Brooklyn Pizza
| Address: | 2035 W Pensacola St, Tallahassee, FL 32304, USA |
| Phone: | +1 850-224-5454 |
| Site: | brooklynpizzamenu.com |
| Rating: | 3.8 |
| Working: | 11:30AM–12AM 11:30AM–12AM 11:30AM–12AM 11:30AM–12AM 11:30AM–12AM 11:30AM–12AM 11:30AM–12AM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 13
TE
Tessa Dukaj
Being from Brooklyn NY specifically the Bay Ridge area, this pizza SCREAMS Brooklyn. Everything about it is NY style. Its thin to perfection and has the best mozzarella cheese. I grew up right by a a pizzeria called Corner Pizza in Brooklyn, and Brooklyn PIzza nails all the characteristics of great NY pizza. Moving to Florida recently, theres a lot of pizza places claiming its NY style but nothing ever comes close. Majority of places dont serve slices but Brooklyn Pizza always does. You can even see your pizza being made fresh to order when you order it. The prices are great especially for a low budget. They have everyday specials that anyone will love. Every time I come in to Brooklyn Pizza its always busy therefore you know theyre doing something right! The service is always great! Its FAMILY owned so you can expect great hospitality. I highly recommend Brooklyn Pizza for a great NY pizza experience!
RO
Rose Smith
3/4/16 Ordered 2 large pies @ 11:04pm and the delivery guy came at 11:55am with the wrong order! I said its ok and 15 mins passed and he never returned. Brooklyn pizza is 2 mins from my boyfriends house. I spoke to Jennifer who stated he must of took my pies to someone else and went back to retrieve them. I said I will not take pizzas someone else had. She lied and said we will make you new ones. Upon arrival @12:20am they were the same pies that they retrieve from someone else. I was like whoa! I need a refund please. She went to speak to her manager. And hes like why they dont want the pizza and laughing. They are super unprofessional and ignorant college dope heads! Hopefully in 3 days I get my refund! I will NEVER ORDER FROM THESE PEOPLE AGAIN! Stay away please! The manager never spoke to me! So rude and nasty.
TR
tristyn be
Disclaimer: we ordered online for delivery - perhaps the eat in experience is different... We placed an order online using the system linked from their website. After an hour of waiting and no pizza, we called and found out they were having computer issues and didnt see our order until another employee searched for it. Ok, no problem - we were told our pizza would be leaving their store in 30 minutes. Another hour goes by and we still have no pizza. Call again and they say the delivery driver just left and we should be getting our pizza "in 5 minutes". 30 minutes goes by and we give up hope, only to have a cold, lifeless pizza delivered to our door. Really not worth the hassle or price if your order is going to be forgotten and a cold pizza delivered after almost 3 hours from ordering time.
RO
Roderica Johnson
I ordered a slice of supreme pizza and received a slice of pepperoni pizza with veggies thrown on top. When I called to try to figure out what happened, (see if I can get an actual slice of supreme pizza), I found out this is their practice for single slices. GROSS. Stuck with this slice, I decided to suck it up and eat what I paid for. As soon as I picked up the slice, all the toppings fell of and I was left with a cold slice of old pepperoni pizza. The only reason I gave two stars instead of one was because my wings were palatable. Im not sure if the dine in experience is different but I have no intention on ordering from them again.
DU
Dustin Stubbs
Like the pizza unfortunately the service was terrible the last time. After ordering at least 10 times in the past... the last time we called to complain. The person on the phone was very rude. They messed up on the pizza the first delivered. Then asked that we return one pizza and they would bring a new one. Who would want a returned pizza?? When I asked to speak with the owner/manager the woman was quick to tell me she was the owners wife! I quickly said we will never order from them again. A while later they called back to apologize. Customer service should be number one.
EV
Event Life, LLC
Brooklyn PIZZA is great. Brooklyn Pizza in Tallahassee needs to understand that everyone is not a drunken college kid - people will notice if you rip them off. My total check was $24 - so i tipped $5. They turned my $5 tip into a $15 tip fraudulently. I have been trying to resolve the issue with a manager but have not been successful. Unfortunately I now have filed a claim through my bank because the manager now claims that she can not find my check. We loved Brooklyn - not anymore! Watch out everyone - if this place sees an opportunity to rip you off - they will :*(
MA
Madison Ann
Read all the good reviews then went in and ordered a sub and wings. The wings were the smallest wings Ive ever seen with barely any sauce on it and the sub had a piece of chicken and cheese on it. The waiter goes "By the way we dont have a cook right now!" Well maybe you should have thought about telling us that before we sat down...They never refilled my drink and we were the only ones in there. And then they over charged me $4. I didnt realize it until I looked at my receipt later that night. NEVER GOING BACK.
KE
Kellie Ickes
Ordered a pizza to be delivered, and it never came. There was no knock on the door after the expected delivery time so we called the store and were told that their delivery call went unanswered. After deciding to forget about the pizza and take a refund, we were told we could not get a refund so we took the pizza. Paid a delivery fee to go pick up a pizza. The pizza itself was incredibly disappointing. Never again will I order pizza from Brooklyn Pizza.
RO
Robert Muriel
I literally just ate one of their "Large" Calzones in less than 5 minutes with my girlfriend. I thought it would feed the both of us because the woman there said the calzone was "MASSIVE" and "FAT" but what i got was a skinny calzone. In comparison the thing was the length and girth of a 4 year old girls arm. I highly DO NOT recommend this place based on what they gave me and the fact that I coughed up 13.00 for something that left me hungrier.
A
A Private User
Brooklyn has the best New York Style pizza in town! Their toppings are great and they have a good selection of speciality pizzas (try the spinach and feta if thats what you like). Also have incredible garlic knots and good lunch specials for slices. 2 for 1 domestic beer specials every day and good salads and subs on garlic bread. But the pizza is the best thing there!
SA
Santiago Rodriguez
Love this place. Ive been a customer for years. Their lunch specials are all week, yes, Monday through Sunday! My favorite, two large cheese slices with a drink... The owner is usually in the back making pizzas. The staff is friendly. The prices are reasonable, especially their lunch prices. Probably one of the best pizza joints in Tallahassee
MA
Mary Lynn Drifke
The people that review the pizza here have obviously never eaten pizza in NYC and their reviews dont even qualify. This was the worst pizza Ive had in Tally. The pizza was dry, no sauce, no cheese, soggy crust and flavorless. The box probably tasted better. I dont know why Three Guys From New York on Tennessee St. closed, they were the BEST!
BR
Brian Doerner
Nice local pizza place! Ate in with my daughter, her boyfriend & his family after moving them into their new apartment. Reminded me a lot of the typical New York pizzerias I grew up eating in up north. Good pie, cold beer, pleasant servers. Will definitely come back next time were in Tally to visit!
