Holy Tomato Too

48 N Main St, Mullica Hill, NJ 08062, USA

Address:	48 N Main St, Mullica Hill, NJ 08062, USA
Phone:	+1 856-417-3749
Site:	holytomatotoo.com
Rating:	4.4
Working:	3:30–9PM 3:30–9PM 3:30–9PM 3:30–9PM 3:30–10PM 3:30–10PM 3:30–9PM

Location

Photos 1

Reviews 22

Bert Zahniser

Most restaurant issues can be overcome through good waitress communication and an attentive owner. Unfortunately neither occurred on this visit. Ordered 2 pizzas- first came out 55 minutes after arrival, and the second was 20 minutes later. The owner who was visible in the serving area throughout the night finally stopped by as we were finishing, and blamed the delay on another irate customer. The food was still decent, but 90+ minutes for a meal at a pizza joint is too long.

Vincent Ferriola

INCREDIBLE! The staff is very friendly and welcoming. This place is adorable, a home converted into a pizza place. Very charming and quaint. There is upstairs seating for 7+ groups. Outdoor seating too. The pizzas are huge, 18"/19" sized deliciousness. Pizza is thin crust and definitely the best thin crust pizza I have EVER had. I will travel from Philly back to Mullica HIll just for this pizza. You will not be disappointed.

Jennifer Duerden

Not only was the food absolutely above and beyond good ( we had the house salad and original pizza washed down with tasty raspberry lemonade ) but the owner and his family made the experience complete! Charming and briming with character, I cant wait to go back!!!!

Joan Evans

Friendly place. Pizza has good consistent taste, thin crust, good salads. Do not think owner is cocky, just a friendly guy that someone mistook his demeanor. We go . So far they are doing great. Home town pizza with a twist

DeAnn Law

The pizza is excellent, thin crispy and huge!! The salad was fresh and delicious. We tried the cheesecake with the funny name (soup-something) and it was unbelievable. This place was a home run. Will definitely be back.

Eric Bruner

Holy Tomato this place is great!!! I just drove an hour and ten minutes to eat here. Well worth the drive. We had the Chicago, Margarita, Red and an original. They were all great! Highly recommended.

Michael Dickson

Not sure if this a copy of the "holy tomato" in Blackwood . It has a similar feel. It was good. Bottom of the pizza was a little burnt . It will take another visit to see if it can make it 5 star.

Mongo JT

By far the worse pizza Ive ever had. Tried the margarita pizza. The crust was burnt and the cheese was sparce across the pie. For the price of $21we wont be coming back

Javier Rapoport

Really liked their pizza. It gets busy, so wait times can be long (even for take out), but I realized its worth the wait! And to top it off, prices are very reasonable!

Eric Stanwood

Love this place!! Great salads, pizza, dessert, and more! Now serving local (Villari) wine. Soon to be their tasting room in the carriage House.

Dave Baionno

Awesome, best pizza place in the tri state area. Marry Ellen keeps the place together and Troy is a great owner..

Stephanie Senetra

Its our favorite Thursday night dinner spot! Food is delicious, friendly staff and one of a kind decor!

Crystal Allen

Limited, but delicious menu. Friendly staff and owners, pizza made fresh. Great, funky decor.

Philip Vasta

The owner was extremely nice and really explained the dishes. The food was excellent, too.

Stephen Ferzetti

Nice decor, AMAZING pizza, great staff, delicious(but somewhat small) key lime pie