Colony House Restaurant
| Address: | 25811 119th St, Trevor, WI 53179, USA |
| Phone: | +1 262-862-2076 |
| Site: | colonyhouserestaurant.co |
| Rating: | 4.3 |
| Working: | Closed 4–9:30PM 4–9:30PM 4–9:30PM 4–10PM 4–10PM 3:30–8:30PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 32
AN
Anthony Martorina
I simply love this place. It has one of the best Friday fish frys around. You can get a $1 off if you eat between 5-6pm. Who doesnt love a good deal. The fish can be battered or broiled. I personally love the battered. Hey its called a fish fry. I typically choose the potato pancakes but you do have a choice of fries too. Just make sure you ask for non burned pancakes. It is a thing here but they will search for a perfect one to serve you. There is also a great happy hour in the bar that goes from 4-5pm. Gary is the bartender and he is just a drink making machine. He knows the regulars and I hope to one day qualify to be a regular. The owner and service is fantastic. This place is a hidden gem and unlike any restaurant you will find in Wisconsin. I love the colder months around Christmas because the inside has beautiful lights that just make this place feel like home.
LO
Lori Dorn
I introduced my husband to Colony House 6 years ago. I had nothing but great food and wonderful service there and wanted to share it with him. We really only go out to eat for our "special" occasions so we are there two to three times a year. They have never ever disappointed us. The food is always fantastic and the service is even better. I cant unwrap a package of breadsticks without someone coming to the table to retrieve the wrapper and ask if we need more. They are gracious and thoughtful and beyond attentive. And did I mention that the food is fabulous?? We hope to continue our visits there for many years to come.
A
A Private User
Well we ate here on Saturday, and it was a pretty bad experience. I remember the times when I was younger, and the food and service was great. First off, took over 10 minutes just to get a drink, then our orders took a while to come out, my scallops were burnt. Also one member in our group, did not get their meal until 15 minutes after everybody (really)? I know you get lots of food, but it was overall not that good. Place has really went downhill, sadly will never be back!
JI
Jim Svehla
The colony house is our favorite place for Friday fish fry. The atmosphere is great and the service outstanding. My wife has special diet needs and they have been very accommodating fixing a special plate with the foods that she needs. We frequent the Colony House often and have never been disappointed. If you are in the Trevor area stop bye you will not be disappointed.
BI
Bill Risk
Well, what can we say... we love you all! Our final reservations are this Saturday and then we are moving to Florida. I am sure that we will NEVER find a better place for prime rib, steaks and seafood. Your servers and bartender are people that we will miss as well! Thanks for a spectacular dining experience these last 23 years we have been visiting your establishment
BE
Bernedette Nelson
This was our first time coming here and we were very disappointed. The service was very good but the food was awful. The shrimp de jonghe was burnt, the Salmon was overcooked and dried out, the lamb chops were very fatty and old tasting, and the Eggplant parmesan was over fried and over baked.
CH
Chris Porter
Their fish fry is good, just not as good as it used to be. My husband enjoys their reasonably priced prime rib. Great atmosphere and service. Reservations are a must on Fridays and Saturdays if you want to sit in the main dining room and not be banished to the basement.
KR
Kristen Parks
The atmosphere and service was great. The homemade soups and steak were both awesome. The crab stuffed flounder was not as good. There wasnt much crab and tasted very fishy. I still recommend this place but not the fish plate.
IT
Itz._. Kay
There food is sooo bad it took forever to get are food and when we did it was so bad there were 3 French fries on my plate and the chicken tenders were wet Dont wast your time there go somewhere else to eat such a bad experience
D
D Di Pompeo
Best darned Fish Fry in the Chain of Lakes region ,..BUT I wont stop there ,. Colony House has a great all around menu,. Steaks, Seafood ,... Great Place, Great Service and always a GREAT TIME !!
DA
Damon Chandler
The service was outstanding. The food was so delicious I cant even begin to describe it. The atmosphere made you feel like you belonged there no matter what you wear. A+ all around.
BI
Bill Mellen
Always great food, friendly service, reasonable priced food and drinks. A must if you are in the area or even if your not. Try there dinning downstairs for quieter atmosphere.
LI
linda skweres
Sweet country supper club. Delicious dinner.. included cheese dip,crackers warm bread with soup and salad. Ordered haddock fish and chips.. Friday fish fry superb!
BR
Brandon S.
I know it is out of the way. However it is worth it just for the seasonal mushroom soup. The dining area is very elegant and romantic, and the staff is fantastic.
JO
Joyce Hovel
Great food, prime rib every day. Would of given 5 stars but a waitress was giving us a to go box and we didnt even eat yet. Key lime pie martini was delicious!!!
A
A Private User
Use to be good; but ever since their flooding incidents, food has become more expensive and the quality of the food has gone down. Owner is also very rude.
MR
MrBloggyC
Very good and food tastes amazing. Order the hot wings and soup of the day. All out amazing experience servers are nice and the bar tender is very cool.
A
A Private User
Burnt fish. Elbows to rear ends. Shady kitchen help smoking out back. Dangerous parking. Located next to wastewater treatment. Whats not to like?
TE
Ted Mall
A classy place for prime rib, steaks and seafood. Attentive service, basic American food done very well. Wonderful ambience. Enjoyed my visit.
RE
Renada Carpen
Watch out on a split bill they stole the cash & charged my card double. Old looking steaks no veggie included on plate just potato.
WI
William Jones
Great Wisconsin Supper Club. Nice bar and lounge, and fantastic cocktails. Great menu and specials that are always changing.
JI
Jim Odom
We had a party of 21 people and not a one was disappointed with the quality or quantity. Fifth visit and more to come.
FL
Flying Right
One of the finer restaurants in the Antioch area. Been coming here for occasions 25 years. Never had a bad experience
D
D Mayer
Have always enjoyed my meals there. Love that most come with a soup and salad. I miss that at resteraunts these days.
PE
Peter Ihlen
Fish fry is excellent. It can get loud on the main floor so ask for the basement if you want a quieter experience.
RA
Randi Mcrobbie
Charming decor - but too loud - ruins the atmosphere- service was bad & food was just o.k., bland for my tastes
KE
Kevin Mack
Have a great dinner at an old farm house. Great staff. Good for larger groups due to the size of this place.
TI
Tina Adams
I love going here, their fish fry is the best! The service is excellent and over all a great experience.
CR
craig hintt
Amazing steaks ! Never disappointed when we come here. Make reservations if you can. You will need them.
AN
Anthony Giovingo
Great old Wisconsin supper club. Food is outstanding and service is always friendly and relatively fast.
AS
Ashley Bakutis
Every visit is a night to remember. Great food, friendly staff, neat old house and a wonderful evening.
CO
Construction Man
Best damn prime rib Ive had in a long time!!!! Absolutely recommend this place. Love it!!!
