New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream

Reviews 104

RA

randy blumenschein

I ordered an Oreo flurry. For $4.50 I got an 8 oz styrofoam coffee cup of ice cream and would could have been mistaken crumbs swept off the floor at the Oreo factory. It was very disappointing. Make sure you take cash, no debit cards accepted here but make sure you tip, a little magic happens. Lol. Please, anything but styrofoam!

---

SA

Sarah Swanson

New Baltimores gem! Lines for days because their ice cream rocks, but they move quickly, so never a long wait. Just enough time to say hello to a neighbor or socialize with someone new. Great flavor choices!

---

JO

Joe Immler

Best ice cream in the area, rotating flavor list is small but mighty. The line can get long. Its cash only. I recommend parking in back, backing out of the front spot can get dicey because of the traffic.

---

NA

Nancy Torbett

Delicious ice cream served up generously at New Baltimore. Quaint outside seating. So busy. Wish their flavor selections had been larger but my strawberry cone was over the top great!

---

DA

Danielle Goddard

Been going here for around 15 years, definitely worth the drive. Generous serving sizes for less than what youd expect to pay for that amount and staff is always very friendly.

---

JE

Jessica Lowry

The line is always so long but it goes quick.great service and amazing ice cream! Just had a small black cherry and I should have gotten a large! Best homemade ice cream!

---

CO

Colleen Schlechte

Best ice cream stand in the county. Homemade ice cream piled high in a waffle cone is the way to go here, and you cant go wrong with flavors because they are all great!

---

DO

Don Malott

It was extremely bad. Its 88 degrees & the morons didnt give us napkins or a bowl to catch melting ice cream in. The idiots will never see me or my friends back. Ever.

---

JA

JASON RUNYON

Wife told me about this place when I moved up here about 10 years ago. Awesome ice cream and daily different flavors. CASH ONLY. Sizes are huge remember that!

---

KA

Kate Soehnlen

As usual, the ice cream was outstanding! I had cookie dough and chocolate in a waffle cone. Yum! Definitely worth a repeat visit. Heck, multiple visits!!! :-)

---

GU

Gustin Cleary

This is a staple home made ice cream stop for our family. My father was taken there as a child as will my children! Large portions and inexpensive.

---

CO

CompuTech 007

Cant go wrong stopping here. New Baltimore ice cream is the bomb baby! Dont bother with DQ when this place is a few minutes away from Hartville.

---

JO

Joseph Wahl

Very large servings for a good price. Flavors dont get too varied. They seem to rotate the same ones through with an occasional exceptions.

---

SH

Shelby Rogers

Excellent home made ice cream! Always a favorite! Even after moving away - its a favorite stop when we return to the area and visit family.

---

TE

Ted Pavlic

Youll be impressed that a "small" cone has something like four scoops of ice cream on top. A local favorite. Check it out if youre in town.

---

CH

Christopher Cole

Great ice cream which causes the only problem and thats long lines. Everyone wants ice cream from here. But its well worth the wait.

---

PH

Philip Zamora

The best ice cream shop around. Get a lot gr8 your money and also has a park setting behind to relax and enjoy your cone.

---

JO

Joseph Luscre

It is worth the drive to New Baltimore for the Ice Cream they serve here. Be prepared to wait in a long line when busy.

---

HA

Handy Kapped

The best Ice cream in the county. Do not pass by without trying their scrumdiddlyumptious homemade ice cream.

---

JA

Jay Lietzow

A real local treasure. Home made ice cream with all of the old time charm. A must visit when in the area.

---

CA

Catherine Allbritain

The ice cream is so awesome and there is so many flavors that you will definitely find one that you love.

---

TE

TERRY WITSAMAN

Their sugar fat free cones r soon good as is the reg. Stuff. Cone sizes r hugeeeee. Incredible value

---

DO

Douglas Klein

Been going since I was a kid and they were featured on "PM Magazine". Awesome homemade icecream!!

---

GI

Gina Holliday

Best ice cream around. Usually the line is long but worth the wait. Very generous proportions.

---

RE

Rebecca Hetrick

Very good ice cream they serve u fast orange pine apple is the best and so is chocolate almond

---

LY

Lyndsey Hartline

Peanut butter ice cream is to die for. I also love the butterscotch and coconut cream flavors

---

CY

Cynthia Landrian

Beautiful country out here. Nice little historic buildings and awesome little shops to visit!

---

RO

Roger Sommers

They make their ice cream home made in the back every week, huge portions and delicious.

---

TR

Tracy Pisani

They need to offer a bathroom. Close to there building. There ice cream was Great.

---

PA

Patty Roosa

Wonderful flavors. Ice cream made at site. More than worth the wait on busy days.

---

JE

Jennifer Wallace

Love this new place! A lot of flavors to choose from and the prices are fair :)

---

SA

Sarah Germak

Really great ice cream with generous portion sizes. I loved the turtle sundae!

---

VI

Virginia Wolfe

Ice Cream is wonderful and not expensive, but bring cash. They only take cash!

---

RA

Rachel Purpera

ice cream is good. i found a finger nail in the ice cream I was eating though.

---

AN

Andrew Monroe

They have delicious homemade ice cream. I have been going here since I was 7.

---

VI

Vicki Whittington

Blue moon the best. Just a great little hometown place to take the family.

---

SH

Shaun H

Probably one of the best places in NEO. Too bad they only accept cash.

---

JO

Joseph Caporale

Cash only. Well worth the trip from anywhere. these are Smalls

---

JA

Jayne Carr

Xbest icecream

---

CA

Carol Richardson

The best I cream around. Worth the drive from...most anywhere.

---

WA

walt ery

Great service. Kid friendly. Wide selection of great flavors.

---

RE

Renee Roudabush

excellent ice cream. been going there more than 30 years.

---

MA

Mary Ann Yoder

It was Amazing!! Peanutbutter Milkshake was spot on Man!!

---

KA

Kate ,Jennings, Wilks

We love to support our local community! Ice cream good!

---

ST

stahawkins

Amazing ice cream!!! Has been my favorite for years!

---

NO

Norma Storms

Best home made ice cream around! Great flavors too.

---

FA

Fallen .Angels

Good ice cream and big portions that is reasonable

---

AL

Alice Flanigan

Great ice cream. You will get your moneys worth.

---

EL

Elizabeth Campbell

First visit this past Saturday ... Ill be back!!

---

PE

PEARL CARR

Large portions. Great ice cream. Great prices.

---

AA

Aaron Ulbricht

Great Ice Cream. Just remember its cash only.

---

RO

Rob Pritchett

Wonderful. Even had a doggy treat for my pup.

---

TA

tamra seni

Huge amounts of ice cream for a decent price

---

CO

cory levis

Always friendly service and good ice cream.

---

DE

dennis gut

Best ice cream in portage and stark County

---

BA

Barbara Wise

Great ice cream, they were a little busy.

---

AN

Andrew Goffus

Great ice cream! Tall cones, homemade!

---

GA

Gayle Kent

Best ice cream and nicest people. Go!

---

CA

Carl Freeman

By far, the best i have ever had!!!!!!

---

TO

Tom Lloyd

Awesome ice cream and a great price.

---

PE

Pete El Guapo Royer

Superman waffle cone with eyeballs

---

ME

Melissa Wyszynski

Best ice cream in the whole world!

---

AM

Amy Stafford

Best banana split says my husband!

---

CA

Carl Merritt

Best ice cream and at a good price

---

AA

Aaron Mills

Great place with great ice cream!

---

PH

Philip Sibila

Never had a bad ice cream flavor

---

JO

Johnna Morris

Nice place good homemade icecream

---

AL

Alex Walker

Best ice cream in Northeast Ohio!

---

AL

Aleta Smithbauer

Best Ice Cream Shop in the World!

---

NA

Naisa Aziz Hridy

Their ice cream is sooo yummyyyy

---

DA

Daniel Luscomb

Ive cream not made there anymore

---

KA

Kathy Ray

Love, love, love their ice cream

---

KE

Ken Hill

Serving size is ample for price

---

GP

gpriceco price

Great place for gteat ice cream

---

DO

Don Gould

Best homemade ice cream around

---

TR

Tracy Polomsky

Yum! Worth the 600 miles drive!

---

KR

Kris Oberjohn

Great ice cream and service.

---

NA

Nancy Tucker

Love the homemade ice cream

---

BR

Brian Haueter

The perfect turtle Sunday.

---

JA

Jason Blasiman

Cheap prices, big portions

---

CO

cohon 900

The best ice cream around!

---

TI

Tina Fohl

Great homemade ice cream.

---

LI

Lisa Vincent

Best ice cream around.

---

ER

Eric Blandford

Best ice cream ever....

---

ST

stacey young

We love this place!!!!

---

BR

Bruce Martin

Best ice cream in Ohio

---

HU

Hurricane Emma

Best ice cream around!

---

MI

Mike F

Always a great place.

---

AN

Ana Maria Tolmos Baker

Best ice cream ever!

---

CH

Charity Ramey

Yum yum yum yum yum!

---

JE

Jessica Sweeney

Love this ice cream!

---

AM

Amanda Martin

Best ice cream ever!

---

EV

Evelyn Swegheimer

Great, great, Great

---

JA

Jare Ball

Great ice cream.

---

BR

Bradley Phipps

Great ice cream!

---

BR

Brad King

Great ice cream.

---

BR

Bryan LAMB Construction Specialists, LLC

Great ice cream

---

DA

Damion J Trains

Great Ice Cream

---

JO

joe pizzulo

Great ice cream

---

EL

Elizabeth Johnson

Best ice cream

---

BG

[email protected] Roadstar17

Great service

---

RO

Ron Meyer

The ice cream

---

HE

Heather Sweitzer

Wonderful!!!!

---

BR

Brett Combs

Awesome place

---

---