Address: | 101 Broad St, Lake Geneva, WI 53147, USA |
Phone: | +1 262-203-5193 |
Site: | bestoflakegeneva.com |
Rating: | 4.4 |
EL
Elizabeth Capdevielle
Plus side: Large scoops, many flavors--and theyre such good flavors! Natural- tasting when you order the natural-looking ones (Superman doesnt taste natural--but why would it!? :-). They were generous with the toppings, too, and I could see that the friendly guy behind the counter was careful and neat about his work. He gave us good reason to tip well, which we did. The location is good in that you can sit at the (nice clean) tables outside to watch people go by, and you have a great view of the lake. The service was fast and generally pleasant, and the place was clean. Neutral: I did not try the strawberry topping, which is always the key test to whether an ice cream place cares about actually good, natural ingredients. So, someone else should comment on whether the strawberry topping/shake flavoring is good. (If they use defrosted real frozen strawberries in their own juice, it will be delicious, but if they use strawberry syrup or canned topping, you might as well go to McDs or eat a strawberry tootsie roll.) The place is local seeming, not big chain-like, because it doesnt look all smooth and prefab--and thats good--but it also doesnt have charm or feel inviting. Theres a goofy, brightly colored, hand-painted mural on the wall, which is fun, but since youre not expected to spend time inside, you might not notice it. Your experience will be weather-dependent. Minus side: Mainly I was disappointed about atmosphere combined with price. This is NOT what I imagine as an old-fashioned ice cream shop at all! Its like a Baskin-Robbins, which is designed for you to stop in for a treat and then walk out carrying it. There are only a couple of tiny tables inside, and theyre not inviting because youd feel you were in the way of the standing people in line if you were to sit down. Everything is paper or plastic with a to-go, utilitarian look to it. No fancy dishes for sundaes or frosty tall glasses for ice cream sodas. No extra-special signature treats in shareable proportions. This despite the fact that a 2-scoop sundae is almost $9. Even this double order is designed for one person to carry while walking (and that person clearly is expected to overeat). I was taking my kids out for a special treat after my son finished a big school project. And $30 just for dessert is a lot for us to spend. So, I wish we could have had a more delightful experience overall. For example I would have liked to sit at a cute table and enjoy fancy looking treats in glass dishes, while also enjoying the people-watching and the lake town feeling. Not sure if such an old-fashioned ice cream parlor and sweet shop sort of place exists in Lake Geneva (though the prices do). Unfortunately one of my sons (who loves chocolate) did not like the taste of the hot fudge sauce. He had to pick around it. Also the other employee--who served us part of the time, was unsmiling and seemed put out or at least overly businesslike. (She was balanced out by the sweet young guy who recommended certain flavors and took so much care to make the sundaes nicely.) I gave it 4 stars for its many good points, but I could wish for better.
AN
Andrea Fitch
Looks cute but sadly upon entering the establishment and waiting to order...the person who Im assuming was the owner/manager angrily yelled at a women coming in holding the door for her 2 very small children because apparently she was taking too long for him. He yelled at her to SHUT THE DOOR! And afterward continued to mumble and groan about the heat outside etc... Too bad, I was looking forward to ice cream but will not spend my money at a place that treats customers in such a manner!
JO
Jordon Data
Shop manager was rude to a mother and her children, then proceeded to mutter about their ignorance under his breath. There is a way to go about asking someone to close the door. We wanted to get an ice cream, but just couldnt spend our money there afterwards.
ST
Stephanie Hanson
We found this place accidentally while driving through the state. My GPS was still in my hand failing to find any ice cream in my search. Excellent ice cream. Many interesting creative flavors. Small friendly place. Just wish I drove there more often!
UR
Urszula Wudarczyk
This past Labor Day weekend we took our motorcycles up to the lake from Chicago. The ice cream selection was fantastic, as long as you looked past the odd names. Great place to stop to cool off.
MA
Matt Schmader
I had a waffle bowl sundae. The lady who made it took so much care in placing the cherry on top (to get it *just* right) that I got choked up. I would eat ice cream here every day with my family.
MA
Manan Shah
The ice cream is great. Even better is the extensive choice of flavor. Definitely worth a visit. The only thing is, on busy weekends or holidays like labor day, the line can get pretty long.
NI
Nicholas Kathrein
Great ice cream place near the lake. Prices arent bad and there are a lot of options. The banna split is big and 2 or 3 can split it. That is the best bang for the buck.
DE
Dennis Kehoe
Great flavor, several unique and creative flavors like the Peanut butter cookie dough that I tried. Excellent location right off Riviera Beach in Downtown Lake Geneva.
DE
Denise Carroll
On a really hot day by the lake, this ice cream was delicious. Very creamy and the bowl was packed full for the price. Good value. Will come back.
DA
Dan Szymanski
Always an enjoyment, never a disappointment. Been coming here every time I go lake Geneva since I was about 8 yrs old, now 32. Best ice cream around.
JO
Joshua Smith
You shouldnt visit Lake Geneva without stopping in here for an ice cream. The scoops were so large, my cone was difficult to finish!
YE
YESICA LOPEZ
They have the best freshly done coffee...u didnt even add sugar to it and it is really good..better than dunkin doughnuts!
ST
Stephen Sherwood
Are you kidding me!?! This has to have been a collaboration between angels and devils. because place is so good its bad.
EI
Eileen C
Superman ice cream was so good! Will definitely be coming back here when Im in the area again.
BE
Ben Williams
Can you honestly say you went to lake Geneva without getting ice cream here?! SOOO GOOD!
BU
Burhan Shakil
Very good selection of flavors. Owner was very friendly. Very large scoops.
FR
Francesca Deir
Smells good inside, service was great. You definitely get your moneys worth.
EJ
EJ Rodell
Nice little ice cream shop but is a little pricey for larger families.
GA
Garrett Pfarr
They have a fun selection of icecream. Though the wait was a bit long
EL
Elizabeth H
Delicious ice cream, huge portions, super clean, and great service.
TI
Timothy Paneitz
Pricey.. But so yummy and great location right by the water.
JA
Jacqueline Navarro
Love this place!!! A must have everytime we are visiting.
MI
Mike Drew
Lots of flavors and options for your ice cream pleasure
GR
Grant Cassiday
Excellent selection of creative flavors, worth finding.
NI
Nick Melchi
Great ice cream, great selection. Would recommend.
IM
IM n0cternul
Hand scooped is always better. Great little shop.
RA
Ray Saunders
Convenient when youre at the beach or the park.
BR
Brian McNally
Owners a jerk go to Kil wins around the corner
HU
Huy Nguyen
Odd flavors ice cream...for the adventurous.
RI
Richard Johnson
Many varieties of flavors of ice cream, Yumm!
PA
Pam
Really good ice cream. Relaxing atmosphere.
CA
Camal Hibbler
Nice owner. Nice staffing come early.
AN
Andy Vogt
Is pricey, but the ice cream is great!
CO
Coyote Hunter Guido
Great ice cream!!! Lots of choices
SA
Sarah Hamrick
Great value and great ice cream.
JO
Josh kiscellus
Great flavors. Decent pricing.
WI
William Frits
Bet pricey but good variety!
JI
jim kvidera
Excellent place. Thanks Tim.
JE
Jeff Rank
Classic small ice cream shop
JA
Jacee Gilbert
Best Ice Cream Anywhere
TO
Tommy Tommy
Great treat for kids
PA
Paulie
Great selection.
DO
Dominik
Great ice cream