New York Pizza
| Address: | 7800 S US Hwy 17 92, Fern Park, FL 32730, USA |
| Phone: | +1 407-830-8585 |
| Rating: | 4.6 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–10:30PM Closed |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 20
HE
Hector Pozzo
We are not from the neighborhood and saw the reviews and decided to check it out. It looked like a hole in the wall restaurant and by my experience, those are the best kind. Ill start with the Pros: It was clean and the environment was cozy and friendly. Waitress was friendly but a little dry on the personality side. We ordered the biggest cheese pizza they had along with chicken parmigans and garlic knots. The pizza crust and bottom side was nice and crisp. Thats it for the pros..We were a party of 5. Cons: The sauce on the pizza and on the chicken parmigan plate was passable but not tasteful at all! The same sauce was given to us for our garlic knots and it was just passable and very watered down. There version of garlic knots were buttered/herbed biscuits. Yes, not a typo, picture biscuit/slider buns and that was there version of garlic knots. Though they were editable it was way too thick of a biscuit and was disappointing they cant twist some dough to make knots... Overall, it was ok. The pricing is fair like others reviewed but in my opinion if your looking for a really tasteful pizza/Italian food, I would go elsewhere. If your looking for something quick and passable, this is your spot. Enjoy!
MI
Mick Fazzolare
The attention to quality is second to none. This restaurant not only impressed me with their delicious offerings, but the fact that they DONT deliver impressed me even more. They are so in tune with putting out an excellent product, they know that a delivered pizza, after traveling in some kids car for 45 minutes while waiting to be brought to your front door; you being the ninth delivery out of ten, will become a soggy steamy disc of blah. Run on sentence intentional. The pizza here is as good if not better than what youd get in any NY pizzeria. Being from the Bronx, I can attest to that fact.
AL
alie SMASH
The best calzones ever!!!! I just moved here from Canada and my husbands go to pizza was pizza hut or dominos. Mostly cicis. Whixh I dont mind. But they arnt the best. BUT NEW YORK PIZZA!!!! This place is perfect. The pizza, the toppings, the price and especially the owners give off excellence. The owners are very friendly and nice. And weve been getting our pizza fix from here ever since!!! Speaking of which, Id like to place an order! :)
S
S Fields
The Owner is a Lovely Man, Who Loves Feeding You And Cooking for You and Making Your Meal the Best... The Quality of Food is New York Pizza ....The Spaghetti Comes To Your Table with the Best Tasting Sauces of Your Choices on it ...You will Not Go Home Hungry... Home Made Garlic Knots, Wings to Die For .... This is Friendly Sit-down Service and a Big Take-Out Service Too .. My Favorite Restaurant Cons ... Guys You have to enlarge my booth .... LOL
JE
Jenny Stutts
This is both of my young sons favorite place to enjoy pizza. I have to second their taste. Its great tasting pizza for a good price and always friendly customer service. We went in for lunch for one of my sons birthdays and the owner even brought out a little tiramisu with a candle in it for him, then brought out more for the rest of the party. It was very kind and Ill never forget that. This will always be our #1 choice for pizza night.
LI
Liane Mary
The people were very friendly, but the pizza was close to tasteless. The crust needs at the very least some salt, and the sauce needs flavor, either sweet or tangy. The texture of the crust was good, and the cheese was your general generic pizza cheese. But if they just changed the crust and sauce a little bit and focused on the flavors, it could be a really solid pizza.
JA
Janine Mueller
Like a New York pizza shop. They have reopened after hurricane IRMA but bring cash. Like many, no internet so credit card machines are down. Very accomodating for a vegan meal. The dough is vegan so order veggies without meat or cheese. The owner assures the marinara is pure. No parmesan! Specify olive oil only!
LE
Leonard Matyjasik
I grew up in N.Y. and they have true traditional New York pepperoni and cheese pizza. I tried other so called NY places and none can compare. Love the Popeye that is Bianca with spinach. I like ordering extra garlic and spinach YUMMM! Their salads are really good and recommend the creamy Italian dressing.
AL
Alex Dominguez
Pizza was good but crust was a bit thick compared to NY pizza. Female server was prompt to take our order and to bring our order to the table but after that she never came by only because we called her. Calzone was big and very tasty. Food wise i will be back but the server needs a bit of training.
SC
Scented Daisies
Manager was very rude on the phone and spoke to me in a sarcastic manner just for giving them a courtesy call to cancel an order. Maybe I shouldnt have called. I can tell he is money hungry. I will never recommend that place to anyone. It deserves zero stars!!
IT
Itsa mea
This place is great, has been for years. Weve tried a lot on the menu and have never been disappointed. Staff is friendly and will talk to you if you engage them. Prices are reasonable, too. Sadly, not open on Sundays but I guess they need a day of rest, too.
KA
Kayla Melvin
Im from New York... This pizza is THE BEST pizza Ive had since I lived in Fla. I live about 40 minutes away and we make that drive once a week (like we are right now lol) to order a pie. Once I ate here, I refuse to eat pizza anywhere else in this state. ❤️
MI
Michael Shaw
Ravioli - out of this world Stuffed shells - best in Orlando area Great pizza - all variations Service - very, very good Food - great taste, always hot - even carry out all the way home Eating there for 11 years Cant go wrong ordering anything on the menu
IV
ivan bravo
1st best pizza in Central Florida, 2nd Best NY pizza style in FL. First best is Steves pizza in Miami. Great service, inexpensive and thin crust, cheese and sweet fresh tomatoes sauce. Italian owned family. A piece of NY on your plate.
CH
Charlotte Green
We have been going here since we moved here in 2012. Nothing has ever been good its always been amazing. We started out with their pizza then tried their subs and pastas. All delicious. You cant go wrong with any choice.
KE
Kevin Hayden
Best NY style pizza in Central Florida! Friendly staff and pizza always tastes good! It is a hidden gem located inside the Winn-Dixie shopping center. Ive been to NY and this pizza is just as good.
EI
Eileen White
Been coming here for over 10 years or more. Small place, good food, pizza by the slice. Best place around here that reminds me of the pizza parlors I used to go to in the Bronx years and years ago.
A
A Private User
This place has the best pizza this side of heaven. Everything tastes fresh and the prices are so cheap! This is the only place my family and I get pizza at...no where else even comes close.
RA
Raquel Murphy
Fantastic food and service. I have eaten at this pizza place for over 15 years and I travel about 15 miles each way when I want to go sit, and enjoy a little piece of Italy .
EL
Elizabeth Zerboulis
I love this Place!!! Its the first pizza place that reminds me of NY. The food (no matter what you choose) is always on point. The staff is friendly and welcoming.
