Baked by Susan
| Address: | 163 Grand St, Croton-On-Hudson, NY 10520, USA |
| Phone: | +1 914-862-0874 |
| Site: | bakedbysusan.com |
| Rating: | 4.9 |
| Working: | Closed Closed 7AM–4PM 7AM–4PM 7AM–4PM 8AM–4PM 8AM–2PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 25
JI
Jill Jackson
Baked by Susan continues to provide high quality baked goods not only of the tried and true but also provides a number of new baked items as time goes on. All the people who work there are as lovely as Susan and are very helpful. You always meet the nicest people there. The environment is pleasant and there are places to sit and have coffee and cake. It is a real pleasure to have Baked by Susan in town. Her Buche de noel is superb and my family enjoys it every Christmas. I always take my out of town guests there for breakfast.
SA
Sallie Zuch
Susan is the best! I worked with her last fall to create just the right cake for our daughters wedding. She is creative, responsive and reasonable. But most importantly, the cakes she bakes are delicious and made with so much love and integrity. The ingredients are of the highest quality which you can taste in every bite. I loved the way she made the buttercream. She followed our directions to a tee. I do hope we have the chance to do something special with her and her team again.
CH
Chuck Rinka
This bakery is without a doubt the best around. They make the best frigging pumpkin pie anywhere. I never liked pumpkin pie until Thanksgiving 2015 when I found this bakery. I now love pumpkin pie but only from Baked By Susan. They are the nicest most pleasant people to work with, always accommodating always great. I recommend Baked by Susan to anyone I know.
SU
Susan Calabro
i JUST WANTED TO SAY HOW MUCH WE LOVED THE VEGAN RED VELVET CAKE THAT BAKED BY SUSAN DID FOR ONE OF THE EMPLOYEES I WORK WITH. AS A VEGAN MYSELF, I WAS SO IMPRESSED WITH THE TEXTURE AND FLAVOUR AND THE BIRTHDAY BOY WAS OVER THE MOON. IM SO GLAD MY FRIEND RECOMMENDED YOU TO ME. I CANT WAIT TO TRY THE VEGAN BROWNIES NEXT. THANKS AGAIN.
PA
Parul Awasthy
The cakes and cupcakes baked by Susan are delicious!! I have ordered bday cakes for both my kids from her and cupcakes in bulk too. The treats are always yummy and beautiful. Susan gives personal attention to each of the orders and will work with you to make sure you get what you want. Will keep ordering from here!!
JI
Jill Ferson
We ordered a cake for our wedding. We had no idea what we wanted. Baked by Susan not only made a beautiful, perfect cake but it was delicious. Made with all natural incredients! Guests are still raving about it. It was the perfect size for the amount of people we had, and there was just enough left over!
JU
Judy Brunell
I visited yesterday for the first time. I was so pleased with the friendly reception and information as I was enquiring about party favor cupcakes. I also purchased cupcakes and an Irish soda bread which I enjoyed immensely for breakfast this morning.
AN
Andrew Abrams
Used Baked by Susan for our wedding cake, couldnt have asked for better service or a better cake. The decoration blew us and our guests away, we will definitely be coming back for our next sweet craving. Highly recommend!
LI
Linda Gangloff
We cant give enough stars or kudos to Baked by Susan. Our wedding cake was fantastic. EVERYONE was impressed with the design and then floored over the taste! Thank you for helping make our celebration a success.
KE
Ken Abbott
Good solid bakery. Bread, muffins, quiche and some pastries. Not world class but very good. One or two tables outside for the summer, but wish they had more. Been there a few times.. will of course go again!!!!!!!
JU
Judith Netter
Susan made the wedding cake and take home gift (cookies) for my daughters wedding. She was wonderful to work with, very creative and totally accommodating. Her baked goods are absolutely DELICIOUS!
NO
Noa L Fusco
Baked by Susan just gets better and better. Her pies, cakes and cookies are fantastic. Susan and her team are well deserving of all their awards - one being Best of Westchester bakery since 2014.
HO
Howie Myers
I cant wait until the next family birthday so I can buy another chocolate buttercream frosting cake. It is heaven - rich and creamy. Baked by Susan is the best bakery on the planet.
JE
Jennie Greer
Baked by Susan is not only an amazing bakery but a lovely shop run by the nicest ladies around. Im new to Croton and this place makes my new town already feel like home.
KA
Katie Gesue
Always fabulous for desserts and appetizers. This is our go to place for both. Plus Susan is a great supporter of the Croton community. Much appreciated!
DM
Dmitry Fridman
Susan makes terrific muffins, brownies which melt in your mouth and delicious cakes. If i go there to often i predictably start gaining pounds...
JO
Jonathan Hiller
A true asset to our community in Croton. High-quality breads, cakes and more which are reliably excellent and reasonably priced.
LO
Lori Silbert
We had Susans Key Lime Pie for my husbands birthday his favorite and it was fantastic thank you!!!!! What a great bakery
LY
lynne gobioff
We were lucky enough to get cookies from Baked by Susan - best we ever had! Great job!
KA
Kate Levin
Our wedding cake was perfect, and the bakery is charming and delightful.
DE
Dean S
The best bakery in Westchester ! Hands down, their cinabuns are amazing
LY
Lynn Farrell
Baked goods are better than homemade
RO
Robert Armati
Outstanding sweets...
NY
NY HVAC
The key lime pie!!!!
DO
Donna Pizzuti
Great key lime pie
