Cape May Peanut Butter Co.
| Address: | 516 Carpenters Ln, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA |
| Phone: | +1 609-898-4444 |
| Site: | capemaypeanutbutterco.com |
| Rating: | 4.8 |
| Working: | 10AM–6PM Closed Closed 10AM–6PM 10AM–7PM 10AM–7PM 10AM–6PM |
Location
Photos 20
Reviews 46
CJ
CJ Waasdorp
Lots of interesting specialty flavors of homemade peanut butter that were tasty. I thought the sandwiches were pricy but would be worth it. Instead I got an unspread blob of plain peanut butter (not the one I ordered) on stale white bread (ordered multigrain) with old bacon. Unexpectedly disappointed. Honestly, buying a fresh loaf of white bread for 2$ would have made the sandwich half as disappointing, sell more sandwiches and make its return on the first sandwich sold.
TO
Tom Boward
This place is amazing. The whole store is a shrine to Peanut Butter and they feature flavors such as Chocolate, Marshmallow, Honey Nut, etc. There are all sorts of peanut butter goodies to go with your purchase as well and there are free samples to boot. When you go there, know that the peanut butter they sell is genuine fresh ground. It tastes different from Skippy. Its not a bad thing, just be prepared for a surprise if youve never had real peanut butter before.
MA
Mark Silber
They begin with an excellent quality full flavored peanut roasted perfectly, then add some interesting and wholesome flavors at a very fair price given its seasonal location where most merchants need to, and do, gouge the tourists. Hazelnut, honey roasted, and plain are my favorites. I like them so much, Ill be mail ordering come fall.
LI
Liam Kinnon
So many peanut butter options, and they all taste like real peanut butter. You can sample them all. We bought the choco peanut butter. Which is a peanut Nutella on steroids. So good! Almost managed to just buy that until I saw a giant bacon peanut butter cup near the cash. I had to have that too and it was delicious!
ME
Mercedes Jennings
I hate peanut butter, but the peanut butter here is actually nice. Dont get me wrong, I still cant eat any of them regularly, but theyre doing something right if I can tolerate them. The staff usually lets you do your own thing, but some of them are very pushy. Overall, a cute little shop thats worth a visit.
SU
Susan Schaeffer
I love this peanut butter I have bought every kind.I especially like the chocolate,regular peanut and the cashew.The products are great I have even started ordering on line but when ever I get to cape may this is one of my stops.I love the scones and always get the treats for our dog he knows the package now.
KR
Kristen Fricke
Great selection of items, bakery items are delish! I always stop for some peanut butter pretzels covered in chocolate, a family favorite! You can sample all their nut butters, lots to choose from. They have drinks and sandwiches too. Definitely stop here if you know a chocolate or peanut lover!
MA
Matthew Failla
Best peanut butter Ive ever had. I make sure every time I visit Cape May that I go home with the big jar of the honesty roasted peanut butter. Its freshly made upstairs and you can smell it as soon as you walk in. Event their peanut butter cups are incredible. Very friendly staff too.
ST
Stephen Luke
From the samples of unique peanut butter to the excellent staff, the Cape May Peanut Butter Company should be a must-see stop for any shopper in the area. They also have cookies, teas, and a small menu of peanut butter sandwiches that are perfect for lunch or as a quick snack.
LA
larry bulay
Great homemade peanut butter I didnt give it 5 Stars its a little tight inside ..This store is behind the mall where the meta parking is at . they have samples of their peanut butter before buying any but a must try is the hot chocolate with the peanut butter mousse in it yum.
MA
Maria Viktorovna
Everything is delicious! You ca have unlimited samples of different peanut butters, cashew, hazelnut. Extremely good. Their teas and cookies are also really good. They have website and they ship it.
BR
Bradley Luchene
Vast array of nut butters to sample. The nut nutters are pricey but that is to be expected at a specialty shop. The sandwiches are very overpriced (i.e. >$5 for a peanut butter and banana sandwich).
VA
Valerie Walter
This place is dangerous! So many amazing, tasty things! You can try all their peanut butters before buying, which is nice. They also have different flavored iced teas which are delicious.
CH
Chris Bush
Definitely the best to get ANYTHING peanut butter...even things you would never have thought of!!!! And dont forget to get the puppy you left at home some yummy peanut butter biscuits!!!
JI
Jim Heesacker
This is a must stop. All sorts of amazing delights ranging from butterscotch PB to cookies to PB marshmallow mix in a mustard looking container. Pricing is also very fair.
GL
GLItch MASter
Every nut better they make here is great. The people that work here a very nice and love their customers. Every time I come to cape May this is my first stop no matter what.
AL
Alexa McBee
This is my favorite shop in cape may. The ladies are so nice and helpful and they let you sample anything before you buy it. The butterscotch peanut butter is heavily!!!
MY
Myranda Shimko
Adorable shop with friendly staff. Lots of different peanut butter samples to try as well as preserves, and fresh brewed teas . Perfect place to pick up some pb&j!
ER
Eric Callahan
This place is a gem ! I love the peanut butter and they even have healthy treats for my dog ! I cant wait to come back and try some more !
ST
STEPHANIE BENNETT
If you love peanut butter then you will love this place. There are many different flavors to try and thr staff is super friendly and helpful
RE
Regina Jaslow
Lots of selection such as butterscotch, chocolate, honey roasted peanut butter and also others such as sunflower seed or almond butter.
NO
Norma Cordeiro
I love the the natural nut butters, beverages and sitting in the back terrace garden with my goodies. I love, love love this place.
MA
Maria Melachrinos-Dunbar
Fresh peanut butter and almond butter samples. Cookies are okay. Enormous peanut butter cups are awesome although not their own.
JA
James Carmine
Excellent customer service. Friendly and knowledgeable. Free samples and very fair prices for quality products.
DA
David Mitchell
Awesome place. Make sure to try the peanut butter samples. We got the Happy Camper to share. So good.
MA
Malka Gonzalez
This place is like HEAVEN for peanut butter lovers.. loved the variety and the free samples yumm yumm
CH
Christian Trotta
This place is amazing! HIGHLY recommend! The King Sandwich with bacon is EPIC! Have it waffled!
PA
Paul Traill
Cool little store. The chocolate hazzlenut peanut butter has made my pregnant wife very happy!
MA
Matt Davis
Great peanut butter selections, especially enjoy the butterscotch. Lots of homemade options.
SU
Susan W
Yum! Many kinds of peanut butters plus other goodies and peanut butter bones for your dogs!
PA
Paul Domenick
Loved working for the spatacco family. Great family, great business, great product 10/10
MA
Marjorie Oquendo-Pai
Best Peanut Butter, Ive been ordering it ever since my first taste back in December 15.
AS
Asha C. Beh
Excellent service and super friendly staff who welcome you like family to the store.
ME
Mehul Vora
Amazing experience with sampling the different peanut butter and the beer jellies!
ST
Steve Adamson
Fav place to visit when we go to cape may every year. Love peanut butter
MA
Marie-Laurence Roch Matte
Good surprise! We tasted a lot of samples to choose the best products !
BO
Borrelli Valentino
Great variety of different flavored peanut butter and they have drinks.
JO
Jody Bollinger
Employees were great. If you love PB, gotta check this place out
CH
Christopher George
Delicious flavors of peanut butter, along with cookies and jams.
RO
Rob Czarneski
More than just peanut butter... Cool place. Nice surprise...
JO
John Murphy
Cappuccino peanut butter!! What more do you need to know..
CR
Craig White
Had the King...... Loved it...... Will be back every year
MI
michael powers
Alot of varieties of peanut butter. Friendly staff.
AN
Andrew Pross
Home made peanut butter what more do I have to say!
NI
Nicole Husson
Yum af.
MI
Michele Haines
Great peanut butter. Nothing else to see there.
