Old Fashioned Ice Cream
| Address: | 1025 Straight Path, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA |
| Phone: | +1 631-669-3020 |
| Rating: | 4.8 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–10PM |
Location
Photos 93
Reviews 45
DE
DEMELL JENKINS
I used to really love this place. They have a good staff of young locals working there. I love that as well. They have my 2 favorite flavors, Maple Walnut and pistachio. What more could I ask for right? Well theres one huge problem. The ice cream melts before you can even get to it. I literally love 5 minutes from this place. By the time I get home, all of our ice cream is basically milk. We then put in freezer for a while, before we can eat it. One employee suggested bringing a cooler. How about getting better freezers so youre not selling a poor example of a sundae. I cant go back because of this, even though I love the ice cream. Its not enjoyable in its liquid version.
KA
Katiana
Do yourself a favor & head on down to this amazing mom & pop ice cream parlor. They have a good variety of flavors at an affordable price, much better than any franchise you could purchase from. They also make ice cream cakes for your partying needs! The cherry vanilla ice cream flavor must be what God snacks on. Definitely worth a visit! Disclaimer: No, I was not paid by anyone to say these things. Actually, Im the one who paid.....for their delicious ice cream!
NA
Nancy Morgan
Well my sons birthday was yesterday so I went to Old Fashioned Ice cream I got an ice cream CAKE it was So Good my family really enjoyed it, it was in the freezer, but the taste was as if they had just made it the BEST AROUND TOWN, CHECK IT OUT, AND YOU CANNOT BE AT THE PRICE.WE LOVE YOU GUYS..Nancy from WYANDANCH. ..
LA
Larissa Jules
Love the ice cream here you know that there are not that many chemicals in this ice cream than others people are always coming in and out. But some of the people working there are try to give me less ice cream so watch out!
JO
Jonathan Eckhaus
Amazing ice cream shop with great flavors to choose from. The crew works very hard to keep the line moving quickly without losing quality customer service.
JO
John Meade
Extremely Nice people, Great Ice Cream Shop With Great Ice cream. Feels better supporting the local parlor over Carvel or other franchised places.
KR
Kristopher Lee
I didnt think it was possible to find an ice cream shop that served "Grape Nut" but here we are. This place is great, havent been disappointed yet!
DE
Desiree Mckoy
The MOST DELICIOUS ICE CREAM EVER, WE OFTEN HAVE DATE NIGHT HERE ITS THE BEST Cherry Vanilla ,or Strawberry thank you for always being the best
SA
Sara Clark
Such good ice cream. TONS of flavors but my favorite is their pumpkin ice cream. They have it all year long.
DA
Davida Corbett
Happiness is a chocolate dipped waffle cone with pistachio soft serve. Nice staff good ice cream
JO
Joe Cavallo
Ice cream is good but nothing spectacular. Inefficient serving, lines can be long at peak times.
L
L Mcpherson
Ice cream cup was not made right didnt like response giving when I inquired about it
RO
Rocco Prichinello
Family owned and operated for years, this is THE place for ice cream!
JE
Jennifer Alayo-Aguilar
I love this place. been coming here since I was a little girl. Kudos!
JA
Jason Reed
This place is awesome, the ice cream is some of the best Ive ever had
BI
Big Papa tippery
They have the truck stuff and hand packed as well..reasonably priced
CH
Chris Shataka
Best ice cream around hands down. Been going here for over 20 years
KA
Kay R
Love this place! Since childhood!!! Only place I get my ice cream!
BR
Brianna Hafez
Always amazing and yummy!been comming here since I was a kid
DA
Dan Novak
Helpful service and nice variety of interesting flavors.
CO
Colette Aristide
After 20 years still the best ice cream place ever.
CO
Colombianbig 89
Its one of the best ice cream places on that island
AM
Amy L. Gellineau
A community staple since I was a child. I love them
LU
Luis Salazar
They have amazing service and delicious ice cream
TE
Terrence Jackson
Mad good best ice cream in the neighborhood
WA
walnutz516 hah
Great ice cream better then carvel by far
CR
Cristina Conciatori
Yummy ice cream and super nice people.
RO
robert madera
Excellent ice cream, great service
DJ
Dj BIG MARK
This place has the best ice cream
MA
Mary Deppisch
Best ice cream on Long Island!!!!!
MU
Muneeb Hussain
Good ice cream. Good service.
WA
Wayne Wade
Best ice cream on long island!
SI
Siobhan Liza
Best ice cream in the world.
TA
Tariq Khan
No frills ice cream place
JA
jAzZyStAr1000
Great quality and price
ME
Melisa Dias
Great fresh ice cream.
JU
Justine Pitts-Howell
My FAVORITE since 1980
NI
Niceta Kebe
Best Ice Cream every
SH
shawnna mimms
Love there ice cream
KE
Kelvin Reyna
Love this place
MA
Mark Antenor
It was awesome
A
A Private User
Best ice cream
CH
christian espinal
Best on town
RI
Richard Kalender
Very tasry
NI
Nini Nini
Amazing!!
