Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Reviews 43

JA

Jason R

I ordered my sandwich and watched as the employee got a replacement scale from the soup table as the sandwich line scales batteries had died. They did not wipe down the soup scale and started putting the meat for my sandwich on top of the water and goo rings on the scale from the soups that had been weighed on it previously. It was then that I said something and they set the meat aside and wiped down the scale. Then I asked for a wax paper protective sheet and they then used wax paper they found somewhere else to keep the meat for my sandwich sanitary. I have serious doubts about the health hazards and sanitary conditions of this place and have stopped eating here. I thought I had found a great place as they had great sandwiches and the turkey kale soup was amazing. But now when I drive by and think of getting food here, it turns my stomach. Dont take your chances, food poisoning isnt fun.

---

JI

Jim Minard

I love the food, but the place is always desperately under-staffed. Every time I walk in there is a 50/50 chance I turn around because theres a huge backlog, and not because its peak time but because there are only 2 people working! Even during lunch time on weekends there are only 4 people working which is crazy. I would go there twice as often if they learn how to staff adequately and didnt have to wait 20-40 minutes for a sandwich

---

NA

Nathan Johnson

The Mediterranean Sandwhich was very good on wheat bread. This place is lot like Quiznos. I got there at 6:30 and beat the rush that came in right around 7:00. Service was a bit slow though. Right State Street so you can people watch.

---

DA

Darren Wacker

Services was slow and the sandwich is not as good as I have had at other Potbelly franchises. They seemed understaffed and a little harried. Servers tried to be polite, but were being torn in too many directions at the same time.

---

SA

Sam

Good food, service, & shakes! My favorite part is the mini shortbread cookies they put on the straw of your shake. They also had live entertainment tonight. Makes the place have a great atmosphere!

---

MA

Matt Lynch

Food is good, and reasonably priced, but the way the food-prep is structured (single toasting oven) means that the wait can get a bit long when you have more than a few people.

---

A

A Private User

The food isnt awesome, but its edible. However, the delivery girl is off the chain. Which, I do believe, means very attractive in todays vernacular.

---

TI

Tim Borgstrom

Fun atmosphere with live music sometimes. Decent price great sandwiches. They also have shakes soups and a few dessert items

---

LI

Linda Brown

The food is delicious! Just not that convenient for a person who walks with two canes! Wish there was one in Sun Prairie!

---

KY

Kyle Geissler

Delicious! The live music is a nice touch, but a little too loud if youre hoping to have a conversation.

---

GE

Geoffrey Rogers

Exceptional sandwiches, especially the grilled chicken chedar. Shakes are a real hidden highlight too!

---

SH

Shane A. Smith

My favorite place on campus. Could not have enough chicken salad sandwich. And their soup options...

---

MA

Matthew Spencer

Really good bread. They usually have a guy playing some tunes. Get the hot peppers on your Sammie.

---

JO

Jose Sanchez

Best sandwich place in Madison! Their chicken cheddar & shakes are amazing! Definitely recommend

---

KE

Ken R

Great sandwiches, live music during lunch rush, good place to people watch on State Street.

---

A

A Private User

Delicious sandwiches, good atmosphere (student-oriented) and fast and entertaining staff.

---

TR

Travis Morton

Great sandwiches and shakes. Live music on Thursdays makes for a nice atmosphere.

---

JO

John Caputo

Sandwiches and soups are great.. .shakes are fantastic! A must try in this area.

---

JE

Jessica Marie Billman

Good grilled chicken and cheddar sandwiches. Love the Mocha Oreo shakes as well.

---

EV

Evan Humphries

the food was great service great and the decor was cool seating was convenient

---

AN

Andrew McOlash

Great food. Quick service and in my opinion the best quick sandwiches around.

---

JA

James Ziglinski

Good food, but not worth the price. There are better options on State St.

---

FE

Fernando Martínez

Food tasted really good like all potbellies, the staff was friendly too

---

DA

Daniel Hoppe

Love the pizza sandwich and dream bars Went here for my sisters birthday

---

KU

Kun Zhang

A-Wreck sandwich is awesome!! Their soups and shakes are also nice.

---

AN

Anantharaghavan Sridhar

A quick place to satisfy a sandwich craving. Good for vegetarians.

---

LU

Luke VandenLangenberg

Great subs. Love the Oreo shake. Live music during certain times

---

GL

Glenn Anderson

Met the original spiderpig here it was tasty af bro #spiderpig

---

DA

Dave Alcorn

Pizza sandwiches are the best! Great soup and shakes too!

---

MA

Machlen Polfliet

Yet another awesome Potbellus location. Fantastic food.

---

KI

Kira Blaschka

Food was really good but staff were extremely mean.

---

AL

Alberto Montes

Pretty good sandwiches but kind of small servings

---

GA

Gaurav Poudyal

Love the chicken bacon sandwich here.

---

SO

Sophia Carayannopoulos

Good service just the food was bland

---

JE

Jerome McKibben

Good hot sandwiches and great shakes

---

CH

Charlie Laabs

Friendly service from the cashier.

---

RI

Richard Garsnett

Friendly people and good sandwich

---

RY

Ryan Schmudlach

Good subs. Long live the Italian.

---

BE

Ben Pfab

Good soup for an okay price

---

RO

Robert Haas

Subs... were... AMAZING!!!

---

DE

Dennis Brower

Very unique, great food.

---

CH

Christina Lorino

Great toasted subs.

---

JA

Jason Lowe-Power

Just ok.

---

---