Old Mill Pizza and Restaurant
| Address: | 5784 US-209 BUS, Sciota, PA 18354, USA |
| Phone: | +1 570-992-7009 |
| Site: | oldmillpizza.com |
| Rating: | 4.3 |
| Working: | 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–9PM |
Location
Photos 33
Reviews 45
JE
Jeremy M
Good place for Pizza, but if looking for some really good Italian food like a real Veal Parmigiana for instance this is not the place. And towards closing time the staff tends to just throw stuff together to get it done and get out, and it really shows in the food preparation quality. The hours arent good close at 9pm but really pretty much closed by 8:15 due to staff rushing out. The area deserves a place like this open til 10pm most nights, and improve to making more authentic dinners and get away from frozen style patty meats like the Veal
TW
Twosheds Jackson
Like New York pizza with a little less cheese grease. Everything I have had is excellent with the possible exception of the cheese steaks. Consistency is key for a restaurant, in my opinion! The first time I had one there it was one of the best I have ever had, but the second was rather dry and sparse on the meat. Which one is typical? Who can say? Not worth rolling the dice when restaurant food is so expensive.
AM
Amanda Bishop
I used to live in PA when I was little. My mom, dad and I used to come to the Old Mill fairly often. After my dad died my mom and I moved to FL but whenever I come home to visit my grandparents and the rest of my family we ALWAYS get pizza from here... I LOVE THIS PLACE!!! I miss it! They just dont make it like that in FL!
A
A Private User
food was great i had wings i wish they used more sauce though !!! steve mc danile is there almost every friday for happy hour and he is on of the best musicians in the poconos very good !!! bartender was very helpfull and the mix of ppl in there made it very interesting !!!!!
AL
Alan Semon
My familys favorite pizza place! Ive been getting pizza here for well over a decade. Their meals are good, their sandwiches are awesome and the pizza is very good. As a business they are very community-oriented.
MA
Mary Daly
My daughter and I agree, they make a great pizza. We ordered a small pepperoni and sausage pizza and ate it all! Very clean. Friendly staff and great service.we will be coming back soon.
ED
Ed Espo
been eating here for at least 7,8 years. great pizza, calzone, sausage roll, milk shakes ect. and oh yea, half off on left overs just before they close great if your on a budget .
OL
olivene young-nelson
The staff was very pleasant and helpful. Placed my order over the phone. The delicious food was hot and ready when I arrived. The accommodations was comfortable to eat in.
MA
Matt Forte
Ive stopped in to this location two times and have left with uncooked chicken. I refuse to go back and waste money and energy for a third time.
JE
Jeffrey Case
Food was very good. Restaurant was clean and comfortable, nice atmosphere in the dining area, friendly service.
DO
donna Vansickell
Pizza good, people polite, clean cheery and the bathrooms spotless. I see they have a banquet hall too,
IT
iTechnologyHelping
Very good pizza, but prices are a little higher than you would expect from a basic pizzeria.
WA
Walter Williams
Dont really care for this place. So many better options , even right up the road.
DY
Dylan Wilmont
Very expensive for what you get order of chicken fingers and a drink was $16
MA
Matthew Morton
I wont buy pizza anywhere else. Best pizza in a 100 mile radius. We LOVE it!
RI
Richard Bontempo
Lunch was great called ahead to save time Sicilian pizza was Delicious.
SC
Scott Nelson
Their gyros and greek salad is excellent! Pizza is very good as well!!
TO
Todd Borger
Nice place, good food, good service. Nice clean facilities.
JO
Joe Murphy
Owner is awesome. Good pizza, nice salads, friendly staff.
JO
Josh Pena
Courtney is great. Shes fun and the foods great too.
DE
Debra Schuler
Close to home, great food at great prices! BYOB!
DO
Doug White
Good pies, one of the better local pizzarias
AL
Alberto Rios
Good pizza great people nice environment
DE
Dee Blue
Delicious and Monday and Tuesday specials
ME
Mershon Gardner
Great pizza and family owned restaurant!
MI
Mike Allen
Great pizza, been going here for years..
JO
Jo Pal
Great wings at this hole in the wall
RI
Richard S
Good pizza and amazing Italian sub!
GL
global marketing
Great wings, good beer prices
SU
Susan Fontaine
Best place to eat and drink!
J.
J. Neil Della Croce
sausage and hot pepper pizza!
TO
Todd Hanlin
Great food..great service.
OL
Olga Ann Stuart
Great food fresh and tasty
GA
Gary Tirpak
Great food, great service.
AN
Andy Zastko
Excellent cheese steak.
TI
tim brusie
Good pizza good service
JA
Jason Brown
Great food, kind staff
SE
sean mcellhenney
Good food. Fun place
BR
Brain Viesewski
Great food and service
CH
chris hagerty
best pizza in the area
MA
Mari Bond
Loving the old mill
DA
David Yeakel
Took too long.
SH
Shailynn Race
Good pizza
RO
robbie wiliams
Good food
JE
Jessie Gonzalez
Good
