Sub Zero Ice Cream

73 N Ocean Ave c, Patchogue, NY 11772, USA

Address:	73 N Ocean Ave c, Patchogue, NY 11772, USA
Phone:	+1 631-307-9747
Rating:	3.1
Working:	3–10PM 3–10PM 3–10PM 3–10PM 3–10PM 3–10PM 3–10PM

Location

Photos 32

Reviews 15

Dylan Smith

My girlfriend and I went here this past weekend and came away with mixed feelings. Here are some pros & cons as well as some suggestions (if they read this). Let me preface by saying the entire reason we came here is because my girlfriend heard they can make any flavor vegan. + The product tasted great (non-vegan cream) + It was fun to watch the nitrogen spill over the counter-top Unfortunately thats about where the positives stop. - Pricey, especially given the next point - My portion was ridiculously small - I ordered a medium ("regular") and my small bowl was half-filled, I mean literally to about the half way point of the height of the cup. This was a $6.00 cup of ice cream (granted I had one add-on worth $.75) and I received maybe 4 ounces. I do not know if this is just the way they portion their product, or if the young man who made mine just misjudged how much he needed. If this can be chalked up to him learning, I am fine with that. - My girlfriend was disappointed with the vegan cream - it had an extremely overpowering coconut flavor. I understand they are using coconut milk for this, but I find it hard to believe that any bowl with the vegan cream will taste like anything other than coconut. Additionally, it was not mixed well - there were chunks of condensed coconut milk in her ice cream. - The last point is that no one was happy - the atmosphere simply sucked. This is supposed to be a fun place and it just wasnt. Some background music would probably go along way, as the long line waited in silence while the three workers made the ice cream to order.

Jason Soler

The variety of flavors and the pure genius, it takes to make a good ice cream shop. Not only will you be blown away by the method they use to make the ice cream (yes, I said make the ice cream... They make the cream into "iced cream" right in front of you within 30 seconds!!!) But you will LOVE and I mean LOVE the taste. There has never been a more creamy ice cream in existence! They also serve alcohol infused ice cream. I had the bourbon chocolate something... Cant remember the name. But the girl recommended it. It was Fantastic. I could taste the slight Jim Bean flavor mixed flawlessly with the chocolate. Definitely worth it! Lastly they offer Military, Police, and Fire discount!! So be sure to ask! Only reason I give it 4 stars?? They dont have a sugar free version. They have a LOW GI but not sugar free... As an avid fitness and gym buff, I count all my macros. Even their vegan base (dairy free) has 19g of carbohydrates and 14 of those being sugar. Aside from that?? OMG. Please go here and try it out!

Christopher Tricarico

This place is great! Its unique and reminds me of a craft beer bar. I love trying new flavors and watching the science behind the whole creation. The staff is great too. Not everyone is going to love every flavor, but in the end, youre eating ice cream! Customers get to create their own flavors, so if you dont like the taste, get over it! Its still ice cream, so how can it be bad?! The same base ingredients go into the ice cream, but coconut milk settles differently than while milk. Its the chemical structure behind it, yet some customers dont seem to want to understand that. Its sad that some people just like to find something to complain about because they dont understand it. Not being cookie cutter is a good thing! Overall, this is the smoothest, most delicious ice cream Ive had.

Joe Barilla

I would love to give 4 starts for how good the ice cream was but here is my problem Dont advertise you are open at a time when you are not. Went in TWICE when their personal site and google says they open at a time and they are not!!! The final attempted visit they were open and I went in. The ice cream was great but the staff were screaming yelling laughing amongst them selves ignoring me waiting right along the counter to order. So the ice cream itself was yummy but the service not so good. Also, atmosphere was lacking and only 2 tables I couldnt sit and enjoy my ice cream had to sit in my car

James Faulkner

Staff was very nice, patient, and helpful. Really cool twist on traditional ice cream. A couple of cons: 1. Boring atmosphere...throw some music on at least. The line of chairs by the window makes it feel like a waiting room. 2. You guys definitely need tables. It was an adventure with little kids and no table. 3. Stock... Some ingredients from 2 different Sensations were out of stock (brownies, cookie dough, and peanut butter cups) but luckily the staff was quick on their toes and came up with good alternatives.

ken green

Awful and overpriced! Selected chocolate cinnamon. Unheard of amount of xinam5. The person making it reason the recipe while making it then added additional cinnamon. Burned my throat literally! Informed the cashier and the response was, "sorry." No attempt to male it right. So we walked out. Learning experience cost $6.00 for a small cup, no less! Pricey lesson. If you have kids dont let them eat it unless you taste it yourself first to see if its edible. And if not, its your loss!

Hailee Reilly

I wish I could give less than one star, but sadly I cannot. Their website and their doors said theyre open until 10pm on Saturday and they had the doors locked at 8:45pm, and there was people in the store. In my opinion thats just wrong and they should stay open until the time they are listed to. Because of this, I will not be returning to this place.

James Doutney

They mix and freeze the ice cream right there in front of you which is really cool to watch. They staff was friendly and they have a wide variety of flavors and toppings. I was able to get lactose free ice cream with all the toppings I wanted in a waffle cone bowl and it was delicious. I will definitely be coming back to this ice cream shop again!

Sam S

Great ice cream super creamy was really happy I was disappointed in the manger of the place as they let there friend come in the back make there own ice cream with out any proper training. They stated that it is a liability issue if customers or non train people come in the back. Other wise great place

Matthew Siegelbaum

Awesomeness! Ice cream made with liquid nitrogen. Fascinating! Its really good too. The kids will love watching the staff make their ice cream concoctions from scratch, right in front of you. Surprisingly reasonable. Huge portions!

Katherine Y

This place is great! Servers are friendly, the making of the ice cream is fun and it is delicious! So creamy and yummy! Many flavors and to choose from! Awesome place!

Sean Milligan

Very cool experience to see the smoke from the liquid nitrogen cover he counter as hey make your ice cream! There are cheap and mid-range price options

JoAnn Termini-Pira

Special experience to see how its made. Priced a little high but delicious and enjoyed the show. Not every day you see a shop like that. We enjoyed!

ylb6490

Came here to try the alcohol infused ice cream. Pretty neat to see the ice cream being made in front of ya. It tasted awesome

Laura Giannakopoulos

Went there doors say 10 . Place was close at 930? . Please dont post a time that you are not serving till.