Wicked Pie Pizza
| Address: | 112 S Meridian, Puyallup, WA 98371, USA |
| Phone: | +1 253-256-4698 |
| Rating: | 4.5 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–1AM 11AM–1AM 11AM–10PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 30
BR
Bronson Johnson
My wife and I showed up about 6:45pm on a friday and our name was put on a list for a estimated 45 minute wait. No problem, we decided to sit in the small waiting area and chat. We were apologized to a few times for the wait, asked if we wanted waters or if we wanted to sit at the bar. Declined both, but loved the attention to service. After a 55 minute wait (it was worth it) we were seated. Good atmosphere, lots of ambient noise from people talking, but thats because everyone looked like they were having a good time. I ordered the fresh squeezed lemonade, sour and sweet and delicious. We started with the caprese salad. Delicious. Followed that with the cheesy bread. High quality crust, cheese, and perfect amount of seasoning made it an excellent choice. ORDER THE CHEESY BREAD! The marinara was good. We ordered a small pizza from the menu (cant remember the name) mushrooms, olives, pepperoni and sausage. Perfect size for two people with leftovers. Again, the crust was perfect, the toppings were fresh and we left happy. Finally a good pizza place in the area! My wife and I are pizza snobs having lived in Chicago for several years. All the other pizza places taste like cardboard, lol. Wicked does a good job meeting that Chicago level of good pizza. Service was great. Our cups stayed full, other servers helped out our table, which showed a cohesive team effort, and the owner Mary was working right beside her team. She introduced herself to us and thanked us for coming in. Will we go back? Most definately.
JE
Jeff
Great new place located downtown. Friendly service (Devynn) Thank you! Locally owned and also friendly. (Monica) Thank you! So happy it is not a Sysco foods supplied restaurant. The pizza was a mix between Shakeys (crust,yum!) and Pietros (small pepperoni circles, crisped edges are the best!) I had the classic, which is pepperoni and whole milk mozzarella. They have cold beer on tap and also wine. Not too loud for a lunch stop since its a 21 and over establishment and I was able to get caught up on some paper work. I will be trying this place on the weekends also.
CH
Chad West
The service is a little rough- well seasoned if you will more so than the pizza. The pizza has great simple ingredients, but as others were complaining, the flavor was a little lacking. Small beer selection of good quality beers that are hard to find and local. Beautiful place, the design of the restaurant is well done. Price was moderately high to match the ombionce and ingredients.
DI
Diana Rogers
Had an awesome Pizza a good cheesy bread awesome drinks after drink menu atmosphere was very pleasant were in here nine nine oclock at night very enjoyable very personable service if you place was packed it probably be a little bit less but I think it would be just as good good job keep up the good work
CA
cara victoria
Awesome awesome awesome. Employees were all wonderful, atmosphere, building are lovely, and all the food especially the pizza we ordered was so delicious! I would suggest this place to anyone, that loves pizza like me, and also a great place for drinks with friends on the weekend or after work
KI
Kim Parisi
We waited for about 30 minutes for a table. Monica our host was awesome. She went and got us drinks and was very friendly. The pizza was amazing. The owner came by and chatted with us. It was a great evening and great food. Will definitely go back.
MA
Mark Rogers
Pets good pizza there awesome cheesy bread awesome drinks good service even though we are there after 9 oclock earlier would be busy good staff even talked with the chef I would recommend to enjoy the pizza and anything else they serve there
JO
Josh Dunn
Really cool space and truly great pizza. Only criticism is that the drinks are all $1.50 more than they should be. $6.25 for a Mac & Jacks is a little overpriced (in Puyallup). Fast, polite service. Definitely will go back for the pie.
RE
Regina Rollis
Wow! Awesome New York style pizza in Puyallup! The "Wickeds No Equal" is great, well be back to try each of the other tasty, creative pie combos and wood fired hot wings, I cant wait! Great addition to Downtown Puyallup.
JA
James Gibson
First time in and wont be the last. Meatball grinder was absolutely delicious. The Pizza was just as good. Not a family place to take the kids but if you want a full bar and great food you should give this place a try.
JA
James Hale
Pleasant Surprise, place has amazing pizza. Got the classic Pep and it was the best pep pizza I have ever had. No bells, no whistles, just a great adult only pizza shop! Stop by here, you wont be disappointed.
L&
L&M LP
Havent gone! Probably wont now that I know it is 21 and over! As a parent would of been nice to have one less "BAR" in downtown Puyallup! Really disappointed that a pizza place isnt family friendly!
KA
Kay Ennis
Absolutely worth every bite. The atmosphere is eclectic and right in the middle of downtown. We had a small Twisted Pizza. Every bite was better than the first. Cant wait to try all the varieties.
MI
mikermilano
Wicked pie pizza is now open in puyallup and well worth the wait. Best pizza in puyallup! The service, food quality and value were amazing I wish I had the option to add a sixth star.
BR
Bruce Ward
Inside the restaurant has been brought to its original decor, beautiful. Wait staff was great, and the pizza was delicous. The flavor, oh my! We are going back to try the others.
MI
Michael Elliott
Pizza was really good with plenty of topping options. A tasty crust and coming out piping hot was a definite plus. Extraordinary not too much, but they try hard.
ME
Mel Salinas
Really good caprese salad, pizza, grinders, drinks. Been here multiple times and never disappointed with everything Ive tried so far. Great staff and owners!
PA
Patrick Amato
Excellent pizza and grinders. One of the few places that serve a canolli with proper Ricotta filling. This is an adult pizza parlor with a good bar.
TH
The Rogers Family
Food was outstanding & staff were wonderful. Felt spoiled by the time we left. It is one of the handful of places we plan to return for a second meal.
GR
Greg Whiting
Second visit for us...wonderful pizza with simply the best crust!!! Super welcoming staff...nice to see this place in Puyallup...we will be back!
RO
Robert Carlson
Found my new favorite pizza place in town. Great atmosphere, excellent drinks, and the thin crust pizza is exactly the way I like it.
CO
Connor Guthmueller
This place has some of the best food and atmosphere around. This place is a must if your looking for good pizza and drinks!
AN
Angela Carson
Good homemade ranch. Great pizza. Kinda wish kids were allowed for easier times but makes a great casual date night.
DE
Debra Beckwith
Great food and drinks! The staff is on top of things while you are there. The space has a nice home town feel to it.
AU
Autumn Fuqua
Wicked Pizza nailed it. Perfect restoration of old building; fantastic pizza; great bar. 21 and over. Love it!!
JA
James Wheeler
Great pizza, not the cheap stuff. Im a strong believer in you pay for the best and these guys are the best.
MA
marty mitchell
Great ambience, friendly service, wonderful out of this world food, small and intimate. Highly recommend!
EV
Evan Bragin
Wicked Crew Kickin it Through Servin Puyallup Pie Reachin for the Sky Gladys over Head Enough Said....
RO
Robin Wieland
Really good wings and pizza. GREAT drinks and for adults only..Prices are good and friendly service
JI
Jim Massey
The pizza, wings, and salad, and cider I had was very good. I will definitely go back again.
