Pizza Parm
| Address: | 591 Main St, Islip, NY 11751, USA |
| Phone: | +1 631-581-9500 |
| Site: | pizzaparmislip.com |
| Rating: | 3.2 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 12–9PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 23
GE
gen bly
Disappointed... The 1st hero I ordered was fantastic. I was thrilled that it was on delicious garlic bread, had the perfect amount of sauce and chicken was flavorful. The 2nd hero I could not even eat. The meatballs had a very strange taste and smell, which may or may not, have been some very strong smelling & tasting cheese??? The meatballs were very under-cooked, very pink in the middle. Very skimpy on the sauce. At least the garlic bread it was on was tasty. The 3rd hero ordered, eggplant parm, was yet again another disappointment. Barley any sauce at all, and the garlic bread had no taste.
PA
Pat Mahr
Tried it the first and last time. I wanted to try it. I am a loyal Angelas customer. Order 2 meals myself a chicken parm. And for my love a penne Ala vodka. Chicken parm if thats what u call it. Was like eating tire rubber. I couldnt finish it. The salad was good! My loves penne was under cooked, dry and funny textured. The delivery driver couldnt find my house. Funny thing is, Im the only house on the block. Go figure. So I tried it and wont recommend it. The owners other establishments are second to none. But this place doesnt cut it.
KI
Kiera Javino
I just got home from pizza parm and I was really excited to try this place. Ive heard a few of my friends have tried it and liked it. So I decided to try it with my friend. We ordered a Sicilian Slice and penne, I will be honest both had no taste and the pasta felt like I was eating rubber. We were very disappointed with our experience.. I think the best thing they have there is the phone charging stations and the soda machine.
MA
Marc Withac
Your pizza is worse than Little Caesars, please move out of Islip so I dont have to make this mistake again, Also.. I thought when I read "free delivery" on the website it meant I wouldnt see a $2 charge for delivery on my bill. Also I only gave you one star because they didnt have a 1-5 mule scale. If they did I would have given them 3 1/2 .
MI
Michelle Rothbart
Gotta a chicken Caesar wrap. Chicken was rubber and the lettuce tasted dirty. Had way too much dressing the wrap was soggy. I guess to hide the dirty lettuce taste?
DA
Dan Hayden
This place rocks! Good food, plenty of space, music, tvs, a phone charging station, good window views, a new soda machine, beer, I can go on!
MR
MrThegang1
The place is smelling a little funky I think its time to change the cleaning products . We came in the back door by the bathrooms
MI
Michael DiCarlo
Just received our delivery. Pizza and fried ravioli were very good. Delivery came faster than expected. Great Job pizza parm
CH
Charles Bernhardt
Veal Parm Hero~ Very little veal and sauce. Tuff Veal dried out. Pizza Extra Cheese no flavor And thats how you learn.
JU
Justin
Great specials mon to thurs, food has been very good. We ordered there a few times, Has been very consistent
BE
bennie knight
Pizza was burned and took forever. Cashier practically threw change at me...
BR
Bryan Zagardo
Worse than Pizza Hut but almost better than 711 pizza.
KE
Kenny Bonilla
Wow 7 11 meatball heros are better then this place
TH
Thatrandomguy
Probably the worst pizza place on Long Island.
JO
Joshua Velez
love the pizza and the staff is wonderful
TO
Tom Leary
Awesome. Salad Pie is to die for.
CH
Christopher Bryan
Needs more white slices
BR
brendan butler
Great service and pizza
RO
Rosa Lloyd
Great pizza please
L
L Percoco
New favorite place
DA
dagoncore
Delicious pizza!
FR
Frank Giuliano
Great place
JA
Jay Halliday
Yup
