtyard.
BH
Bhairavi Kulkarni
Such a cute little pie shop! We had the apple pie and the chocolate cream with coconut flakes. Loved both of them! Very friendly and helpful staff. There is some indoor seating and also cute red chairs for outdoor seating. Dont miss the sign in the outdoor seating area! Definitely going again!
MA
Marina V
Yum! What an awesome place! We split 3 pies: cheeseburger pie, chicken pot pie and strawberry rhubarb pie. Soo good! Love how they source ingredients locally,organic where possible. And they recycle the pie tins right there, very thoughtful! Loved this place!! Highly recommend :)
JO
Jon Robichaud
Really wanted to love this place. Sadly it was just OK. The cheese burger pie seemed to lack cheese and the flavors were ok. The strawberry dark chocolate pie was good but the strawberries seems to be more like jam. Great little vibe and offering of options though.
SE
Sean Thorniley
Very nice little spot with really nice food. It is all about pies of the eat em with your hands style. Eat them Savory, East them Sweet, they area always a tasty treat. They do sell out at times so call ahead, or go before evening to get that seasons stand outs!
PE
Petronila Esther Mandeno
Been here twice so far and plan many more visits. The veggie pies are great. I had a Japanese inspired curry (I think) and a mushroom and cheese pie. Both were excellent. Good soup too. Portions are perfect. Great staff. A little pricey, but worth it!
HA
Hanh Pham
Delicious dessert and savory pies! I had a key lime one and it was super tasty. It wasnt super sweet and even ate the limey whipped cream (usually, I hate frosting or whipped cream). Good thing, it was a small pie or else it wouldve been dangerous.
CH
Chris sisemore
This is a Petaluma gem; I recommend it not for its dessert pies, but for its savory meal pies. My favorite lunch is a mushroom goat gouda hand pie. Stop by and get a delicious savory pie (they have especially delicious vegetarian options).
KE
Kevin Ryan
A bit pricy but very delicious sweet and savory pies baked fresh daily. Good vegetarian options if theyre not sold out. Solid coffee and great service. Quaint pedestrian plaza outside is a great place to enjoy your pit stop here.
AN
Ann Ruengvivatpant
The Elvis pie was everything we wanted it to be! Mini dessert pies are perfect for two. Salad was a bit strong on the dressing and Cornish pasty was not bad. Will be back to try the cheeseburger hand pie!
EL
Elh Hel
This place it great. It is consistent and I have been going for a couple years now. I love the banana cream pie, but the Jamaican burger is my new favorite. Best meat pie Ive ever had, hands down.
BR
Bruce Higgins
They offer a number of organic items. All items are freshly made on the premises and I have thoroughly enjoyed all varieties Ive tried so far...especially the organic salted caramel apple pie!
TY
Tyler Harding
Yum! Had the hand pie (collard greens) and soup (pumpkin curry) combo, and really enjoyed both of them. Maybe just a tad pricey for quantity of food, but its tough to beat on a cold day.
PE
Peter Pavlovic
Amazing press and empanadas! There are meat, vegetarian and vegan options to speak to everyone. They taste just like theyre home made and theyre cheap too. The cherry pie is worth it.
RO
Ron Filion
Heavenly pies! The crust was amazing. They also have an Elvis pie (next time). Definitely a dessert destination. They also have savory pies (next time).
NO
North Bay Smiles
We love the pie, the little lunch hand-pies, the cookies!!!, and, oh, yeah, the pie. Did we say pie? Especially the Elvis pie, oh my goodness.
TI
Timmy Crew
They make way more than just desert pies & they have so much varieties. Theyre so nice to everyone thats also why I love being there.
DA
Daniel Lindstrom
Amazing little pie shop! All natural, organic ingredients, incredible taste! We got the peach blueberry crumble mini pie. Unreal!
NI
Nick Luciani
Amazing pies. They charge them every season and they have freshly made hot cocoa. Their little pies are great for grab and go
BE
Benny Varkel
We stopped in after dinner @ Dempseys for desert & coffee. Mostly whipped cream on the banana cream pie & coffee was awful.
DO
Donna DiPace
This quaint little store offers amazing pies. Definitely worth the stop for an afternoon delight, salty or sweet!
NA
Nathan
Had a very good meat pit. I had a cheese burger pie. The lady their was very nice and the place is pet friendly.
RY
Ryan Williamson
Always the best pies. Seasonal fruit pies, some classics, and some excellent savory pies. And large pies!
MA
Mark Eliasson
Absolutely love this place. We stop by anytime we are in Petaluma. Only wish they had one in Napa.
CH
Chad Dunbar
Pies are great for once in a while outings. Prices are a bit high for my taste but worth a visit.
BR
Bryan Goff
I just had to try the bacon and egg pie. It did not disappoint. Highly recommended. Very tasty.
RA
ran haimoff
Felt baked pies in all tastes and sizes. Fun to take and eat in the little Park right outside
JE
Jenny Suoja
Love this place ❤ Great prices for wonderful ingredients, food, and people who really care!
XI
Xinmei Cai
Ordered a savory pie and a sweet one. Nothing special. The crust doesnt have much flavor.
RI
Richard Brennan
Try the rhubarb - berry pie with a side of the artisan vanilla ice cream!!!! Killer...
JO
Jon Yen
Tasty but not cheap... Got a spinach egg & cheese pie + chocolate chip cookie for $8
WA
Warren Katzenstein
A small shop that is a hidden gem. Always stop here when I pass through Petaluma.
JO
John Backues
Banana cream pie was just bananas with whipped cream. Boring and boring...
LI
Lincoln K
Tastes good, but for the portion size, it should be bigger in my opinion.
