American Pie
| Address: | 2044 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976, USA |
| Phone: | +1 631-613-6177 |
| Site: | hamptonsamericanpie.com |
| Rating: | 4.5 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM |
Location
Photos 44
Reviews 12
JA
Jared Reed
For those who lack restraint, it would be very easy to go broke in this place. The varieties of pizza are plentiful, and the ones Ive eaten so far have all been excellent. The Chicken Bacon Ranch and the Pastrami & Provolone are my favorites of all the specialty pies. On days Im feeling less adventurous, I tend to go with sausage and extra cheese slices. Those are great as well, not least of all because they actually slice the sausage meat instead of using those balled up pig droppings commonly found on lesser pizzas. Time and time again, I have proven to my cousins that the pizza from American Pie is far superior to that of their favorite pizza place in town. You can taste the effort and stress that go into each pie, and though it may sound gross, its actually very palatable and rewarding. About 90% of the staff there greets me happily, which is remarkably high. The seating can be a bit cramped at times, but I think the food is best enjoyed with Netflix and an ottoman anyway. I havent tried the frozen yogurt yet, but they offer many different flavors that are always very enticing. American Pie is a welcome reprieve from the cardboard crusts and terrible tomato sauces of certain chain pizzerias. I definitely recommend this place for your pizza needs.
A
A Private User
Thankyou American Pie for opening up in Bridgehampton! WE NEEDED YOU! Best Pizza in the Hamptons with healthy options.....including Yolicious.....the "RED MANGO" brand of frozen yogurt! Defintitely check this place out!
AN
Anna Verneuille
Great food & great service! Perfect for those nights when you need delivery - They are one of the few places in town who will deliver in Noyac, I would recommend the Hawaiian Pizza and the Meatball Garlic Knot Sliders
MA
Maria Teresa
Food is amazing... just when I would think I had a favorite, Id try something else offered and soon discover a completely new "favorite," until the next time... so many scrumptious choices, so little time!
E.
E. M.
Their pizza is one of the best out in the Hamptons. It is always fresh and their gelato is amazing. The staff is very friendly as well. Highly recommend going here :)
BA
Batyr Nuryyev
Best pizza Ive tried in my life. Diversity of menu, including not only pizza, but also pastas, salads, soups, and even ice cream
KR
Kristopher Bel
High quality ingredients and people who really care about making good food make this my favorite pizza place.
KA
Kate Penna
Best pizza in a 100 mile radius! The staff is friendly and aim to please. Prices are beyond reasonable!
YA
Yanira Hernandez
Best pizza in town. I wish they will have another location in southampton.
ST
Stephen Mcdonald
7 dollars, for 2 burnt cheese slices and a small Pepsi. Never again awful!
MA
Max Stauffacher
Excellent food and service! My favorite pizza place in New York period!
IS
Isai Bala
My friends dads pizzeria is amazing! Has high quality food
